An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City)
Introduction On the verge of entering the third millennium, very fast evolutions have been occurred in human societies which apart from profits accompanied with serious damages too. Available documents and evidence indicated that the main driver for these evolutions has been industrial revolution an...
| Main Authors: | , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | fas |
| Published: |
University of Tabriz
2021-04-01
|
| Series: | نشریه جغرافیا و برنامهریزی |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://geoplanning.tabrizu.ac.ir/article_12790_5fca9db4d67e1efae5535ae3c9d4d36c.pdf |
| _version_ | 1797256846147321856 |
|---|---|
| author | Samad Medadi Heris Mohammad Reza Pourmohammadi Mirsattar Sadre Mousavi Shahrivar Rostaei |
| author_facet | Samad Medadi Heris Mohammad Reza Pourmohammadi Mirsattar Sadre Mousavi Shahrivar Rostaei |
| author_sort | Samad Medadi Heris |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Introduction On the verge of entering the third millennium, very fast evolutions have been occurred in human societies which apart from profits accompanied with serious damages too. Available documents and evidence indicated that the main driver for these evolutions has been industrial revolution and its resulted effects as fallowing to apply machine in human societies and using electronic devices resulted from this revolution we were witness of accelerating resource consumption from one hand and on the other hand with development of medical science and applying technology in manufacturing medical devices, deaths have been decreased and subsequently population has increased. With high rate of fertility and immigration from rural to city areas, especially cities of developing countries in recent decades have been expanded dramatically. At civil levels, with economic, social and cultural evolution of 19th and 20th centuries affected from modernism is caused genesis of metropolises and generated fundamental changes in the their structure and spatial-physical organization. Looking at this situation, a new approach for sustainable development has been proposed at international level that controlling development and determining restrictions are among its objectives align with human society welfare and controlling damages to the environment. Given to the course of the evolutions in the theoretical and practical domain of the cities under the influence of new paradigm, meeting needs is a requisite for life environment in addition personal welfare and high quality of life are required and necessary too. Considering to sustainable development theory, some emphasize confidently that environment, society and economical subjects should be considered for the unpredictable future of the environment. Data and Method The current study is descriptive- analytical which has been conducted using effective indicators in sustainability of residential environment using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and entropy Model. Available methods and models for selection and evaluation are categorized in two general groups: 1- flat models 2- hierarchical models. One of the models in this regard is fuzzy analytic hierarchy model. Fuzzy analytic hierarchy approach is an expanded AHP approach. Table No. (1): Expert weighting of indicators and criteria In this study various data from different aspects of the sustainable (environmental, economic, social and physical) development has been collected. In scientific studies one of the well-known methods that is widely used to solve multi criteria decision making problems is fuzzy AHP. Accordingly, if fuzzy values were triangular numbers which are shown as (mi, li, ui) then it can be calculated using below equation.Entropy in data theory is a measure of unreliability which is specified with probability distribution (p < sub>i) and measuring this unreliability () by Shanon has been stated as below in which the greater dispersion in the values of an indicator, the more important that indicator is. Results and Discussion Due to the importance of sustainability in development and sustainable development in recent years, so many investigations have been done in various domains and in dimensions such as economical, environmental and physical ones. According to the results obtained from this study, physical criterion which includes (construct, accessibility and vicinity) is the main criterion considered by experts with numerical weight of 0.544. Social, economic and environmental dimensions are respectively at next level of priority. For the same reason physical dimension is emphasized as the main influential factor in Tabriz sustainable development in this study. At the next step dimensions of sustainable development were analyzed and the role that each dimension plays on civil areas was studied and below conclusions were obtained: Of 66 indices for analysing sustainable development dimensions in Tabriz city, 7 indices belonged to economic dimension, 14 to social dimension, 8 to environmental dimensions and remaining are applied for physical dimension that the obtained results are summarized as below: At economic dimension districts 4, 1 and 2 with scores of 6.14, 5.46 and 4.95 scores obtained first, second and third scores of indicators and district 10 gained the lowest score. Conclusion Sustainable development is the dominant paradigm in the third millennium. This theory has been expanded in proposed period of time with a glance to environmental discussion and with the aim of preventing environmental deterioration and has been drawn to different discussions after passing a short time. Sustainable development encounters with inappropriate production, distribution and nature destructive pattern that its final purpose is to control environmental damages and increasing the quality of life. This study has been conducted with the aim of prioritizing sustainable development dimensions at the first stage and weighting civil districts based on the same dimensions. The results obtained from this study indicated that physical dimension is at the first priority among other dimensions. |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-24T22:28:14Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-5c5d8b9ca8c546c083eba5945ef1441b |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2008-8078 2717-3534 |
| language | fas |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-24T22:28:14Z |
| publishDate | 2021-04-01 |
| publisher | University of Tabriz |
| record_format | Article |
| series | نشریه جغرافیا و برنامهریزی |
| spelling | doaj.art-5c5d8b9ca8c546c083eba5945ef1441b2024-03-19T22:10:42ZfasUniversity of Tabrizنشریه جغرافیا و برنامهریزی2008-80782717-35342021-04-01257524526010.22034/gp.2021.1279012790An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City)Samad Medadi Heris0Mohammad Reza Pourmohammadi1Mirsattar Sadre Mousavi2Shahrivar Rostaei3PhD student of geography and Urban Planning University of TabrizProfessor Department of geography and urban planning, Faculty of planning and Environmental Sciences, University of TabrizProfessor Department of geography and Rural planning, Faculty of planning and Environmental Sciences, University of TabrizAssociate Professor Department of geography and Urban planning, Faculty of planning and Environmental Sciences, University of TabrizIntroduction On the verge of entering the third millennium, very fast evolutions have been occurred in human societies which apart from profits accompanied with serious damages too. Available documents and evidence indicated that the main driver for these evolutions has been industrial revolution and its resulted effects as fallowing to apply machine in human societies and using electronic devices resulted from this revolution we were witness of accelerating resource consumption from one hand and on the other hand with development of medical science and applying technology in manufacturing medical devices, deaths have been decreased and subsequently population has increased. With high rate of fertility and immigration from rural to city areas, especially cities of developing countries in recent decades have been expanded dramatically. At civil levels, with economic, social and cultural evolution of 19th and 20th centuries affected from modernism is caused genesis of metropolises and generated fundamental changes in the their structure and spatial-physical organization. Looking at this situation, a new approach for sustainable development has been proposed at international level that controlling development and determining restrictions are among its objectives align with human society welfare and controlling damages to the environment. Given to the course of the evolutions in the theoretical and practical domain of the cities under the influence of new paradigm, meeting needs is a requisite for life environment in addition personal welfare and high quality of life are required and necessary too. Considering to sustainable development theory, some emphasize confidently that environment, society and economical subjects should be considered for the unpredictable future of the environment. Data and Method The current study is descriptive- analytical which has been conducted using effective indicators in sustainability of residential environment using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and entropy Model. Available methods and models for selection and evaluation are categorized in two general groups: 1- flat models 2- hierarchical models. One of the models in this regard is fuzzy analytic hierarchy model. Fuzzy analytic hierarchy approach is an expanded AHP approach. Table No. (1): Expert weighting of indicators and criteria In this study various data from different aspects of the sustainable (environmental, economic, social and physical) development has been collected. In scientific studies one of the well-known methods that is widely used to solve multi criteria decision making problems is fuzzy AHP. Accordingly, if fuzzy values were triangular numbers which are shown as (mi, li, ui) then it can be calculated using below equation.Entropy in data theory is a measure of unreliability which is specified with probability distribution (p < sub>i) and measuring this unreliability () by Shanon has been stated as below in which the greater dispersion in the values of an indicator, the more important that indicator is. Results and Discussion Due to the importance of sustainability in development and sustainable development in recent years, so many investigations have been done in various domains and in dimensions such as economical, environmental and physical ones. According to the results obtained from this study, physical criterion which includes (construct, accessibility and vicinity) is the main criterion considered by experts with numerical weight of 0.544. Social, economic and environmental dimensions are respectively at next level of priority. For the same reason physical dimension is emphasized as the main influential factor in Tabriz sustainable development in this study. At the next step dimensions of sustainable development were analyzed and the role that each dimension plays on civil areas was studied and below conclusions were obtained: Of 66 indices for analysing sustainable development dimensions in Tabriz city, 7 indices belonged to economic dimension, 14 to social dimension, 8 to environmental dimensions and remaining are applied for physical dimension that the obtained results are summarized as below: At economic dimension districts 4, 1 and 2 with scores of 6.14, 5.46 and 4.95 scores obtained first, second and third scores of indicators and district 10 gained the lowest score. Conclusion Sustainable development is the dominant paradigm in the third millennium. This theory has been expanded in proposed period of time with a glance to environmental discussion and with the aim of preventing environmental deterioration and has been drawn to different discussions after passing a short time. Sustainable development encounters with inappropriate production, distribution and nature destructive pattern that its final purpose is to control environmental damages and increasing the quality of life. This study has been conducted with the aim of prioritizing sustainable development dimensions at the first stage and weighting civil districts based on the same dimensions. The results obtained from this study indicated that physical dimension is at the first priority among other dimensions.https://geoplanning.tabrizu.ac.ir/article_12790_5fca9db4d67e1efae5535ae3c9d4d36c.pdfprioritizationresidential environmentsustainabilityfuzzy ahp methodentropy techniqueindicators |
| spellingShingle | Samad Medadi Heris Mohammad Reza Pourmohammadi Mirsattar Sadre Mousavi Shahrivar Rostaei An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City) نشریه جغرافیا و برنامهریزی prioritization residential environment sustainability fuzzy ahp method entropy technique indicators |
| title | An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City) |
| title_full | An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City) |
| title_fullStr | An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City) |
| title_full_unstemmed | An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City) |
| title_short | An Analysis on Prioritizing Effective indicators on Development of Sustainable Residential Environment Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Entropy Model (Case Study: Tabriz City) |
| title_sort | analysis on prioritizing effective indicators on development of sustainable residential environment using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and entropy model case study tabriz city |
| topic | prioritization residential environment sustainability fuzzy ahp method entropy technique indicators |
| url | https://geoplanning.tabrizu.ac.ir/article_12790_5fca9db4d67e1efae5535ae3c9d4d36c.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT samadmedadiheris ananalysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT mohammadrezapourmohammadi ananalysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT mirsattarsadremousavi ananalysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT shahrivarrostaei ananalysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT samadmedadiheris analysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT mohammadrezapourmohammadi analysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT mirsattarsadremousavi analysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity AT shahrivarrostaei analysisonprioritizingeffectiveindicatorsondevelopmentofsustainableresidentialenvironmentusingfuzzyanalytichierarchyprocessandentropymodelcasestudytabrizcity |