The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>)
<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Immediate blood testing for patients presenting with unexplained complaints in family practice is superfluous from a diagnostic point of view. However, many general pracitioners (GPs) order tests immediately. Watchful waiting reduces...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMC
2012-04-01
|
| Series: | Implementation Science |
| Online Access: | http://www.implementationscience.com/content/7/1/29 |
| _version_ | 1819027081577627648 |
|---|---|
| author | van Bokhoven Marloes A Koch Hèlen van der Weijden Trudy Weekers-Muyres Anuska HM Bindels Patrick JE Grol Richard PTM Dinant Geert-Jan |
| author_facet | van Bokhoven Marloes A Koch Hèlen van der Weijden Trudy Weekers-Muyres Anuska HM Bindels Patrick JE Grol Richard PTM Dinant Geert-Jan |
| author_sort | van Bokhoven Marloes A |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | <p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Immediate blood testing for patients presenting with unexplained complaints in family practice is superfluous from a diagnostic point of view. However, many general pracitioners (GPs) order tests immediately. Watchful waiting reduces the number of patients to be tested and the number of false-positive results. The objectives of this study are: to determine the feasibility of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering; to determine if a special quality improvement strategy can improve this feasibility; and to determine if watchful waiting leads to testing at a later time.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>The study is a cluster-randomized clinical trial with three groups, on blood test ordering strategies in patients with unexplained complaints. GPs in group one were instructed to order tests immediately and GPs in group two to apply a watchful waiting approach. GPs in group three received the same instruction as group two, but they were supported by a systematically designed quality improvement strategy. A total of 498 patients with unexplained complaints from 63 practices of Dutch GPs participated. We measured: the percentage of patients for whom tests were ordered and number of tests ordered at the first consultation; performance on the strategy's performance objectives (i.e., ordering fewer tests and specific communication skills); the number of tests ordered after four weeks; and GP and patient characteristics.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>Immediate test ordering proved feasible in 92% of the patients; watchful waiting in 86% and 84%, respectively, for groups two and three. The two watchful waiting groups did not differ significantly in the achievement of any of the performance objectives. Of the patients who returned after four weeks, none from group one and six from the two watchful waiting groups had tests ordered for them.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p>Watchful waiting is a feasible approach. It does not lead to testing immediately afterwards. Furthermore, watchful waiting was not improved by the quality improvement strategy.</p> <p>Trial registration</p> <p>Clinical trial registration: <a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a></p> |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-21T05:36:48Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-5f0b81b9abc84eaab7659a494742d0fe |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1748-5908 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-21T05:36:48Z |
| publishDate | 2012-04-01 |
| publisher | BMC |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Implementation Science |
| spelling | doaj.art-5f0b81b9abc84eaab7659a494742d0fe2022-12-21T19:14:23ZengBMCImplementation Science1748-59082012-04-01712910.1186/1748-5908-7-29The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>)van Bokhoven Marloes AKoch Hèlenvan der Weijden TrudyWeekers-Muyres Anuska HMBindels Patrick JEGrol Richard PTMDinant Geert-Jan<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Immediate blood testing for patients presenting with unexplained complaints in family practice is superfluous from a diagnostic point of view. However, many general pracitioners (GPs) order tests immediately. Watchful waiting reduces the number of patients to be tested and the number of false-positive results. The objectives of this study are: to determine the feasibility of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering; to determine if a special quality improvement strategy can improve this feasibility; and to determine if watchful waiting leads to testing at a later time.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>The study is a cluster-randomized clinical trial with three groups, on blood test ordering strategies in patients with unexplained complaints. GPs in group one were instructed to order tests immediately and GPs in group two to apply a watchful waiting approach. GPs in group three received the same instruction as group two, but they were supported by a systematically designed quality improvement strategy. A total of 498 patients with unexplained complaints from 63 practices of Dutch GPs participated. We measured: the percentage of patients for whom tests were ordered and number of tests ordered at the first consultation; performance on the strategy's performance objectives (i.e., ordering fewer tests and specific communication skills); the number of tests ordered after four weeks; and GP and patient characteristics.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>Immediate test ordering proved feasible in 92% of the patients; watchful waiting in 86% and 84%, respectively, for groups two and three. The two watchful waiting groups did not differ significantly in the achievement of any of the performance objectives. Of the patients who returned after four weeks, none from group one and six from the two watchful waiting groups had tests ordered for them.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p>Watchful waiting is a feasible approach. It does not lead to testing immediately afterwards. Furthermore, watchful waiting was not improved by the quality improvement strategy.</p> <p>Trial registration</p> <p>Clinical trial registration: <a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a></p>http://www.implementationscience.com/content/7/1/29 |
| spellingShingle | van Bokhoven Marloes A Koch Hèlen van der Weijden Trudy Weekers-Muyres Anuska HM Bindels Patrick JE Grol Richard PTM Dinant Geert-Jan The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>) Implementation Science |
| title | The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>) |
| title_full | The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>) |
| title_fullStr | The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>) |
| title_full_unstemmed | The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>) |
| title_short | The effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners' blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints; a randomized clinical trial (<a href="http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN55755886">ISRCTN55755886</a>) |
| title_sort | effect of watchful waiting compared to immediate test ordering instructions on general practitioners blood test ordering behaviour for patients with unexplained complaints a randomized clinical trial a href http www controlled trials com isrctn55755886 isrctn55755886 a |
| url | http://www.implementationscience.com/content/7/1/29 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT vanbokhovenmarloesa theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT kochhelen theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT vanderweijdentrudy theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT weekersmuyresanuskahm theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT bindelspatrickje theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT grolrichardptm theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT dinantgeertjan theeffectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT vanbokhovenmarloesa effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT kochhelen effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT vanderweijdentrudy effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT weekersmuyresanuskahm effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT bindelspatrickje effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT grolrichardptm effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a AT dinantgeertjan effectofwatchfulwaitingcomparedtoimmediatetestorderinginstructionsongeneralpractitionersbloodtestorderingbehaviourforpatientswithunexplainedcomplaintsarandomizedclinicaltrialahrefhttpwwwcontrolledtrialscomisrctn55755886isrctn55755886a |