De la République romaine à la République française : exemple historique et scénographie

This article opens with introducing the notion of verbal historical example. Then it compares two historical examples, two centuries apart, about French Revolution. The first one, a verbal example, is at the front of a speech of Robespierre to the Constituent Assembly, in favor of the abolition of t...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Dominique Maingueneau
Format: Article
Language:fra
Published: University of Tel-Aviv 2016-04-01
Series:Argumentation et Analyse du Discours
Subjects:
Online Access:http://journals.openedition.org/aad/2102
Description
Summary:This article opens with introducing the notion of verbal historical example. Then it compares two historical examples, two centuries apart, about French Revolution. The first one, a verbal example, is at the front of a speech of Robespierre to the Constituent Assembly, in favor of the abolition of the death penalty (30th may 1791). The second one has been extracted from a pamphlet of the extreme left-wing French politician José Bové when he was campaigning for President in 2007. This comparison allows us to see that historical examples can be presented in very different ways: some of them are explicit and clearly defined (Robespierre), others structure implicitly the whole text (Bové). It also allows us to emphasize that verbal examples get maximum efficiency when they can reflect the very conditions of possibility of the utterances where they are inserted.
ISSN:1565-8961