Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining
Abstract : Introduction : This review article is based on jurisprudential rulings, legal approaches, social aspects, medical and ethical approach perspectives , and clarifies decisions related to the issue of brain death. Correct understanding of the brain death phenomenon in terms of brain struct...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Qom University of Medical Sciences
2021-12-01
|
| Series: | Health, Spirituality and Medical Ethics |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://jhsme.muq.ac.ir/article-1-263-en.html |
| _version_ | 1817990967143170048 |
|---|---|
| author | Davoud Nezamoleslami alireza Olyaeemanesh ahmad jonidi seyiedhossein hajimirzaie Reihaneh Kiamanesh ali akbar Haghveisy Fattanehsadat bathaei |
| author_facet | Davoud Nezamoleslami alireza Olyaeemanesh ahmad jonidi seyiedhossein hajimirzaie Reihaneh Kiamanesh ali akbar Haghveisy Fattanehsadat bathaei |
| author_sort | Davoud Nezamoleslami |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract :
Introduction : This review article is based on jurisprudential rulings, legal approaches, social aspects, medical and ethical approach perspectives , and clarifies decisions related to the issue of brain death. Correct understanding of the brain death phenomenon in terms of brain structure and functioning, and the attitude of the community towards this phenomenon, and in particular the understanding of the condition of a patient with brain death in the future, will modify the form and content of the type of decision and process of the content. Human after the spirit insufflation will have been moral identity, and this identity remains with him until death and even after it .Brain death is a Neologism that hase propeled Experts in the fields of medicine, theology, law and even public to Try and Challenging the vague secret of death .Consistency Braindeath with absolute death Has serious pros and cons Which each other By resorting to Arguments desired , Try to Proving their alleged tendency views .
Method: This research is a review article with Analytical descriptive and correlational method, by collecting information through the in which the resources include books, articles and electronic resources from the library of the Museum of History of Medicine and Central Library and Electronic Resources in the search engines google scholar, Pubmed , Direct Science, Ovid, SID, Iran medex and in If necessary, other databases have been searched by keywords.
Discussion: Brain death is accepted in many countries as certain death. Sum Of the arguments seem to brain death is unequivalent exactly to certain death and don’t lapses human from humanity and At least the existence. the concepts of spirit, life and death,can be understood not by their quiddity but by their effect . according to Islamic thoughts , life and death is based on the presentation and separation soul from the body. It is seemed on the Islamic thought basis ,
Result : Brain death isnchr('39')t realy equivalent with certain death because it has not broken relatinsheep between the spirit and body perfectly. From the perspective of medical ethics this is important that be accepted harvesting Vital organs from brain dead patients is cause of death them. Assuming the viability of brain dead patients , harvest any organ that led to his death is morally unacceptable Except with prior permission or substitute decision maker . |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-14T01:06:06Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-3d9b0c77a36f409397686aef910d80b4 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2322-4304 2383-3610 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-14T01:06:06Z |
| publishDate | 2021-12-01 |
| publisher | Qom University of Medical Sciences |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Health, Spirituality and Medical Ethics |
| spelling | doaj.art-3d9b0c77a36f409397686aef910d80b42022-12-22T02:21:13ZengQom University of Medical SciencesHealth, Spirituality and Medical Ethics2322-43042383-36102021-12-0183191197Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need RedefiningDavoud Nezamoleslami0alireza Olyaeemanesh1ahmad jonidi2seyiedhossein hajimirzaie3Reihaneh Kiamanesh4ali akbar Haghveisy5Fattanehsadat bathaei6 Medical History and Ethics Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran National Institute for Health Research, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Tehran, Iran. Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Tehran, Iran. Nutrition Sciences Ethics and Nutrition, Research Centers, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran Department of Ethics and Nutrition, Faculty of Health, Qom University of Medical Sciences and Health Service, Qom, Iran. Abstract : Introduction : This review article is based on jurisprudential rulings, legal approaches, social aspects, medical and ethical approach perspectives , and clarifies decisions related to the issue of brain death. Correct understanding of the brain death phenomenon in terms of brain structure and functioning, and the attitude of the community towards this phenomenon, and in particular the understanding of the condition of a patient with brain death in the future, will modify the form and content of the type of decision and process of the content. Human after the spirit insufflation will have been moral identity, and this identity remains with him until death and even after it .Brain death is a Neologism that hase propeled Experts in the fields of medicine, theology, law and even public to Try and Challenging the vague secret of death .Consistency Braindeath with absolute death Has serious pros and cons Which each other By resorting to Arguments desired , Try to Proving their alleged tendency views . Method: This research is a review article with Analytical descriptive and correlational method, by collecting information through the in which the resources include books, articles and electronic resources from the library of the Museum of History of Medicine and Central Library and Electronic Resources in the search engines google scholar, Pubmed , Direct Science, Ovid, SID, Iran medex and in If necessary, other databases have been searched by keywords. Discussion: Brain death is accepted in many countries as certain death. Sum Of the arguments seem to brain death is unequivalent exactly to certain death and don’t lapses human from humanity and At least the existence. the concepts of spirit, life and death,can be understood not by their quiddity but by their effect . according to Islamic thoughts , life and death is based on the presentation and separation soul from the body. It is seemed on the Islamic thought basis , Result : Brain death isnchr('39')t realy equivalent with certain death because it has not broken relatinsheep between the spirit and body perfectly. From the perspective of medical ethics this is important that be accepted harvesting Vital organs from brain dead patients is cause of death them. Assuming the viability of brain dead patients , harvest any organ that led to his death is morally unacceptable Except with prior permission or substitute decision maker .http://jhsme.muq.ac.ir/article-1-263-en.htmlbrain deathdeathmedical ethicsdignity |
| spellingShingle | Davoud Nezamoleslami alireza Olyaeemanesh ahmad jonidi seyiedhossein hajimirzaie Reihaneh Kiamanesh ali akbar Haghveisy Fattanehsadat bathaei Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining Health, Spirituality and Medical Ethics brain death death medical ethics dignity |
| title | Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining |
| title_full | Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining |
| title_fullStr | Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining |
| title_full_unstemmed | Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining |
| title_short | Brain Death, Challenges Between Reality and the New Concept of Death May Not Be Synonymous With the True Meaning and Need Redefining |
| title_sort | brain death challenges between reality and the new concept of death may not be synonymous with the true meaning and need redefining |
| topic | brain death death medical ethics dignity |
| url | http://jhsme.muq.ac.ir/article-1-263-en.html |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT davoudnezamoleslami braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining AT alirezaolyaeemanesh braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining AT ahmadjonidi braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining AT seyiedhosseinhajimirzaie braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining AT reihanehkiamanesh braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining AT aliakbarhaghveisy braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining AT fattanehsadatbathaei braindeathchallengesbetweenrealityandthenewconceptofdeathmaynotbesynonymouswiththetruemeaningandneedredefining |