Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation
ABSTRACT Genomics allows accurately pinpointing microbial ancestry for taxonomic purposes, yet there is currently no consensus to genus definition based on genome data. Different metrics and criteria are used, with an increasing trend toward genera over-splitting. Here, we report a method for prokar...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
American Society for Microbiology
2023-10-01
|
| Series: | mBio |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.02207-23 |
| _version_ | 1797619682343124992 |
|---|---|
| author | Jorge Val-Calvo José A. Vázquez-Boland |
| author_facet | Jorge Val-Calvo José A. Vázquez-Boland |
| author_sort | Jorge Val-Calvo |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | ABSTRACT Genomics allows accurately pinpointing microbial ancestry for taxonomic purposes, yet there is currently no consensus to genus definition based on genome data. Different metrics and criteria are used, with an increasing trend toward genera over-splitting. Here, we report a method for prokaryotic genus assignment that combines normalized tree clustering and network analysis of several genomic relatedness indices. Objectivity is maximized by linear application of the same partitioning thresholds across an entire middle/high taxonomic rank context (order level), with the classical (“pre-genomic”) genera as demarcation reference, ensuring continuity in taxonomy and nomenclature. We tested the method with the Mycobacteriales, where recent examples of genus fragmentation divided Mycobacterium into five genera, or made Rhodococcus paraphyletic by creating the genus Prescottella for the sublineage containing the animal and human pathogen, Rhodococcus equi. Our approach did not support the mycobacterial five-genus split or the Prescottella nested genus, but identified a basal branch in each of the mycobacterial and rhodococcal radiations warranting genus status (Mycobacteroides, and novel genus Rhodococcoides for the Rhodococcus fascians clade, respectively). The median average amino acid identity (AAI) between the demarcated genera was 56% to 59%, consistent with the <65% AAI genus boundary standard. Shifting the demarcation threshold to the Prescottella/mycobacterial five-genus level systematically elevated the intrageneric sublineages to genus rank, leading to taxonomic atomization (≈threefold increase in potential Mycobacteriales genera). The proposed approach provides a standardizable methodological framework for non-subjective prokaryotic genus delineation. IMPORTANCE A robust taxonomy is essential for the organized study of prokaryotes and the effective communication of microbial knowledge. The genus rank is the mainstay of biological classification as it brings together under a common name a group of closely related organisms sharing the same recent ancestry and similar characteristics. Despite the unprecedented resolution afforded by whole-genome sequencing in defining evolutionary relationships, a consensus approach for phylogenomics-based prokaryotic genus delineation remains elusive. Taxonomists use different demarcation criteria, sometimes leading to genus rank over-splitting and the creation of multiple new genera. This work reports a simple, reliable, and standardizable method that seeks to minimize subjectivity in genomics-based demarcation of prokaryotic genera, exemplified through application to the order Mycobacteriales. Formal descriptions of proposed taxonomic changes based on our study are included. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-11T08:30:17Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-428dea5379204b32ba2d25f07075350e |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2150-7511 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-11T08:30:17Z |
| publishDate | 2023-10-01 |
| publisher | American Society for Microbiology |
| record_format | Article |
| series | mBio |
| spelling | doaj.art-428dea5379204b32ba2d25f07075350e2023-11-16T21:48:01ZengAmerican Society for MicrobiologymBio2150-75112023-10-0114510.1128/mbio.02207-23Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcationJorge Val-Calvo0José A. Vázquez-Boland1Microbial Pathogenesis Laboratory, Infection Medicine, Edinburgh Medical School (Biomedical Sciences), University of Edinburgh , Edinburgh, Scotland, United KingdomMicrobial Pathogenesis Laboratory, Infection Medicine, Edinburgh Medical School (Biomedical Sciences), University of Edinburgh , Edinburgh, Scotland, United KingdomABSTRACT Genomics allows accurately pinpointing microbial ancestry for taxonomic purposes, yet there is currently no consensus to genus definition based on genome data. Different metrics and criteria are used, with an increasing trend toward genera over-splitting. Here, we report a method for prokaryotic genus assignment that combines normalized tree clustering and network analysis of several genomic relatedness indices. Objectivity is maximized by linear application of the same partitioning thresholds across an entire middle/high taxonomic rank context (order level), with the classical (“pre-genomic”) genera as demarcation reference, ensuring continuity in taxonomy and nomenclature. We tested the method with the Mycobacteriales, where recent examples of genus fragmentation divided Mycobacterium into five genera, or made Rhodococcus paraphyletic by creating the genus Prescottella for the sublineage containing the animal and human pathogen, Rhodococcus equi. Our approach did not support the mycobacterial five-genus split or the Prescottella nested genus, but identified a basal branch in each of the mycobacterial and rhodococcal radiations warranting genus status (Mycobacteroides, and novel genus Rhodococcoides for the Rhodococcus fascians clade, respectively). The median average amino acid identity (AAI) between the demarcated genera was 56% to 59%, consistent with the <65% AAI genus boundary standard. Shifting the demarcation threshold to the Prescottella/mycobacterial five-genus level systematically elevated the intrageneric sublineages to genus rank, leading to taxonomic atomization (≈threefold increase in potential Mycobacteriales genera). The proposed approach provides a standardizable methodological framework for non-subjective prokaryotic genus delineation. IMPORTANCE A robust taxonomy is essential for the organized study of prokaryotes and the effective communication of microbial knowledge. The genus rank is the mainstay of biological classification as it brings together under a common name a group of closely related organisms sharing the same recent ancestry and similar characteristics. Despite the unprecedented resolution afforded by whole-genome sequencing in defining evolutionary relationships, a consensus approach for phylogenomics-based prokaryotic genus delineation remains elusive. Taxonomists use different demarcation criteria, sometimes leading to genus rank over-splitting and the creation of multiple new genera. This work reports a simple, reliable, and standardizable method that seeks to minimize subjectivity in genomics-based demarcation of prokaryotic genera, exemplified through application to the order Mycobacteriales. Formal descriptions of proposed taxonomic changes based on our study are included.https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.02207-23Mycobacteriales phylogenomicsprokaryotic genus definitiongenus demarcationRhodococcusRhodococcus equiPrescottella |
| spellingShingle | Jorge Val-Calvo José A. Vázquez-Boland Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation mBio Mycobacteriales phylogenomics prokaryotic genus definition genus demarcation Rhodococcus Rhodococcus equi Prescottella |
| title | Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation |
| title_full | Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation |
| title_fullStr | Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation |
| title_full_unstemmed | Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation |
| title_short | Mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis-aided, context-uniform phylogenomic approach for non-subjective genus demarcation |
| title_sort | mycobacteriales taxonomy using network analysis aided context uniform phylogenomic approach for non subjective genus demarcation |
| topic | Mycobacteriales phylogenomics prokaryotic genus definition genus demarcation Rhodococcus Rhodococcus equi Prescottella |
| url | https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.02207-23 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT jorgevalcalvo mycobacterialestaxonomyusingnetworkanalysisaidedcontextuniformphylogenomicapproachfornonsubjectivegenusdemarcation AT joseavazquezboland mycobacterialestaxonomyusingnetworkanalysisaidedcontextuniformphylogenomicapproachfornonsubjectivegenusdemarcation |