Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base
The article deals the analysis of arguments, adduced by seismologist Andrei Nikonov for benefit of hypothesis of destructive earthquake in Crimea in 11th century. Arguments were put forward in a joint article with Inna Antonova «Vestiges of destructive earthquakes in Chersonesos and its outskirts in...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | Bulgarian |
| Published: |
Nizhnevartovsk State University
2011-12-01
|
| Series: | Материалы по археологии и истории античного и средневекового Крыма |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/gipoteza-a-a-nikonova-o-razrushitelnom-zemletryasenii-1041-g-v-krymu-k-voprosu-o-dostovernosti-istochnikovoy-bazy |
| _version_ | 1828894411419811840 |
|---|---|
| author | V.V. Khapaev |
| author_facet | V.V. Khapaev |
| author_sort | V.V. Khapaev |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | The article deals the analysis of arguments, adduced by seismologist Andrei Nikonov for benefit of hypothesis of destructive earthquake in Crimea in 11th century. Arguments were put forward in a joint article with Inna Antonova «Vestiges of destructive earthquakes in Chersonesos and its outskirts in the Roman time and Early Medieval period». The author arrives at a conclusion that A. Nikonov arguments are based on fallacious using of archeological data and relocation of artifacts dated to different times (from 5th till 19th centuries) to the 11th century to prove the hypothesis of earthquake. The A. Nikonov dating of this earthquake by 1041 as it was supposedly mentioned by John Skilitsa in the story of Peter Delean revolt is also criticized. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-13T14:10:56Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-4a548db44d984a6aa5f4ab69b274a841 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2219-8857 |
| language | Bulgarian |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-13T14:10:56Z |
| publishDate | 2011-12-01 |
| publisher | Nizhnevartovsk State University |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Материалы по археологии и истории античного и средневекового Крыма |
| spelling | doaj.art-4a548db44d984a6aa5f4ab69b274a8412022-12-21T23:42:28ZbulNizhnevartovsk State UniversityМатериалы по археологии и истории античного и средневекового Крыма2219-88572011-12-013275303Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source baseV.V. KhapaevThe article deals the analysis of arguments, adduced by seismologist Andrei Nikonov for benefit of hypothesis of destructive earthquake in Crimea in 11th century. Arguments were put forward in a joint article with Inna Antonova «Vestiges of destructive earthquakes in Chersonesos and its outskirts in the Roman time and Early Medieval period». The author arrives at a conclusion that A. Nikonov arguments are based on fallacious using of archeological data and relocation of artifacts dated to different times (from 5th till 19th centuries) to the 11th century to prove the hypothesis of earthquake. The A. Nikonov dating of this earthquake by 1041 as it was supposedly mentioned by John Skilitsa in the story of Peter Delean revolt is also criticized.https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/gipoteza-a-a-nikonova-o-razrushitelnom-zemletryasenii-1041-g-v-krymu-k-voprosu-o-dostovernosti-istochnikovoy-bazyArchaeologyMedieval CrimeaHistoryGeography |
| spellingShingle | V.V. Khapaev Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base Материалы по археологии и истории античного и средневекового Крыма Archaeology Medieval Crimea History Geography |
| title | Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base |
| title_full | Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base |
| title_fullStr | Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base |
| title_full_unstemmed | Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base |
| title_short | Гипотеза А.А. Никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г. в Крыму: к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы / Hypothesis of A.A. Nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the Crimea: the question of the reliability of the source base |
| title_sort | гипотеза а а никонова о разрушительном землетрясении 1041 г в крыму к вопросу о достоверности источниковой базы hypothesis of a a nikonov of the devastating earthquake in 1041 in the crimea the question of the reliability of the source base |
| topic | Archaeology Medieval Crimea History Geography |
| url | https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/gipoteza-a-a-nikonova-o-razrushitelnom-zemletryasenii-1041-g-v-krymu-k-voprosu-o-dostovernosti-istochnikovoy-bazy |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT vvkhapaev gipotezaaanikonovaorazrušitelʹnomzemletrâsenii1041gvkrymukvoprosuodostovernostiistočnikovojbazyhypothesisofaanikonovofthedevastatingearthquakein1041inthecrimeathequestionofthereliabilityofthesourcebase |