Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author?
This article is aimed at investigating the 1806 Map of Tobolsk Governorate, which has been presented to a wider research community relatively recently. This is a unique source indicating the exact location of the grave of Ermak (the first Russian conqueror of Siberia). On the «Plan of a location nea...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | Russian |
| Published: |
Tyumen Scientific Centre SB RA
2018-09-01
|
| Series: | Вестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://www.ipdn.ru/va-en/_private/a42/enga42-1-6.htm |
| _version_ | 1818753032880390144 |
|---|---|
| author | Adamov А.А. |
| author_facet | Adamov А.А. |
| author_sort | Adamov А.А. |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | This article is aimed at investigating the 1806 Map of Tobolsk Governorate, which has been presented to a wider research community relatively recently. This is a unique source indicating the exact location of the grave of Ermak (the first Russian conqueror of Siberia). On the «Plan of a location near the Irtysh river, the Vagay river and other lakes and rivers...», a provincial land surveyor V. Filimonov put a sign indicating a dry Siberian pine 10 yards from the tomb of Ermak. In an extensive text on the map, Filimonov in his own words outlined the details of G.F. Miller’s data referring to the last battle of Ermak and the details of his burial. This text was supplemented by information obtained from the local Tatar population. At the same time, as a conscientious researcher, he clearly delineated the narration of G.F. Miller’s works from the gathered data. In recent articles, I.V. Belich has made an assumption that V. Filimonov forged the historic source by changing Miller’s text and unreasonably mapped the location of Ermak’s grave near Begishevо Yurts. However, a careful analysis of the explanatory text to the map has not confirmed this assumption. In addition, there is no proof for suppositions about Filimonov’s grabbing habit and the disclosure of the forgery back in the 19th century. Archaeological excavations conducted on the site of the alleged grave of Ermak have failed to confirm the statement that local residents just pointed to V. Filimonov at a medieval burial ground or the location of a revered tree. At the same time, the map analysis shows that it was drawn by a professional, who indicated Ermak’s burial place based on the information having been obtained from local residents. As any other historical source, this map undeniably requires a comprehensive re-examination and criticism. However, this should be a scientific criticism, rather than mere accusations against its author. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-18T05:00:55Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-55b99869c8ca4605955eb7776c684bea |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1811-7465 2071-0437 |
| language | Russian |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-18T05:00:55Z |
| publishDate | 2018-09-01 |
| publisher | Tyumen Scientific Centre SB RA |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Вестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии |
| spelling | doaj.art-55b99869c8ca4605955eb7776c684bea2022-12-21T21:20:09ZrusTyumen Scientific Centre SB RAВестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии1811-74652071-04372018-09-013(42)657110.20874/2071-0437-2018-42-3-065-071Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author?Adamov А.А.0Tobolsk Complex Scientific Station of the Ural Branch of the RASThis article is aimed at investigating the 1806 Map of Tobolsk Governorate, which has been presented to a wider research community relatively recently. This is a unique source indicating the exact location of the grave of Ermak (the first Russian conqueror of Siberia). On the «Plan of a location near the Irtysh river, the Vagay river and other lakes and rivers...», a provincial land surveyor V. Filimonov put a sign indicating a dry Siberian pine 10 yards from the tomb of Ermak. In an extensive text on the map, Filimonov in his own words outlined the details of G.F. Miller’s data referring to the last battle of Ermak and the details of his burial. This text was supplemented by information obtained from the local Tatar population. At the same time, as a conscientious researcher, he clearly delineated the narration of G.F. Miller’s works from the gathered data. In recent articles, I.V. Belich has made an assumption that V. Filimonov forged the historic source by changing Miller’s text and unreasonably mapped the location of Ermak’s grave near Begishevо Yurts. However, a careful analysis of the explanatory text to the map has not confirmed this assumption. In addition, there is no proof for suppositions about Filimonov’s grabbing habit and the disclosure of the forgery back in the 19th century. Archaeological excavations conducted on the site of the alleged grave of Ermak have failed to confirm the statement that local residents just pointed to V. Filimonov at a medieval burial ground or the location of a revered tree. At the same time, the map analysis shows that it was drawn by a professional, who indicated Ermak’s burial place based on the information having been obtained from local residents. As any other historical source, this map undeniably requires a comprehensive re-examination and criticism. However, this should be a scientific criticism, rather than mere accusations against its author.http://www.ipdn.ru/va-en/_private/a42/enga42-1-6.htmMap of Tobolsk Governorate of 1806land surveyor V. FilimonovErmak’s graveS.U. RemezovG.F. MillerSiberian Tartars |
| spellingShingle | Adamov А.А. Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author? Вестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии Map of Tobolsk Governorate of 1806 land surveyor V. Filimonov Ermak’s grave S.U. Remezov G.F. Miller Siberian Tartars |
| title | Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author? |
| title_full | Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author? |
| title_fullStr | Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author? |
| title_full_unstemmed | Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author? |
| title_short | Tobolsk Governorate Map of 1806: a sourse for searching Ermak’s grave or falsification of its author? |
| title_sort | tobolsk governorate map of 1806 a sourse for searching ermak s grave or falsification of its author |
| topic | Map of Tobolsk Governorate of 1806 land surveyor V. Filimonov Ermak’s grave S.U. Remezov G.F. Miller Siberian Tartars |
| url | http://www.ipdn.ru/va-en/_private/a42/enga42-1-6.htm |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT adamovaa tobolskgovernoratemapof1806asourseforsearchingermaksgraveorfalsificationofitsauthor |