An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE
Observations of chemical constituents and meteorological quantities obtained during the two Arctic phases of the airborne campaign ARCTAS (Arctic Research of the Composition of the Troposphere from Aircraft and Satellites) are analyzed using an observationally constrained steady state box model. Mea...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Copernicus Publications
2012-08-01
|
| Series: | Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics |
| Online Access: | http://www.atmos-chem-phys.net/12/6799/2012/acp-12-6799-2012.pdf |
| _version_ | 1828425305328451584 |
|---|---|
| author | J. R. Olson J. H. Crawford W. Brune J. Mao X. Ren A. Fried B. Anderson E. Apel M. Beaver D. Blake G. Chen J. Crounse J. Dibb G. Diskin S. R. Hall L. G. Huey D. Knapp D. Richter D. Riemer J. St. Clair K. Ullmann J. Walega P. Weibring A. Weinheimer P. Wennberg A. Wisthaler |
| author_facet | J. R. Olson J. H. Crawford W. Brune J. Mao X. Ren A. Fried B. Anderson E. Apel M. Beaver D. Blake G. Chen J. Crounse J. Dibb G. Diskin S. R. Hall L. G. Huey D. Knapp D. Richter D. Riemer J. St. Clair K. Ullmann J. Walega P. Weibring A. Weinheimer P. Wennberg A. Wisthaler |
| author_sort | J. R. Olson |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Observations of chemical constituents and meteorological quantities obtained during the two Arctic phases of the airborne campaign ARCTAS (Arctic Research of the Composition of the Troposphere from Aircraft and Satellites) are analyzed using an observationally constrained steady state box model. Measurements of OH and HO<sub>2</sub> from the Penn State ATHOS instrument are compared to model predictions. Forty percent of OH measurements below 2 km are at the limit of detection during the spring phase (ARCTAS-A). While the median observed-to-calculated ratio is near one, both the scatter of observations and the model uncertainty for OH are at the magnitude of ambient values. During the summer phase (ARCTAS-B), model predictions of OH are biased low relative to observations and demonstrate a high sensitivity to the level of uncertainty in NO observations. Predictions of HO<sub>2</sub> using observed CH<sub>2</sub>O and H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub> as model constraints are up to a factor of two larger than observed. A temperature-dependent terminal loss rate of HO<sub>2</sub> to aerosol recently proposed in the literature is shown to be insufficient to reconcile these differences. A comparison of ARCTAS-A to the high latitude springtime portion of the 2000 TOPSE campaign (Tropospheric Ozone Production about the Spring Equinox) shows similar meteorological and chemical environments with the exception of peroxides; observations of H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub> during ARCTAS-A were 2.5 to 3 times larger than those during TOPSE. The cause of this difference in peroxides remains unresolved and has important implications for the Arctic HO<sub>x</sub> budget. Unconstrained model predictions for both phases indicate photochemistry alone is unable to simultaneously sustain observed levels of CH<sub>2</sub>O and H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub>; however when the model is constrained with observed CH<sub>2</sub>O, H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub> predictions from a range of rainout parameterizations bracket its observations. A mechanism suitable to explain observed concentrations of CH<sub>2</sub>O is uncertain. Free tropospheric observations of acetaldehyde (CH<sub>3</sub>CHO) are 2–3 times larger than its predictions, though constraint of the model to those observations is sufficient to account for less than half of the deficit in predicted CH<sub>2</sub>O. The box model calculates gross O<sub>3</sub> formation during spring to maximize from 1–4 km at 0.8 ppbv d<sup>−1</sup>, in agreement with estimates from TOPSE, and a gross production of 2–4 ppbv d<sup>−1</sup> in the boundary layer and upper troposphere during summer. Use of the lower observed levels of HO<sub>2</sub> in place of model predictions decreases the gross production by 25–50%. Net O<sub>3</sub> production is near zero throughout the ARCTAS-A troposphere, and is 1–2 ppbv in the boundary layer and upper altitudes during ARCTAS-B. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-10T16:31:29Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-2ea21a10d95342fb967e4a18ea3a4b5c |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1680-7316 1680-7324 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-10T16:31:29Z |
| publishDate | 2012-08-01 |
| publisher | Copernicus Publications |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics |
| spelling | doaj.art-2ea21a10d95342fb967e4a18ea3a4b5c2022-12-22T01:41:32ZengCopernicus PublicationsAtmospheric Chemistry and Physics1680-73161680-73242012-08-0112156799682510.5194/acp-12-6799-2012An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSEJ. R. OlsonJ. H. CrawfordW. BruneJ. MaoX. RenA. FriedB. AndersonE. ApelM. BeaverD. BlakeG. ChenJ. CrounseJ. DibbG. DiskinS. R. HallL. G. HueyD. KnappD. RichterD. RiemerJ. St. ClairK. UllmannJ. WalegaP. WeibringA. WeinheimerP. WennbergA. WisthalerObservations of chemical constituents and meteorological quantities obtained during the two Arctic phases of the airborne campaign ARCTAS (Arctic Research of the Composition of the Troposphere from Aircraft and Satellites) are analyzed using an observationally constrained steady state box model. Measurements of OH and HO<sub>2</sub> from the Penn State ATHOS instrument are compared to model predictions. Forty percent of OH measurements below 2 km are at the limit of detection during the spring phase (ARCTAS-A). While the median observed-to-calculated ratio is near one, both the scatter of observations and the model uncertainty for OH are at the magnitude of ambient values. During the summer phase (ARCTAS-B), model predictions of OH are biased low relative to observations and demonstrate a high sensitivity to the level of uncertainty in NO observations. Predictions of HO<sub>2</sub> using observed CH<sub>2</sub>O and H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub> as model constraints are up to a factor of two larger than observed. A temperature-dependent terminal loss rate of HO<sub>2</sub> to aerosol recently proposed in the literature is shown to be insufficient to reconcile these differences. A comparison of ARCTAS-A to the high latitude springtime portion of the 2000 TOPSE campaign (Tropospheric Ozone Production about the Spring Equinox) shows similar meteorological and chemical environments with the exception of peroxides; observations of H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub> during ARCTAS-A were 2.5 to 3 times larger than those during TOPSE. The cause of this difference in peroxides remains unresolved and has important implications for the Arctic HO<sub>x</sub> budget. Unconstrained model predictions for both phases indicate photochemistry alone is unable to simultaneously sustain observed levels of CH<sub>2</sub>O and H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub>; however when the model is constrained with observed CH<sub>2</sub>O, H<sub>2</sub>O<sub>2</sub> predictions from a range of rainout parameterizations bracket its observations. A mechanism suitable to explain observed concentrations of CH<sub>2</sub>O is uncertain. Free tropospheric observations of acetaldehyde (CH<sub>3</sub>CHO) are 2–3 times larger than its predictions, though constraint of the model to those observations is sufficient to account for less than half of the deficit in predicted CH<sub>2</sub>O. The box model calculates gross O<sub>3</sub> formation during spring to maximize from 1–4 km at 0.8 ppbv d<sup>−1</sup>, in agreement with estimates from TOPSE, and a gross production of 2–4 ppbv d<sup>−1</sup> in the boundary layer and upper troposphere during summer. Use of the lower observed levels of HO<sub>2</sub> in place of model predictions decreases the gross production by 25–50%. Net O<sub>3</sub> production is near zero throughout the ARCTAS-A troposphere, and is 1–2 ppbv in the boundary layer and upper altitudes during ARCTAS-B.http://www.atmos-chem-phys.net/12/6799/2012/acp-12-6799-2012.pdf |
| spellingShingle | J. R. Olson J. H. Crawford W. Brune J. Mao X. Ren A. Fried B. Anderson E. Apel M. Beaver D. Blake G. Chen J. Crounse J. Dibb G. Diskin S. R. Hall L. G. Huey D. Knapp D. Richter D. Riemer J. St. Clair K. Ullmann J. Walega P. Weibring A. Weinheimer P. Wennberg A. Wisthaler An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics |
| title | An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE |
| title_full | An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE |
| title_fullStr | An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE |
| title_full_unstemmed | An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE |
| title_short | An analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in-situ observations from ARCTAS and TOPSE |
| title_sort | analysis of fast photochemistry over high northern latitudes during spring and summer using in situ observations from arctas and topse |
| url | http://www.atmos-chem-phys.net/12/6799/2012/acp-12-6799-2012.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT jrolson ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jhcrawford ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT wbrune ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jmao ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT xren ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT afried ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT banderson ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT eapel ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT mbeaver ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT dblake ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT gchen ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jcrounse ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jdibb ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT gdiskin ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT srhall ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT lghuey ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT dknapp ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT drichter ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT driemer ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jstclair ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT kullmann ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jwalega ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT pweibring ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT aweinheimer ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT pwennberg ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT awisthaler ananalysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jrolson analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jhcrawford analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT wbrune analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jmao analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT xren analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT afried analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT banderson analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT eapel analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT mbeaver analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT dblake analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT gchen analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jcrounse analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jdibb analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT gdiskin analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT srhall analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT lghuey analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT dknapp analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT drichter analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT driemer analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jstclair analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT kullmann analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT jwalega analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT pweibring analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT aweinheimer analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT pwennberg analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse AT awisthaler analysisoffastphotochemistryoverhighnorthernlatitudesduringspringandsummerusinginsituobservationsfromarctasandtopse |