ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY
The article offers a historiographical consideration of the description of the Khotyn battle 1621with an emphasis on the historical value of M. Kostin's “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” in the coverage of the event. The relevance of the study is dictated by the 400th anniversary of the ba...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Bukovinian State Medical university
2021-06-01
|
| Series: | Актуальні питання суспільних наук та історії медицини |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://apsnim.bsmu.edu.ua/home/2_2021/moysey_moisei |
| _version_ | 1828331367370326016 |
|---|---|
| author | Antoniy MOYSEY Arkadiy MOІSEY |
| author_facet | Antoniy MOYSEY Arkadiy MOІSEY |
| author_sort | Antoniy MOYSEY |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | The article offers a historiographical consideration
of the description of the Khotyn battle 1621with an emphasis on the historical
value of M. Kostin's “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” in the coverage of the
event. The relevance of the study is dictated by the 400th anniversary of the
battle. The purpose of the study is to clarify the historical significance of the
chronicle in revealing the theme of the Battle of Khotyn in 1621. Methodology
describes the work of M. Kostin, its source base, comparison with other historical
sources, review of its use. Conclusions. “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” by
Myron Kostin, being the only source for studying the history of Moldova in the
early and mid seventeenth century. at the same time it is a true description of the
events of the Khotyn War (1620–1621). Although the chronicler is not a
contemporary of the events, his account of the Battle of Khotyn is based on serious
Polish sources of the relevant era, oral information from contemporaries of the
fighting, the traditions of the princely family of Movileshty, and so on. The work is
positively characterized by a deep and detailed description of events, impartiality,
clear analysis of military operations of a participant in many battles, education of
the author and his broad outlook, which allowed him to understand the causal links
of actions, actions of the parties, unconditional literary talent M. Kostin. His
disregard for the events of the Khotyn War of 1621 by a number of Ukrainian
historians shows a reluctance to consider the event comprehensively, using all
sources. Moreover, we see a focus on showing only one fragment of this historical
event, the participation of the Ukrainian side in it. The language barrier to the use
of the Chronicle is no more a problem than a political motive. |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-13T20:51:31Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-32f8fc8b5a734ef8a0dc9d28eeea7ec9 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2311-9896 2411-6181 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-13T20:51:31Z |
| publishDate | 2021-06-01 |
| publisher | Bukovinian State Medical university |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Актуальні питання суспільних наук та історії медицини |
| spelling | doaj.art-32f8fc8b5a734ef8a0dc9d28eeea7ec92022-12-22T02:30:28ZengBukovinian State Medical universityАктуальні питання суспільних наук та історії медицини2311-98962411-61812021-06-012(30)444810.24061/2411-6181.2.2021.266ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHYAntoniy MOYSEY0https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5295-2271Arkadiy MOІSEY1https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5295-2271Bukovinian State Medical UniversityRomanian Cultural Center E. HurmuzakiThe article offers a historiographical consideration of the description of the Khotyn battle 1621with an emphasis on the historical value of M. Kostin's “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” in the coverage of the event. The relevance of the study is dictated by the 400th anniversary of the battle. The purpose of the study is to clarify the historical significance of the chronicle in revealing the theme of the Battle of Khotyn in 1621. Methodology describes the work of M. Kostin, its source base, comparison with other historical sources, review of its use. Conclusions. “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” by Myron Kostin, being the only source for studying the history of Moldova in the early and mid seventeenth century. at the same time it is a true description of the events of the Khotyn War (1620–1621). Although the chronicler is not a contemporary of the events, his account of the Battle of Khotyn is based on serious Polish sources of the relevant era, oral information from contemporaries of the fighting, the traditions of the princely family of Movileshty, and so on. The work is positively characterized by a deep and detailed description of events, impartiality, clear analysis of military operations of a participant in many battles, education of the author and his broad outlook, which allowed him to understand the causal links of actions, actions of the parties, unconditional literary talent M. Kostin. His disregard for the events of the Khotyn War of 1621 by a number of Ukrainian historians shows a reluctance to consider the event comprehensively, using all sources. Moreover, we see a focus on showing only one fragment of this historical event, the participation of the Ukrainian side in it. The language barrier to the use of the Chronicle is no more a problem than a political motive.http://apsnim.bsmu.edu.ua/home/2_2021/moysey_moiseibattle of khotyn in 1621participants and contemporaries of the battlehistoriography of the event“chronicle of the land of moldova” by m. kostinmyron kostinhistorical sources |
| spellingShingle | Antoniy MOYSEY Arkadiy MOІSEY ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY Актуальні питання суспільних наук та історії медицини battle of khotyn in 1621 participants and contemporaries of the battle historiography of the event “chronicle of the land of moldova” by m. kostin myron kostin historical sources |
| title | ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY |
| title_full | ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY |
| title_fullStr | ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY |
| title_full_unstemmed | ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY |
| title_short | ХОТИНСЬКА БИТВА 1621 РОКУ. ІГНОРОВАНЕ ДЖЕРЕЛО В УКРАЇНСЬКІЙ ІСТОРІОГРАФІЇ/ KHOTYN BATTLE 1621. IGNORED SOURCE IN UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY |
| title_sort | хотинська битва 1621 року ігнороване джерело в українській історіографії khotyn battle 1621 ignored source in ukrainian historiography |
| topic | battle of khotyn in 1621 participants and contemporaries of the battle historiography of the event “chronicle of the land of moldova” by m. kostin myron kostin historical sources |
| url | http://apsnim.bsmu.edu.ua/home/2_2021/moysey_moisei |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT antoniymoysey hotinsʹkabitva1621rokuígnorovanedžerelovukraínsʹkíjístoríografííkhotynbattle1621ignoredsourceinukrainianhistoriography AT arkadiymoísey hotinsʹkabitva1621rokuígnorovanedžerelovukraínsʹkíjístoríografííkhotynbattle1621ignoredsourceinukrainianhistoriography |