What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography
Abstract Background People experiencing homelessness have higher rates of problematic substance use but difficulty engaging with treatment services. There is limited evidence regarding how problematic substance use treatment should be delivered for these individuals. Previous qualitative research ha...
| Main Authors: | , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMC
2020-01-01
|
| Series: | Harm Reduction Journal |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1186/s12954-020-0356-9 |
| _version_ | 1818623063167598592 |
|---|---|
| author | Hannah Carver Nicola Ring Joanna Miler Tessa Parkes |
| author_facet | Hannah Carver Nicola Ring Joanna Miler Tessa Parkes |
| author_sort | Hannah Carver |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Background People experiencing homelessness have higher rates of problematic substance use but difficulty engaging with treatment services. There is limited evidence regarding how problematic substance use treatment should be delivered for these individuals. Previous qualitative research has explored perceptions of effective treatment by people who are homeless, but these individual studies need to be synthesised to generate further practice-relevant insights from the perspective of this group. Methods Meta-ethnography was conducted to synthesise research reporting views on substance use treatment by people experiencing homelessness. Studies were identified through systematic searching of electronic databases (CINAHL; Criminal Justice Abstracts; Health Source; MEDLINE; PsycINFO; SocINDEX; Scopus; and Web of Science) and websites and were quality appraised. Original participant quotes and author interpretations were extracted and coded thematically. Concepts identified were compared to determine similarities and differences between studies. Findings were translated (reciprocally and refutationally) across studies, enabling development of an original over-arching line-of-argument and conceptual model. Results Twenty-three papers published since 2002 in three countries, involving 462 participants, were synthesised. Findings broadly related, through personal descriptions of, and views on, the particular intervention components considered effective to people experiencing homelessness. Participants of all types of interventions had a preference for harm reduction-oriented services. Participants considered treatment effective when it provided a facilitative service environment; compassionate and non-judgemental support; time; choices; and opportunities to (re)learn how to live. Interventions that were of longer duration and offered stability to service users were valued, especially by women. From the line-of-argument synthesis, a new model was developed highlighting critical components of effective substance use treatment from the service user’s perspective, including a service context of good relationships, with person-centred care and an understanding of the complexity of people’s lives. Conclusion This is the first meta-ethnography to examine the components of effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of those experiencing homelessness. Critical components of effective problematic substance use treatment are highlighted. The way in which services and treatment are delivered is more important than the type of treatment provided. Substance use interventions should address these components, including prioritising good relationships between staff and those using services, person-centred approaches, and a genuine understanding of individuals’ complex lives. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-16T18:35:06Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-32e88d3f7fcf434fa5f7acf27780561e |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1477-7517 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-16T18:35:06Z |
| publishDate | 2020-01-01 |
| publisher | BMC |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Harm Reduction Journal |
| spelling | doaj.art-32e88d3f7fcf434fa5f7acf27780561e2022-12-21T22:21:11ZengBMCHarm Reduction Journal1477-75172020-01-0117112210.1186/s12954-020-0356-9What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnographyHannah Carver0Nicola Ring1Joanna Miler2Tessa Parkes3Salvation Army Centre for Addiction Services and Research, 4T26, RG Bomont Building, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of StirlingSchool of Health and Social Care, Sighthill Campus, Edinburgh Napier UniversitySalvation Army Centre for Addiction Services and Research, 4T26, RG Bomont Building, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of StirlingSalvation Army Centre for Addiction Services and Research, 4T26, RG Bomont Building, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of StirlingAbstract Background People experiencing homelessness have higher rates of problematic substance use but difficulty engaging with treatment services. There is limited evidence regarding how problematic substance use treatment should be delivered for these individuals. Previous qualitative research has explored perceptions of effective treatment by people who are homeless, but these individual studies need to be synthesised to generate further practice-relevant insights from the perspective of this group. Methods Meta-ethnography was conducted to synthesise research reporting views on substance use treatment by people experiencing homelessness. Studies were identified through systematic searching of electronic databases (CINAHL; Criminal Justice Abstracts; Health Source; MEDLINE; PsycINFO; SocINDEX; Scopus; and Web of Science) and websites and were quality appraised. Original participant quotes and author interpretations were extracted and coded thematically. Concepts identified were compared to determine similarities and differences between studies. Findings were translated (reciprocally and refutationally) across studies, enabling development of an original over-arching line-of-argument and conceptual model. Results Twenty-three papers published since 2002 in three countries, involving 462 participants, were synthesised. Findings broadly related, through personal descriptions of, and views on, the particular intervention components considered effective to people experiencing homelessness. Participants of all types of interventions had a preference for harm reduction-oriented services. Participants considered treatment effective when it provided a facilitative service environment; compassionate and non-judgemental support; time; choices; and opportunities to (re)learn how to live. Interventions that were of longer duration and offered stability to service users were valued, especially by women. From the line-of-argument synthesis, a new model was developed highlighting critical components of effective substance use treatment from the service user’s perspective, including a service context of good relationships, with person-centred care and an understanding of the complexity of people’s lives. Conclusion This is the first meta-ethnography to examine the components of effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of those experiencing homelessness. Critical components of effective problematic substance use treatment are highlighted. The way in which services and treatment are delivered is more important than the type of treatment provided. Substance use interventions should address these components, including prioritising good relationships between staff and those using services, person-centred approaches, and a genuine understanding of individuals’ complex lives.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12954-020-0356-9Substance useTreatmentInterventionsQualitativeHomelessnessMeta-ethnography |
| spellingShingle | Hannah Carver Nicola Ring Joanna Miler Tessa Parkes What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography Harm Reduction Journal Substance use Treatment Interventions Qualitative Homelessness Meta-ethnography |
| title | What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography |
| title_full | What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography |
| title_fullStr | What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography |
| title_full_unstemmed | What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography |
| title_short | What constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless? A systematic review and meta-ethnography |
| title_sort | what constitutes effective problematic substance use treatment from the perspective of people who are homeless a systematic review and meta ethnography |
| topic | Substance use Treatment Interventions Qualitative Homelessness Meta-ethnography |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1186/s12954-020-0356-9 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT hannahcarver whatconstituteseffectiveproblematicsubstanceusetreatmentfromtheperspectiveofpeoplewhoarehomelessasystematicreviewandmetaethnography AT nicolaring whatconstituteseffectiveproblematicsubstanceusetreatmentfromtheperspectiveofpeoplewhoarehomelessasystematicreviewandmetaethnography AT joannamiler whatconstituteseffectiveproblematicsubstanceusetreatmentfromtheperspectiveofpeoplewhoarehomelessasystematicreviewandmetaethnography AT tessaparkes whatconstituteseffectiveproblematicsubstanceusetreatmentfromtheperspectiveofpeoplewhoarehomelessasystematicreviewandmetaethnography |