A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial
BackgroundPsychosocial, self-guided, internet-based programs are effective in treating depression and anxiety. However, the community uptake of these programs is poor. Recent approaches to increasing engagement (defined as both uptake and adherence) in internet-based programs...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
JMIR Publications
2021-07-01
|
| Series: | Journal of Medical Internet Research |
| Online Access: | https://www.jmir.org/2021/7/e23029 |
| _version_ | 1797735844459577344 |
|---|---|
| author | Philip J Batterham Alison L Calear Matthew Sunderland Frances Kay-Lambkin Louise M Farrer Helen Christensen Amelia Gulliver |
| author_facet | Philip J Batterham Alison L Calear Matthew Sunderland Frances Kay-Lambkin Louise M Farrer Helen Christensen Amelia Gulliver |
| author_sort | Philip J Batterham |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description |
BackgroundPsychosocial, self-guided, internet-based programs are effective in treating depression and anxiety. However, the community uptake of these programs is poor. Recent approaches to increasing engagement (defined as both uptake and adherence) in internet-based programs include brief engagement facilitation interventions (EFIs). However, these programs require evaluation to assess their efficacy.
ObjectiveThe aims of this hybrid implementation effectiveness trial are to examine the effects of a brief internet-based EFI presented before an internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy self-help program (myCompass 2) in improving engagement (uptake and adherence) with that program (primary aim), assess the relative efficacy of the myCompass 2 program, and determine whether greater engagement was associated with improved efficacy (greater reduction in depression or anxiety symptoms) relative to the control (secondary aim).
MethodsA 3-arm randomized controlled trial (N=849; recruited via social media) assessed the independent efficacy of the EFI and myCompass 2. The myCompass 2 program was delivered with or without the EFI; both conditions were compared with an attention control condition. The EFI comprised brief (5 minutes), tailored audio-visual content on a series of click-through linear webpages.
ResultsUptake was high in all groups; 82.8% (703/849) of participants clicked through the intervention following the pretest survey. However, the difference in uptake between the EFI + myCompass 2 condition (234/280, 83.6%) and the myCompass 2 alone condition (222/285, 77.9%) was not significant (n=565; χ21=29.2; P=.09). In addition, there was no significant difference in the proportion of participants who started any number of modules (1-14 modules) versus those who started none between the EFI + myCompass 2 (214/565, 37.9%) and the myCompass 2 alone (210/565, 37.2%) conditions (n=565; χ21<0.1; P=.87). Finally, there was no significant difference between the EFI + myCompass 2 and the myCompass 2 alone conditions in the number of modules started (U=39366.50; z=−0.32; P=.75) or completed (U=39494.0; z=−0.29; P=.77). The myCompass 2 program was not found to be efficacious over time for symptoms of depression (F4,349.97=1.16; P=.33) or anxiety (F4,445.99=0.12; P=.98). However, planned contrasts suggested that myCompass 2 may have been effective for participants with elevated generalized anxiety disorder symptoms (F4,332.80=3.50; P=.01).
ConclusionsThis brief internet-based EFI did not increase the uptake of or adherence to an existing internet-based program for depression and anxiety. Individuals’ motivation to initiate and complete internet-based self-guided interventions is complex and remains a significant challenge for self-guided interventions.
Trial RegistrationAustralian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12618001565235; https://www.anzctr.org.au/Trial/Registration/TrialReview.aspx?id=375839 |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-12T13:04:00Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-00119be9e9854f7ebb86426443517dc7 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1438-8871 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-12T13:04:00Z |
| publishDate | 2021-07-01 |
| publisher | JMIR Publications |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Journal of Medical Internet Research |
| spelling | doaj.art-00119be9e9854f7ebb86426443517dc72023-08-28T17:08:57ZengJMIR PublicationsJournal of Medical Internet Research1438-88712021-07-01237e2302910.2196/23029A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled TrialPhilip J Batterhamhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-4547-6876Alison L Calearhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-7028-725XMatthew Sunderlandhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-8452-364XFrances Kay-Lambkinhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-4252-5572Louise M Farrerhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-5694-4631Helen Christensenhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-0435-2065Amelia Gulliverhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6351-9844 BackgroundPsychosocial, self-guided, internet-based programs are effective in treating depression and anxiety. However, the community uptake of these programs is poor. Recent approaches to increasing engagement (defined as both uptake and adherence) in internet-based programs include brief engagement facilitation interventions (EFIs). However, these programs require evaluation to assess their efficacy. ObjectiveThe aims of this hybrid implementation effectiveness trial are to examine the effects of a brief internet-based EFI presented before an internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy self-help program (myCompass 2) in improving engagement (uptake and adherence) with that program (primary aim), assess the relative efficacy of the myCompass 2 program, and determine whether greater engagement was associated with improved efficacy (greater reduction in depression or anxiety symptoms) relative to the control (secondary aim). MethodsA 3-arm randomized controlled trial (N=849; recruited via social media) assessed the independent efficacy of the EFI and myCompass 2. The myCompass 2 program was delivered with or without the EFI; both conditions were compared with an attention control condition. The EFI comprised brief (5 minutes), tailored audio-visual content on a series of click-through linear webpages. ResultsUptake was high in all groups; 82.8% (703/849) of participants clicked through the intervention following the pretest survey. However, the difference in uptake between the EFI + myCompass 2 condition (234/280, 83.6%) and the myCompass 2 alone condition (222/285, 77.9%) was not significant (n=565; χ21=29.2; P=.09). In addition, there was no significant difference in the proportion of participants who started any number of modules (1-14 modules) versus those who started none between the EFI + myCompass 2 (214/565, 37.9%) and the myCompass 2 alone (210/565, 37.2%) conditions (n=565; χ21<0.1; P=.87). Finally, there was no significant difference between the EFI + myCompass 2 and the myCompass 2 alone conditions in the number of modules started (U=39366.50; z=−0.32; P=.75) or completed (U=39494.0; z=−0.29; P=.77). The myCompass 2 program was not found to be efficacious over time for symptoms of depression (F4,349.97=1.16; P=.33) or anxiety (F4,445.99=0.12; P=.98). However, planned contrasts suggested that myCompass 2 may have been effective for participants with elevated generalized anxiety disorder symptoms (F4,332.80=3.50; P=.01). ConclusionsThis brief internet-based EFI did not increase the uptake of or adherence to an existing internet-based program for depression and anxiety. Individuals’ motivation to initiate and complete internet-based self-guided interventions is complex and remains a significant challenge for self-guided interventions. Trial RegistrationAustralian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12618001565235; https://www.anzctr.org.au/Trial/Registration/TrialReview.aspx?id=375839https://www.jmir.org/2021/7/e23029 |
| spellingShingle | Philip J Batterham Alison L Calear Matthew Sunderland Frances Kay-Lambkin Louise M Farrer Helen Christensen Amelia Gulliver A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial Journal of Medical Internet Research |
| title | A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial |
| title_full | A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial |
| title_fullStr | A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial |
| title_full_unstemmed | A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial |
| title_short | A Brief Intervention to Increase Uptake and Adherence of an Internet-Based Program for Depression and Anxiety (Enhancing Engagement With Psychosocial Interventions): Randomized Controlled Trial |
| title_sort | brief intervention to increase uptake and adherence of an internet based program for depression and anxiety enhancing engagement with psychosocial interventions randomized controlled trial |
| url | https://www.jmir.org/2021/7/e23029 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT philipjbatterham abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT alisonlcalear abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT matthewsunderland abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT franceskaylambkin abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT louisemfarrer abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT helenchristensen abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT ameliagulliver abriefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT philipjbatterham briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT alisonlcalear briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT matthewsunderland briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT franceskaylambkin briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT louisemfarrer briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT helenchristensen briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial AT ameliagulliver briefinterventiontoincreaseuptakeandadherenceofaninternetbasedprogramfordepressionandanxietyenhancingengagementwithpsychosocialinterventionsrandomizedcontrolledtrial |