INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT
ABSTRACT Objective The therapeutic decision in cases of adult spinal deformity takes numerous factors into account with a consequent variability in treatment options. The objective is to compare the impact of the MISDEF (minimally invasive spine deformity) algorithm on therapeutic decisions in case...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Sociedade Brasileira de Coluna (SBC)
|
| Series: | Coluna/Columna |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1808-18512020000200096&lng=en&tlng=en |
| _version_ | 1828745448591982592 |
|---|---|
| author | GUILHERME ZANDAVALLI RAMOS EMILIANO VIALLE RAFAEL LUIZ PINTO CRISTIANO MENEZES MAURÍCIO SANTOS GUSMÃO NICOLAS GONZÁLEZ MASANÉS ASDRUBAL FALAVIGNA CHÁRBEL JACOB JUNIOR LUIZ ROBERTO VIALLE RAMON FERREIRA GUILHERMO HOLTMAN |
| author_facet | GUILHERME ZANDAVALLI RAMOS EMILIANO VIALLE RAFAEL LUIZ PINTO CRISTIANO MENEZES MAURÍCIO SANTOS GUSMÃO NICOLAS GONZÁLEZ MASANÉS ASDRUBAL FALAVIGNA CHÁRBEL JACOB JUNIOR LUIZ ROBERTO VIALLE RAMON FERREIRA GUILHERMO HOLTMAN |
| author_sort | GUILHERME ZANDAVALLI RAMOS |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | ABSTRACT Objective The therapeutic decision in cases of adult spinal deformity takes numerous factors into account with a consequent variability in treatment options. The objective is to compare the impact of the MISDEF (minimally invasive spine deformity) algorithm on therapeutic decisions in cases of adult spinal deformity. Methods Prospective radiographic analysis of 40 cases of adult deformity. The cases were sent, in two steps, to 20 Latin American surgeons who had to choose among six treatment options with and without the use of the MISDEF. Results For the conducts of decompression, decompression and short fusion, decompression and fusion with interbody device, and osteotomy with extension of fusion to the thoracic spine, no significant differences were found when comparing decisions made with and without MISDEF. For osteotomy, we observed a tendency for the number of surgeons choosing this conduct to increase when the decision is made with MISDEF. We observed that the number of surgeons who decided on conservative treatment decreased with the use of MISDEF (p <0.001). In cases with sagittal vertical axis <6 cm or pelvic tilt <25 ° or PI-LL (pelvic incidence minus lumbar lordosis) <10 ° or coronal curve <20 °, there was a decrease in the conservative treatment option and an increase in osteotomy with proximal extension of the fusion with the use of MISDEF. Conclusions There is a tendency to increase indications of osteotomy and decrease the conservative treatment option when making a decision with MISDEF. The use of the algorithm showed no significant impact on the therapeutic decision in severe cases of adult deformity. Level of Evidence II; Prospective comparative radiographic analysis. |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-14T04:04:30Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-280c8e329f79490f8de93f99aff978ae |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1808-1851 2177-014X |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-14T04:04:30Z |
| publisher | Sociedade Brasileira de Coluna (SBC) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Coluna/Columna |
| spelling | doaj.art-280c8e329f79490f8de93f99aff978ae2022-12-22T02:13:25ZengSociedade Brasileira de Coluna (SBC)Coluna/Columna1808-18512177-014X1929610310.1590/s1808-185120201902222428S1808-18512020000200096INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULTGUILHERME ZANDAVALLI RAMOSEMILIANO VIALLERAFAEL LUIZ PINTOCRISTIANO MENEZESMAURÍCIO SANTOS GUSMÃONICOLAS GONZÁLEZ MASANÉSASDRUBAL FALAVIGNACHÁRBEL JACOB JUNIORLUIZ ROBERTO VIALLERAMON FERREIRAGUILHERMO HOLTMANABSTRACT Objective The therapeutic decision in cases of adult spinal deformity takes numerous factors into account with a consequent variability in treatment options. The objective is to compare the impact of the MISDEF (minimally invasive spine deformity) algorithm on therapeutic decisions in cases of adult spinal deformity. Methods Prospective radiographic analysis of 40 cases of adult deformity. The cases were sent, in two steps, to 20 Latin American surgeons who had to choose among six treatment options with and without the use of the MISDEF. Results For the conducts of decompression, decompression and short fusion, decompression and fusion with interbody device, and osteotomy with extension of fusion to the thoracic spine, no significant differences were found when comparing decisions made with and without MISDEF. For osteotomy, we observed a tendency for the number of surgeons choosing this conduct to increase when the decision is made with MISDEF. We observed that the number of surgeons who decided on conservative treatment decreased with the use of MISDEF (p <0.001). In cases with sagittal vertical axis <6 cm or pelvic tilt <25 ° or PI-LL (pelvic incidence minus lumbar lordosis) <10 ° or coronal curve <20 °, there was a decrease in the conservative treatment option and an increase in osteotomy with proximal extension of the fusion with the use of MISDEF. Conclusions There is a tendency to increase indications of osteotomy and decrease the conservative treatment option when making a decision with MISDEF. The use of the algorithm showed no significant impact on the therapeutic decision in severe cases of adult deformity. Level of Evidence II; Prospective comparative radiographic analysis.http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1808-18512020000200096&lng=en&tlng=enadultoescoliosiscolumna vertebraltratamiento conservadorosteotomía |
| spellingShingle | GUILHERME ZANDAVALLI RAMOS EMILIANO VIALLE RAFAEL LUIZ PINTO CRISTIANO MENEZES MAURÍCIO SANTOS GUSMÃO NICOLAS GONZÁLEZ MASANÉS ASDRUBAL FALAVIGNA CHÁRBEL JACOB JUNIOR LUIZ ROBERTO VIALLE RAMON FERREIRA GUILHERMO HOLTMAN INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT Coluna/Columna adulto escoliosis columna vertebral tratamiento conservador osteotomía |
| title | INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT |
| title_full | INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT |
| title_fullStr | INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT |
| title_full_unstemmed | INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT |
| title_short | INFLUENCE OF THE MISDEF ALGORITHM ON THE THERAPEUTIC DECISION FOR VERTEBRAL DEFORMITY IN THE ADULT |
| title_sort | influence of the misdef algorithm on the therapeutic decision for vertebral deformity in the adult |
| topic | adulto escoliosis columna vertebral tratamiento conservador osteotomía |
| url | http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1808-18512020000200096&lng=en&tlng=en |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT guilhermezandavalliramos influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT emilianovialle influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT rafaelluizpinto influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT cristianomenezes influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT mauriciosantosgusmao influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT nicolasgonzalezmasanes influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT asdrubalfalavigna influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT charbeljacobjunior influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT luizrobertovialle influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT ramonferreira influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult AT guilhermoholtman influenceofthemisdefalgorithmonthetherapeuticdecisionforvertebraldeformityintheadult |