Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’
The Arundel Clay of Maryland is among the only Early Cretaceous terrestrial units known from eastern North America. Research on some theropod dinosaur bones from this layer has indicated the presence of two ornithomimosaur taxa in the assemblage. However, a recent paper discussed issues with the def...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
University of Alberta Libraries
2018-07-01
|
| Series: | Vertebrate Anatomy, Morphology, Palaeontology |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://journals-clone.library.ualberta.ca/vamp/index.php/VAMP/article/view/29340 |
| _version_ | 1828053197010239488 |
|---|---|
| author | Chase Doran Brownstein |
| author_facet | Chase Doran Brownstein |
| author_sort | Chase Doran Brownstein |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | The Arundel Clay of Maryland is among the only Early Cretaceous terrestrial units known from eastern North America. Research on some theropod dinosaur bones from this layer has indicated the presence of two ornithomimosaur taxa in the assemblage. However, a recent paper discussed issues with the definite assignment of any of these unguals to Ornithomimosauria and suggested that morphological differences originally interpreted to be indicative of the presence of two ornithomimosaurs could be explained by positional variation. Here, I show that substantial evidence persists for the presence of two ornithomimosaurs in the Arundel Clay assemblage, even considering the recent description of positional variation in ornithomimosaur pedal unguals. Furthermore, the argument against the confident assignment of these unguals to ornithomimosaurs is shown to be based on oversimplified comparisons that do not take into account the combination of features in the Arundel specimens that allow for their assignment to that clade. Although several small points made in the initial paper describing the Arundel specimens are incorrect or unsubstantiated, the differences between the Maryland unguals are outside the spectrum of positional variation and are indicative of the presence of two ornithomimosaurs in the Arundel Clay assemblage.
|
| first_indexed | 2024-04-10T20:03:30Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-465ba151f91d4f489bdc2fe362583854 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2292-1389 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-10T20:03:30Z |
| publishDate | 2018-07-01 |
| publisher | University of Alberta Libraries |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Vertebrate Anatomy, Morphology, Palaeontology |
| spelling | doaj.art-465ba151f91d4f489bdc2fe3625838542023-01-26T20:57:46ZengUniversity of Alberta LibrariesVertebrate Anatomy, Morphology, Palaeontology2292-13892018-07-016Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’Chase Doran Brownstein0Stamford Museum and Nature CenterThe Arundel Clay of Maryland is among the only Early Cretaceous terrestrial units known from eastern North America. Research on some theropod dinosaur bones from this layer has indicated the presence of two ornithomimosaur taxa in the assemblage. However, a recent paper discussed issues with the definite assignment of any of these unguals to Ornithomimosauria and suggested that morphological differences originally interpreted to be indicative of the presence of two ornithomimosaurs could be explained by positional variation. Here, I show that substantial evidence persists for the presence of two ornithomimosaurs in the Arundel Clay assemblage, even considering the recent description of positional variation in ornithomimosaur pedal unguals. Furthermore, the argument against the confident assignment of these unguals to ornithomimosaurs is shown to be based on oversimplified comparisons that do not take into account the combination of features in the Arundel specimens that allow for their assignment to that clade. Although several small points made in the initial paper describing the Arundel specimens are incorrect or unsubstantiated, the differences between the Maryland unguals are outside the spectrum of positional variation and are indicative of the presence of two ornithomimosaurs in the Arundel Clay assemblage. https://journals-clone.library.ualberta.ca/vamp/index.php/VAMP/article/view/29340CretaceousOrnithomimosauriaDinosauriaArundel Clay |
| spellingShingle | Chase Doran Brownstein Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’ Vertebrate Anatomy, Morphology, Palaeontology Cretaceous Ornithomimosauria Dinosauria Arundel Clay |
| title | Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’ |
| title_full | Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’ |
| title_fullStr | Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’ |
| title_full_unstemmed | Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’ |
| title_short | Rebuttal of McFeeters, Ryan and Cullen, 2018, ‘Positional variation in pedal unguals of North American ornithomimids (Dinosauria, Theropoda): A Response to Brownstein (2017)’ |
| title_sort | rebuttal of mcfeeters ryan and cullen 2018 positional variation in pedal unguals of north american ornithomimids dinosauria theropoda a response to brownstein 2017 |
| topic | Cretaceous Ornithomimosauria Dinosauria Arundel Clay |
| url | https://journals-clone.library.ualberta.ca/vamp/index.php/VAMP/article/view/29340 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT chasedoranbrownstein rebuttalofmcfeetersryanandcullen2018positionalvariationinpedalungualsofnorthamericanornithomimidsdinosauriatheropodaaresponsetobrownstein2017 |