Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy
This work aimed to identify clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) that include recommendations for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of women’s malnutrition during pregnancy and to evaluate the quality of these guidelines using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II)...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
MDPI AG
2022-11-01
|
| Series: | Nutrients |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/14/21/4579 |
| _version_ | 1797466863982084096 |
|---|---|
| author | Cinthya Muñoz-Manrique Mónica Ancira-Moreno Soraya Burrola-Méndez Isabel Omaña-Guzmán Elizabeth Hoyos-Loya Sonia Hernández-Cordero Alejandra Trejo-Domínguez Mónica Mazariegos Natalia Smith Scarlett Alonso-Carmona Jennifer Mier-Cabrera Loredana Tavano-Colaizzi Belén Sánchez-Múzquiz Fermín Avendaño-Álvarez Karla Muciño-Sandoval Nadia C. Rodríguez-Moguel Magali Padilla-Camacho Salvador Espino-y-Sosa Lizeth Ibarra-González Cristina Medina-Avilés |
| author_facet | Cinthya Muñoz-Manrique Mónica Ancira-Moreno Soraya Burrola-Méndez Isabel Omaña-Guzmán Elizabeth Hoyos-Loya Sonia Hernández-Cordero Alejandra Trejo-Domínguez Mónica Mazariegos Natalia Smith Scarlett Alonso-Carmona Jennifer Mier-Cabrera Loredana Tavano-Colaizzi Belén Sánchez-Múzquiz Fermín Avendaño-Álvarez Karla Muciño-Sandoval Nadia C. Rodríguez-Moguel Magali Padilla-Camacho Salvador Espino-y-Sosa Lizeth Ibarra-González Cristina Medina-Avilés |
| author_sort | Cinthya Muñoz-Manrique |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | This work aimed to identify clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) that include recommendations for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of women’s malnutrition during pregnancy and to evaluate the quality of these guidelines using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) instrument. We conducted a literature review using PubMed and different websites from January 2009 to February 2021. The quality of the CPGs was independently assessed by reviewers using the AGREE II instrument, which defines guidelines scoring >70% in the overall assessment as “high quality”. The analysis included 43 guidelines. Among the main findings, we identified that only half of the CPGs (51.1%) obtained a final “high quality” evaluation. AGREE II results varied widely across domains and categories. The two domains that obtained the highest scores were scope and purpose with 88.3% (range 39 to 100%) and clarity of presentation with 87.2% (range 25 to 100%). Among the “high quality” CPGs, the best scores were achieved by the three guidelines published by the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the World Health Organization (WHO). Due to the importance of maternal nutrition in pregnancy, it is essential to join forces to improve the quality of the guidelines, especially in CPGs that do not meet the reference standards for quality. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-09T18:45:42Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-0f65a53a3c874bb0afd2d1cf9122fd5a |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2072-6643 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-09T18:45:42Z |
| publishDate | 2022-11-01 |
| publisher | MDPI AG |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Nutrients |
| spelling | doaj.art-0f65a53a3c874bb0afd2d1cf9122fd5a2023-11-24T06:13:49ZengMDPI AGNutrients2072-66432022-11-011421457910.3390/nu14214579Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during PregnancyCinthya Muñoz-Manrique0Mónica Ancira-Moreno1Soraya Burrola-Méndez2Isabel Omaña-Guzmán3Elizabeth Hoyos-Loya4Sonia Hernández-Cordero5Alejandra Trejo-Domínguez6Mónica Mazariegos7Natalia Smith8Scarlett Alonso-Carmona9Jennifer Mier-Cabrera10Loredana Tavano-Colaizzi11Belén Sánchez-Múzquiz12Fermín Avendaño-Álvarez13Karla Muciño-Sandoval14Nadia C. Rodríguez-Moguel15Magali Padilla-Camacho16Salvador Espino-y-Sosa17Lizeth Ibarra-González18Cristina Medina-Avilés19Health Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoMaternal and Child Health and Nutrition Network (MaCHiNNe), Observatorio Materno Infantil (OMI), Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoMaternal and Child Health and Nutrition Network (MaCHiNNe), Observatorio Materno Infantil (OMI), Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoDepartment of Pediatrics, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA 94143, USAHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoMaternal and Child Health and Nutrition Network (MaCHiNNe), Observatorio Materno Infantil (OMI), Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoMaternal and Child Health and Nutrition Network (MaCHiNNe), Observatorio Materno Infantil (OMI), Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoHealth Department, Universidad Iberoamericana, Prolongación Paseo de Reforma 880, Lomas de Santa Fe, Mexico City 01219, MexicoThis work aimed to identify clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) that include recommendations for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of women’s malnutrition during pregnancy and to evaluate the quality of these guidelines using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) instrument. We conducted a literature review using PubMed and different websites from January 2009 to February 2021. The quality of the CPGs was independently assessed by reviewers using the AGREE II instrument, which defines guidelines scoring >70% in the overall assessment as “high quality”. The analysis included 43 guidelines. Among the main findings, we identified that only half of the CPGs (51.1%) obtained a final “high quality” evaluation. AGREE II results varied widely across domains and categories. The two domains that obtained the highest scores were scope and purpose with 88.3% (range 39 to 100%) and clarity of presentation with 87.2% (range 25 to 100%). Among the “high quality” CPGs, the best scores were achieved by the three guidelines published by the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the World Health Organization (WHO). Due to the importance of maternal nutrition in pregnancy, it is essential to join forces to improve the quality of the guidelines, especially in CPGs that do not meet the reference standards for quality.https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/14/21/4579AGREE IIclinical practice guidelinespregnancyhealthy pregnancymalnutrition |
| spellingShingle | Cinthya Muñoz-Manrique Mónica Ancira-Moreno Soraya Burrola-Méndez Isabel Omaña-Guzmán Elizabeth Hoyos-Loya Sonia Hernández-Cordero Alejandra Trejo-Domínguez Mónica Mazariegos Natalia Smith Scarlett Alonso-Carmona Jennifer Mier-Cabrera Loredana Tavano-Colaizzi Belén Sánchez-Múzquiz Fermín Avendaño-Álvarez Karla Muciño-Sandoval Nadia C. Rodríguez-Moguel Magali Padilla-Camacho Salvador Espino-y-Sosa Lizeth Ibarra-González Cristina Medina-Avilés Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy Nutrients AGREE II clinical practice guidelines pregnancy healthy pregnancy malnutrition |
| title | Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy |
| title_full | Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy |
| title_fullStr | Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy |
| title_full_unstemmed | Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy |
| title_short | Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy |
| title_sort | quality appraisal of nutritional guidelines to prevent diagnose and treat malnutrition in all its forms during pregnancy |
| topic | AGREE II clinical practice guidelines pregnancy healthy pregnancy malnutrition |
| url | https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/14/21/4579 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT cinthyamunozmanrique qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT monicaanciramoreno qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT sorayaburrolamendez qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT isabelomanaguzman qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT elizabethhoyosloya qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT soniahernandezcordero qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT alejandratrejodominguez qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT monicamazariegos qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT nataliasmith qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT scarlettalonsocarmona qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT jennifermiercabrera qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT loredanatavanocolaizzi qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT belensanchezmuzquiz qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT ferminavendanoalvarez qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT karlamucinosandoval qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT nadiacrodriguezmoguel qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT magalipadillacamacho qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT salvadorespinoysosa qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT lizethibarragonzalez qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy AT cristinamedinaaviles qualityappraisalofnutritionalguidelinestopreventdiagnoseandtreatmalnutritioninallitsformsduringpregnancy |