Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement
Cesáreo Trueba Vasavilbaso,1 Carlos David Rosas Bello,1 Erla Medina López,2 Maria Pilar Coronel Granado,3 José Mario Navarrete Álvarez,1 Cesáreo Angel Trueba Davalillo,4 Félix Isaac Gil Orbezo5 1Orthopedics Department, Hospital Espa&a...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Dove Medical Press
2017-09-01
|
| Series: | Open Access Rheumatology: Research and Reviews |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.dovepress.com/benefits-of-different-postoperative-treatments-in-patients-undergoing--peer-reviewed-article-OARRR |
| _version_ | 1818570620566241280 |
|---|---|
| author | Trueba Vasavilbaso C Rosas Bello CD Medina López E Coronel Granado MP Navarrete Álvarez JM Trueba Davalillo CA Gil Orbezo FI |
| author_facet | Trueba Vasavilbaso C Rosas Bello CD Medina López E Coronel Granado MP Navarrete Álvarez JM Trueba Davalillo CA Gil Orbezo FI |
| author_sort | Trueba Vasavilbaso C |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Cesáreo Trueba Vasavilbaso,1 Carlos David Rosas Bello,1 Erla Medina López,2 Maria Pilar Coronel Granado,3 José Mario Navarrete Álvarez,1 Cesáreo Angel Trueba Davalillo,4 Félix Isaac Gil Orbezo5 1Orthopedics Department, Hospital Español de México, Mexico DF, 2Orthopedics Department, Hospital Médica Sur, Mexico City, Mexico; 3International Development, Tedec Meiji Farma SA, Madrid, Spain; 4Orthopedics University Master (National University of Mexico, UNAM), 5Orthopedics Department, Hospital Español de México, Mexico City, Mexico Purpose: To assess the effectiveness of viscosupplementation or platelet-rich plasma (PRP), compared to standard care, for pain relief after knee arthroscopic debridement in patients with meniscal pathology and osteoarthritis (OA), under normal clinical practice conditions.Patients and methods: We conducted a prospective, randomized, evaluator-blind, pilot study. After arthroscopy, patients were randomized to receive 1) five injections of HA1 (Suprahyal®/Adant®); 2) four injections of HA2 (Orthovisc®); 3) three injections of HA3 (Synvisc®); 4) a single injection of PRP (GPS™ II); or 5) standard care (control). Patients were followed up for 18 months. Clinical outcomes were evaluated using the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC) at 3, 6, 12, and 18 months. Minimally Clinical Important Improvement (MCII), as relative improvement ≥20 for pain and function, was also calculated.Results: Fifty patients were included. At early follow-up (3 months), total WOMAC scores improved in all groups compared to baseline with reductions of 44.79% (HA1), 24.02% (HA2), 40.38% (HA3), 39.77% (PRP), and 27.64% (control) (p=0.002 HA1 compared to HA2). At 18 months, the higher improvement in total WOMAC was in HA1 with a 65.20% reduction, followed by PRP (55.01%), HA3 (49.57%), and HA2 (29.82%), whereas the control group had a 14.55% increase over baseline (p=0.001 control compared to HA1 and HA3). The percentage of patients achieving the MCII for both pain and function at 18 months was 100% (HA1), 80% (HA3), 60% (HA2), and 60% (PRP), whereas, in the control group, all patients returned to pre-arthroscopy levels. There were no adverse events attributable to surgery or to intraarticular administration.Conclusion: Viscosupplementation following arthroscopy is more effective than PRP in adequately selected patients with meniscal lesions occurring concomitantly with OA. Further controlled studies with a larger sample size and/or alternative regimens would be of interest for the scientific community. Keywords: arthroscopy, osteoarthritis, viscosupplementation, PRP |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-14T13:44:21Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-42be4d7d49dc4cf9aeb308b8dff46041 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1179-156X |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-14T13:44:21Z |
| publishDate | 2017-09-01 |
| publisher | Dove Medical Press |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Open Access Rheumatology: Research and Reviews |
| spelling | doaj.art-42be4d7d49dc4cf9aeb308b8dff460412022-12-21T22:59:21ZengDove Medical PressOpen Access Rheumatology: Research and Reviews1179-156X2017-09-01Volume 917117934873Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridementTrueba Vasavilbaso CRosas Bello CDMedina López ECoronel Granado MPNavarrete Álvarez JMTrueba Davalillo CAGil Orbezo FICesáreo Trueba Vasavilbaso,1 Carlos David Rosas Bello,1 Erla Medina López,2 Maria Pilar Coronel Granado,3 José Mario Navarrete Álvarez,1 Cesáreo Angel Trueba Davalillo,4 Félix Isaac Gil Orbezo5 1Orthopedics Department, Hospital Español de México, Mexico DF, 2Orthopedics Department, Hospital Médica Sur, Mexico City, Mexico; 3International Development, Tedec Meiji Farma SA, Madrid, Spain; 4Orthopedics University Master (National University of Mexico, UNAM), 5Orthopedics Department, Hospital Español de México, Mexico City, Mexico Purpose: To assess the effectiveness of viscosupplementation or platelet-rich plasma (PRP), compared to standard care, for pain relief after knee arthroscopic debridement in patients with meniscal pathology and osteoarthritis (OA), under normal clinical practice conditions.Patients and methods: We conducted a prospective, randomized, evaluator-blind, pilot study. After arthroscopy, patients were randomized to receive 1) five injections of HA1 (Suprahyal®/Adant®); 2) four injections of HA2 (Orthovisc®); 3) three injections of HA3 (Synvisc®); 4) a single injection of PRP (GPS™ II); or 5) standard care (control). Patients were followed up for 18 months. Clinical outcomes were evaluated using the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC) at 3, 6, 12, and 18 months. Minimally Clinical Important Improvement (MCII), as relative improvement ≥20 for pain and function, was also calculated.Results: Fifty patients were included. At early follow-up (3 months), total WOMAC scores improved in all groups compared to baseline with reductions of 44.79% (HA1), 24.02% (HA2), 40.38% (HA3), 39.77% (PRP), and 27.64% (control) (p=0.002 HA1 compared to HA2). At 18 months, the higher improvement in total WOMAC was in HA1 with a 65.20% reduction, followed by PRP (55.01%), HA3 (49.57%), and HA2 (29.82%), whereas the control group had a 14.55% increase over baseline (p=0.001 control compared to HA1 and HA3). The percentage of patients achieving the MCII for both pain and function at 18 months was 100% (HA1), 80% (HA3), 60% (HA2), and 60% (PRP), whereas, in the control group, all patients returned to pre-arthroscopy levels. There were no adverse events attributable to surgery or to intraarticular administration.Conclusion: Viscosupplementation following arthroscopy is more effective than PRP in adequately selected patients with meniscal lesions occurring concomitantly with OA. Further controlled studies with a larger sample size and/or alternative regimens would be of interest for the scientific community. Keywords: arthroscopy, osteoarthritis, viscosupplementation, PRPhttps://www.dovepress.com/benefits-of-different-postoperative-treatments-in-patients-undergoing--peer-reviewed-article-OARRRArthroscopyosteoarthritisviscosupplementationPRP |
| spellingShingle | Trueba Vasavilbaso C Rosas Bello CD Medina López E Coronel Granado MP Navarrete Álvarez JM Trueba Davalillo CA Gil Orbezo FI Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement Open Access Rheumatology: Research and Reviews Arthroscopy osteoarthritis viscosupplementation PRP |
| title | Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement |
| title_full | Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement |
| title_fullStr | Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement |
| title_full_unstemmed | Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement |
| title_short | Benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement |
| title_sort | benefits of different postoperative treatments in patients undergoing knee arthroscopic debridement |
| topic | Arthroscopy osteoarthritis viscosupplementation PRP |
| url | https://www.dovepress.com/benefits-of-different-postoperative-treatments-in-patients-undergoing--peer-reviewed-article-OARRR |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT truebavasavilbasoc benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement AT rosasbellocd benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement AT medinalopeze benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement AT coronelgranadomp benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement AT navarretealvarezjm benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement AT truebadavalilloca benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement AT gilorbezofi benefitsofdifferentpostoperativetreatmentsinpatientsundergoingkneearthroscopicdebridement |