Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home
Smart home technology (SHT) is becoming more widespread, implemented to enhance convenience as well as energy flexibility and efficiency. Smart heating, lighting, security and entertainment systems are affecting social practices and the use of energy in different ways. This paper explores difference...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Ubiquity Press
2022-09-01
|
| Series: | Buildings & Cities |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://journal-buildingscities.org/articles/205 |
| _version_ | 1827882803859030016 |
|---|---|
| author | Line Kryger Aagaard Line Valdorff Madsen |
| author_facet | Line Kryger Aagaard Line Valdorff Madsen |
| author_sort | Line Kryger Aagaard |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Smart home technology (SHT) is becoming more widespread, implemented to enhance convenience as well as energy flexibility and efficiency. Smart heating, lighting, security and entertainment systems are affecting social practices and the use of energy in different ways. This paper explores differences in competences, meanings and forms of knowledge involved in the performance of (gendered) household practices based on two Danish qualitative studies of different user groups: SHT frontrunner households ('n' = 15) and less tech-interested households ('n' = 12). The former had incorporated a broad range of smart technologies, 'e.g'. vacuum cleaners, lighting and entertainment systems, while the latter were primarily engaged with smart heating systems. In the frontrunner households, internal differences in competences and meanings between men and women were more apparent than in households with less tech interest. A clear division between traditional and digital housekeeping is apparent that reinforces gender inequality. Evidence shows the variation in how SHT is part of gendered everyday practices; how SHT changes meanings and competences in practices and induces new ways of performing practices that can involve gendered digital inequality. Thus, it is necessary to consider competences and meanings in everyday practices as well as gendered ideas behind the technology. 'Policy relevance' Strategies and policies for a green transition of the energy systems in Denmark and the European Union include a digitalisation of consumption in households. This transition will induce reconfigurations of everyday practices potentially entailing both digital and gendered inequality. The home has often been a contested space, relating to gender roles, inequality and division of household labour. This paper shows that SHT potentially reinforces gender inequality by creating a gendered gap between digital and traditional housekeeping. To avoid potential reinforcement of gender inequality within the home, SHT promotion and development needs to account for gender differences. Actions by industry would include differences of gendered housekeeping, showing an awareness of varying technology competences and meanings in everyday practices as well as the gendered vision of SHT and its users. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-12T19:03:01Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-207d0a7440114566a05d401f9a7faa4e |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2632-6655 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-12T19:03:01Z |
| publishDate | 2022-09-01 |
| publisher | Ubiquity Press |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Buildings & Cities |
| spelling | doaj.art-207d0a7440114566a05d401f9a7faa4e2023-08-02T06:26:03ZengUbiquity PressBuildings & Cities2632-66552022-09-013110.5334/bc.205141Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart homeLine Kryger Aagaard0Line Valdorff Madsen1Department of the Built Environment, Aalborg University, CopenhagenDepartment of the Built Environment, Aalborg University, CopenhagenSmart home technology (SHT) is becoming more widespread, implemented to enhance convenience as well as energy flexibility and efficiency. Smart heating, lighting, security and entertainment systems are affecting social practices and the use of energy in different ways. This paper explores differences in competences, meanings and forms of knowledge involved in the performance of (gendered) household practices based on two Danish qualitative studies of different user groups: SHT frontrunner households ('n' = 15) and less tech-interested households ('n' = 12). The former had incorporated a broad range of smart technologies, 'e.g'. vacuum cleaners, lighting and entertainment systems, while the latter were primarily engaged with smart heating systems. In the frontrunner households, internal differences in competences and meanings between men and women were more apparent than in households with less tech interest. A clear division between traditional and digital housekeeping is apparent that reinforces gender inequality. Evidence shows the variation in how SHT is part of gendered everyday practices; how SHT changes meanings and competences in practices and induces new ways of performing practices that can involve gendered digital inequality. Thus, it is necessary to consider competences and meanings in everyday practices as well as gendered ideas behind the technology. 'Policy relevance' Strategies and policies for a green transition of the energy systems in Denmark and the European Union include a digitalisation of consumption in households. This transition will induce reconfigurations of everyday practices potentially entailing both digital and gendered inequality. The home has often been a contested space, relating to gender roles, inequality and division of household labour. This paper shows that SHT potentially reinforces gender inequality by creating a gendered gap between digital and traditional housekeeping. To avoid potential reinforcement of gender inequality within the home, SHT promotion and development needs to account for gender differences. Actions by industry would include differences of gendered housekeeping, showing an awareness of varying technology competences and meanings in everyday practices as well as the gendered vision of SHT and its users.https://journal-buildingscities.org/articles/205digital housekeepingenergygenderhomessmart homesocial practicestech competences |
| spellingShingle | Line Kryger Aagaard Line Valdorff Madsen Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home Buildings & Cities digital housekeeping energy gender homes smart home social practices tech competences |
| title | Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home |
| title_full | Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home |
| title_fullStr | Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home |
| title_full_unstemmed | Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home |
| title_short | Technological fascination and reluctance: gendered practices in the smart home |
| title_sort | technological fascination and reluctance gendered practices in the smart home |
| topic | digital housekeeping energy gender homes smart home social practices tech competences |
| url | https://journal-buildingscities.org/articles/205 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT linekrygeraagaard technologicalfascinationandreluctancegenderedpracticesinthesmarthome AT linevaldorffmadsen technologicalfascinationandreluctancegenderedpracticesinthesmarthome |