Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties
Introduction: Compassion fatigue (CF) is the emotional and physical burden felt by those helping others in distress, leading to a reduced capacity and interest in being empathetic towards future suffering. Emergency care providers are at an increased risk of CF secondary to their first responder...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
eScholarship Publishing, University of California
2014-09-01
|
Series: | Western Journal of Emergency Medicine |
Online Access: | http://escholarship.org/uc/item/4pn5d48k |
_version_ | 1819036436323631104 |
---|---|
author | M. Fernanda Bellolio Daniel Cabrera Annie T. Sadosty Erik P. Hess Ronna L. Campbell Christine M. Lohse Karmen L. Sunga |
author_facet | M. Fernanda Bellolio Daniel Cabrera Annie T. Sadosty Erik P. Hess Ronna L. Campbell Christine M. Lohse Karmen L. Sunga |
author_sort | M. Fernanda Bellolio |
collection | DOAJ |
description | Introduction: Compassion fatigue (CF) is the emotional and physical burden felt by those helping
others in distress, leading to a reduced capacity and interest in being empathetic towards future
suffering. Emergency care providers are at an increased risk of CF secondary to their first responder
roles and exposure to traumatic events. We aimed to investigate the current state of compassion
fatigue among emergency medicine (EM) resident physicians, including an assessment of
contributing factors.
Methods: We distributed a validated electronic questionnaire consisting of the Professional Quality
of Life Scale with subscales for the three components of CF (compassion satisfaction, burnout and
secondary traumatic stress), with each category scored independently. We collected data pertaining
to day- versus night-shift distribution, hourly workload and child dependents. We included residents
in EM, neurology, orthopedics, family medicine, pediatrics, obstetrics, and general surgery.
Results: We surveyed 255 residents, with a response rate of 75%. Of the 188 resident respondents,
18% worked a majority of their clinical shifts overnight, and 32% had child dependents. Burnout
scores for residents who worked greater than 80 hours per week, or primarily worked overnight
shifts, were higher than residents who worked less than 80 hours (mean score 25.0 vs 21.5;
p=0.013), or did not work overnight (mean score 23.5 vs 21.3; p=0.022). EM residents had similar
scores in all three components of CF when compared to other specialties. Secondary traumatic
stress scores for residents who worked greater than 80 hours were higher than residents who
worked less than 80 hours (mean score 22.2 vs 19.5; p=0.048), and those with child dependents had
higher secondary traumatic stress than those without children (mean score 21.0 vs 19.1; p=0.012).
Conclusion: CF scores in EM residents are similar to residents in other surgical and medical
specialties. Residents working primarily night shifts and those working more than 80 hours per week
appear to be at high risk of developing compassion fatigue. Residents with children are more likely to
experience secondary traumatic stress. [West J Emerg Med. 2014;15(6):629–635] |
first_indexed | 2024-12-21T08:05:29Z |
format | Article |
id | doaj.art-254e8821f86e498e955a05423069bf50 |
institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
issn | 1936-900X 1936-9018 |
language | English |
last_indexed | 2024-12-21T08:05:29Z |
publishDate | 2014-09-01 |
publisher | eScholarship Publishing, University of California |
record_format | Article |
series | Western Journal of Emergency Medicine |
spelling | doaj.art-254e8821f86e498e955a05423069bf502022-12-21T19:10:48ZengeScholarship Publishing, University of CaliforniaWestern Journal of Emergency Medicine1936-900X1936-90182014-09-0115662963510.5811/westjem.2014.5.21624Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical SpecialtiesM. Fernanda Bellolio0Daniel Cabrera1Annie T. Sadosty2Erik P. Hess3Ronna L. Campbell4Christine M. Lohse5Karmen L. Sunga6Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaMayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaMayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaMayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaMayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaMayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaMayo Clinic College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Rochester, MinnesotaIntroduction: Compassion fatigue (CF) is the emotional and physical burden felt by those helping others in distress, leading to a reduced capacity and interest in being empathetic towards future suffering. Emergency care providers are at an increased risk of CF secondary to their first responder roles and exposure to traumatic events. We aimed to investigate the current state of compassion fatigue among emergency medicine (EM) resident physicians, including an assessment of contributing factors. Methods: We distributed a validated electronic questionnaire consisting of the Professional Quality of Life Scale with subscales for the three components of CF (compassion satisfaction, burnout and secondary traumatic stress), with each category scored independently. We collected data pertaining to day- versus night-shift distribution, hourly workload and child dependents. We included residents in EM, neurology, orthopedics, family medicine, pediatrics, obstetrics, and general surgery. Results: We surveyed 255 residents, with a response rate of 75%. Of the 188 resident respondents, 18% worked a majority of their clinical shifts overnight, and 32% had child dependents. Burnout scores for residents who worked greater than 80 hours per week, or primarily worked overnight shifts, were higher than residents who worked less than 80 hours (mean score 25.0 vs 21.5; p=0.013), or did not work overnight (mean score 23.5 vs 21.3; p=0.022). EM residents had similar scores in all three components of CF when compared to other specialties. Secondary traumatic stress scores for residents who worked greater than 80 hours were higher than residents who worked less than 80 hours (mean score 22.2 vs 19.5; p=0.048), and those with child dependents had higher secondary traumatic stress than those without children (mean score 21.0 vs 19.1; p=0.012). Conclusion: CF scores in EM residents are similar to residents in other surgical and medical specialties. Residents working primarily night shifts and those working more than 80 hours per week appear to be at high risk of developing compassion fatigue. Residents with children are more likely to experience secondary traumatic stress. [West J Emerg Med. 2014;15(6):629–635]http://escholarship.org/uc/item/4pn5d48k |
spellingShingle | M. Fernanda Bellolio Daniel Cabrera Annie T. Sadosty Erik P. Hess Ronna L. Campbell Christine M. Lohse Karmen L. Sunga Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties Western Journal of Emergency Medicine |
title | Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties |
title_full | Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties |
title_fullStr | Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties |
title_full_unstemmed | Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties |
title_short | Compassion Fatigue is Similar in Emergency Medicine Residents Compared to other Medical and Surgical Specialties |
title_sort | compassion fatigue is similar in emergency medicine residents compared to other medical and surgical specialties |
url | http://escholarship.org/uc/item/4pn5d48k |
work_keys_str_mv | AT mfernandabellolio compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties AT danielcabrera compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties AT annietsadosty compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties AT erikphess compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties AT ronnalcampbell compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties AT christinemlohse compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties AT karmenlsunga compassionfatigueissimilarinemergencymedicineresidentscomparedtoothermedicalandsurgicalspecialties |