The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India
Abstract Background Comprehensive commercial surrogacy became legal in India in 2002, and many foreigners, including individuals and same-sex couples, sought Indian surrogacy services due to their affordability. Numerous scandals resulted, with increasing calls for the government to eliminate the ex...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMC
2023-07-01
|
| Series: | Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1186/s13010-023-00130-y |
| _version_ | 1797784477553917952 |
|---|---|
| author | Yuri Hibino |
| author_facet | Yuri Hibino |
| author_sort | Yuri Hibino |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Background Comprehensive commercial surrogacy became legal in India in 2002, and many foreigners, including individuals and same-sex couples, sought Indian surrogacy services due to their affordability. Numerous scandals resulted, with increasing calls for the government to eliminate the exploitation of women in lower social strata. In 2015, the Indian government decided to exclude foreign clients and commercial surrogacy remained legal for local Indian couples only. Furthermore, to eliminate exploitation, the concept of altruistic surrogacy was introduced in 2016. In 2020, some restrictions within altruistic surrogacy practice were removed. Controversy remains, however, in various sectors, not least because surrogacy is a relatively new concept in India. In this paper, the advantages and disadvantages of both altruistic and commercial surrogacy in the Indian context are considered, and more appropriate policy concerning surrogacy practices is suggested. Methods This paper is based on fieldwork conducted in India from 2010 to 2018. Interview surveys were conducted among doctors, policy makers, activists, former surrogates, and brokers. Government documents and media reports were also important sources. Results Surrogacy for commercial purposes began in India in 2002, and stakeholders within the commercial surrogacy industry became well established. It was found that such stakeholders were strongly opposed to altruistic surrogacy as introduced in 2016. It was also found that women in lower social strata still sought some form of financial compensation from their reproductive labor. Controversies surrounding altruistic surrogacy continue within Indian society. Conclusion Policies and practices aimed at eliminating exploitive need to consider the Indian context carefully. Any surrogacy practice might potentially be exploitive, and the distinction between commercial and altruistic surrogacy is too simplistic to be useful, with more nuanced understanding required. It is of critical importance that investigation continues on how to eliminate the exploitation of Indian surrogate mothers throughout the process, regardless of monetary compensation. The entire surrogacy process should be managed with sensitivity, particularly in relation to the well-being of the mother and child. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-13T00:40:28Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-432c8c6128db49c8b0196a927335fae0 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1747-5341 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-13T00:40:28Z |
| publishDate | 2023-07-01 |
| publisher | BMC |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine |
| spelling | doaj.art-432c8c6128db49c8b0196a927335fae02023-07-09T11:20:51ZengBMCPhilosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine1747-53412023-07-0118111010.1186/s13010-023-00130-yThe advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in IndiaYuri Hibino0College of Philosophy in Interdisciplinary Sciences, Kanazawa UniversityAbstract Background Comprehensive commercial surrogacy became legal in India in 2002, and many foreigners, including individuals and same-sex couples, sought Indian surrogacy services due to their affordability. Numerous scandals resulted, with increasing calls for the government to eliminate the exploitation of women in lower social strata. In 2015, the Indian government decided to exclude foreign clients and commercial surrogacy remained legal for local Indian couples only. Furthermore, to eliminate exploitation, the concept of altruistic surrogacy was introduced in 2016. In 2020, some restrictions within altruistic surrogacy practice were removed. Controversy remains, however, in various sectors, not least because surrogacy is a relatively new concept in India. In this paper, the advantages and disadvantages of both altruistic and commercial surrogacy in the Indian context are considered, and more appropriate policy concerning surrogacy practices is suggested. Methods This paper is based on fieldwork conducted in India from 2010 to 2018. Interview surveys were conducted among doctors, policy makers, activists, former surrogates, and brokers. Government documents and media reports were also important sources. Results Surrogacy for commercial purposes began in India in 2002, and stakeholders within the commercial surrogacy industry became well established. It was found that such stakeholders were strongly opposed to altruistic surrogacy as introduced in 2016. It was also found that women in lower social strata still sought some form of financial compensation from their reproductive labor. Controversies surrounding altruistic surrogacy continue within Indian society. Conclusion Policies and practices aimed at eliminating exploitive need to consider the Indian context carefully. Any surrogacy practice might potentially be exploitive, and the distinction between commercial and altruistic surrogacy is too simplistic to be useful, with more nuanced understanding required. It is of critical importance that investigation continues on how to eliminate the exploitation of Indian surrogate mothers throughout the process, regardless of monetary compensation. The entire surrogacy process should be managed with sensitivity, particularly in relation to the well-being of the mother and child.https://doi.org/10.1186/s13010-023-00130-yIndiaCommercial surrogacyAltruistic surrogacyExploitationRegulation |
| spellingShingle | Yuri Hibino The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine India Commercial surrogacy Altruistic surrogacy Exploitation Regulation |
| title | The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India |
| title_full | The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India |
| title_fullStr | The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India |
| title_full_unstemmed | The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India |
| title_short | The advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in India |
| title_sort | advantages and disadvantages of altruistic and commercial surrogacy in india |
| topic | India Commercial surrogacy Altruistic surrogacy Exploitation Regulation |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1186/s13010-023-00130-y |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT yurihibino theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofaltruisticandcommercialsurrogacyinindia AT yurihibino advantagesanddisadvantagesofaltruisticandcommercialsurrogacyinindia |