Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia
Introduction: The large number of people affected by dementia diseases poses major challenges for public health, healthcare services and healthcare service providers. The Western health policy of ageing in place rests on a triad collaboration among patients, healthcare service providers and family c...
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Ubiquity Press
2019-08-01
|
| Series: | International Journal of Integrated Care |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.ijic.org/articles/4891 |
| _version_ | 1818056695484514304 |
|---|---|
| author | Lill Sverresdatter Larsen Bodil Hansen Blix Torunn Hamran |
| author_facet | Lill Sverresdatter Larsen Bodil Hansen Blix Torunn Hamran |
| author_sort | Lill Sverresdatter Larsen |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Introduction: The large number of people affected by dementia diseases poses major challenges for public health, healthcare services and healthcare service providers. The Western health policy of ageing in place rests on a triad collaboration among patients, healthcare service providers and family caregivers. Such collaborations presuppose involvement in and influence on a vague juridical landscape. Several researchers have stated the need for knowledge about decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia. The research question of this study is as follows: How do family caregivers experience involvement in and influence on the nursing home decision-making process for persons with dementia? Theory/Methods: The data consist of twelve in-depth interviews with family caregivers to persons with dementia. By the use of positioning theory, we demonstrate how family caregivers strive to balance their assumed duty to take care of the person with their needs to take care of themselves. Results: The family caregivers involvement (or non-involvement) in the complex decision-making process is demonstrated through seven positions: 1) the self-condemning determiner, 2) the dominant, 3) the proponent, 4) the saluting, 5) the pending, 6) the prisoner, and 7) the stooge. Discussions: We discuss why expedient positions are more available for some individuals and the consequences that family caregivers’ various positions have on the healthcare policy aim of collaboration, and moreover, of equal healthcare services. Conclusions: Health care policies regarding ageing in place rest on a third party: the family caregivers. This study contributes family caregivers’ experiences of involvement in and influence on the nursing home decision-making process for persons with dementia. Knowledge of how family caregivers present themselves and others within positions is useful in understanding how decisions regarding admission to nursing homes are made, and further, in evaluating individuals’ access to healthcare. This knowledge is important for Health care providers in order for them to provide tailored support and thus facilitate the involvement of family caregivers in nursing home decision-making processes for persons with dementia. Lessons learned: To pinpoint the legislated user involvement for persons with dementia and reduce the family caregivers’ decisional burden, politicians and healthcare services must understand, acknowledge and emphasize family caregivers’ own needs. If the Health care providers are aware of potential positions in interactions with family caregivers of persons with dementia, they may enable more expedient positions for themselves and family caregivers. More expedient positions may result in fewer conflicts and reduced decisional burden when demanding decisions as admission to nursing homes must be made. Limitations:The study design is an exploratory, qualitative design based on an interactional perspective, where ‘reality’ is context bound and thus the results reflect one of several possible interpretations. Suggestions for future research: Our model of family caregivers’ positions can be useful for further development of decisional aid to reduce conflicts and negative effects of care for family caregivers in home-based care. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-10T12:32:56Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-1bcad9ed6ae0459f8acb4d8fbb1a5777 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1568-4156 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-10T12:32:56Z |
| publishDate | 2019-08-01 |
| publisher | Ubiquity Press |
| record_format | Article |
| series | International Journal of Integrated Care |
| spelling | doaj.art-1bcad9ed6ae0459f8acb4d8fbb1a57772022-12-22T01:48:44ZengUbiquity PressInternational Journal of Integrated Care1568-41562019-08-0119410.5334/ijic.s31454262Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementiaLill Sverresdatter Larsen0Bodil Hansen Blix1Torunn Hamran2UiT The Arctic University of Norway; Centre for Care ResearchUiT The Arctic University of Norway; Centre for Care ResearchUiT The Arctic University of Norway; Centre for Care ResearchIntroduction: The large number of people affected by dementia diseases poses major challenges for public health, healthcare services and healthcare service providers. The Western health policy of ageing in place rests on a triad collaboration among patients, healthcare service providers and family caregivers. Such collaborations presuppose involvement in and influence on a vague juridical landscape. Several researchers have stated the need for knowledge about decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia. The research question of this study is as follows: How do family caregivers experience involvement in and influence on the nursing home decision-making process for persons with dementia? Theory/Methods: The data consist of twelve in-depth interviews with family caregivers to persons with dementia. By the use of positioning theory, we demonstrate how family caregivers strive to balance their assumed duty to take care of the person with their needs to take care of themselves. Results: The family caregivers involvement (or non-involvement) in the complex decision-making process is demonstrated through seven positions: 1) the self-condemning determiner, 2) the dominant, 3) the proponent, 4) the saluting, 5) the pending, 6) the prisoner, and 7) the stooge. Discussions: We discuss why expedient positions are more available for some individuals and the consequences that family caregivers’ various positions have on the healthcare policy aim of collaboration, and moreover, of equal healthcare services. Conclusions: Health care policies regarding ageing in place rest on a third party: the family caregivers. This study contributes family caregivers’ experiences of involvement in and influence on the nursing home decision-making process for persons with dementia. Knowledge of how family caregivers present themselves and others within positions is useful in understanding how decisions regarding admission to nursing homes are made, and further, in evaluating individuals’ access to healthcare. This knowledge is important for Health care providers in order for them to provide tailored support and thus facilitate the involvement of family caregivers in nursing home decision-making processes for persons with dementia. Lessons learned: To pinpoint the legislated user involvement for persons with dementia and reduce the family caregivers’ decisional burden, politicians and healthcare services must understand, acknowledge and emphasize family caregivers’ own needs. If the Health care providers are aware of potential positions in interactions with family caregivers of persons with dementia, they may enable more expedient positions for themselves and family caregivers. More expedient positions may result in fewer conflicts and reduced decisional burden when demanding decisions as admission to nursing homes must be made. Limitations:The study design is an exploratory, qualitative design based on an interactional perspective, where ‘reality’ is context bound and thus the results reflect one of several possible interpretations. Suggestions for future research: Our model of family caregivers’ positions can be useful for further development of decisional aid to reduce conflicts and negative effects of care for family caregivers in home-based care.https://www.ijic.org/articles/4891decision-making processesdementiafamily caregiversinvolvementhome-based careadmission to nursing homespositioning |
| spellingShingle | Lill Sverresdatter Larsen Bodil Hansen Blix Torunn Hamran Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia International Journal of Integrated Care decision-making processes dementia family caregivers involvement home-based care admission to nursing homes positioning |
| title | Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia |
| title_full | Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia |
| title_fullStr | Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia |
| title_full_unstemmed | Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia |
| title_short | Family caregivers’ involvement in Decision-making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia |
| title_sort | family caregivers involvement in decision making processes regarding admission to nursing homes for persons with dementia |
| topic | decision-making processes dementia family caregivers involvement home-based care admission to nursing homes positioning |
| url | https://www.ijic.org/articles/4891 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT lillsverresdatterlarsen familycaregiversinvolvementindecisionmakingprocessesregardingadmissiontonursinghomesforpersonswithdementia AT bodilhansenblix familycaregiversinvolvementindecisionmakingprocessesregardingadmissiontonursinghomesforpersonswithdementia AT torunnhamran familycaregiversinvolvementindecisionmakingprocessesregardingadmissiontonursinghomesforpersonswithdementia |