Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students

A review of: Curry, Ann and Deborah Copeman. “Reference Service to International Students: A Field Stimulation Research Study.” Journal of Academic Librarianship 31.5 (Sep. 2005): 409-20. Objective – To evaluate the quality of reference service provided to non-native, English-speaking intern...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Lorie Andrea Kloda
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: University of Alberta 2006-12-01
Series:Evidence Based Library and Information Practice
Online Access:https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/eblip/index.php/EBLIP/article/view/100
_version_ 1819261901785268224
author Lorie Andrea Kloda
author_facet Lorie Andrea Kloda
author_sort Lorie Andrea Kloda
collection DOAJ
description A review of: Curry, Ann and Deborah Copeman. “Reference Service to International Students: A Field Stimulation Research Study.” Journal of Academic Librarianship 31.5 (Sep. 2005): 409-20. Objective – To evaluate the quality of reference service provided to non-native, English-speaking international students in academic libraries. Design – Field stimulation (unobtrusive testing). Setting – Eleven college and university libraries in the lower mainland of British Columbia, Canada, in the fall of 2003. Subjects – Library staff offering reference service at one of the participating libraries. Methods – The study utilized field stimulation, whereby an individual, or “proxy,” posed as a library user and initiated a reference encounter with library staff at each institution. In each case the proxy asked the same question to the library staff member. After the interaction was completed the proxy recorded all observed behaviours. Data were collected using a checklist of actions; a narrative record written by the proxy; and several evaluative questions. Each library was visited by the same proxy on two separate occasions for a total of 22 visits, of which 20 instances resulted in usable data. The narrative recordings of the reference encounters were analyzed using an open coding process. Main results – In 75% of the cases, the proxy was “‘satisfied” or “very satisfied” with help received from the library staff member and was “likely to” or “definitely would return to the staff member” in the future. The reference encounters lasted between a few minutes to half an hour in length, with most lasting between 5 and 15 minutes. Encounters that were brief (less than 5 minutes) resulted in an evaluation of “dissatisfied” or “very dissatisfied” and “not likely to” or “definitely would not return.” Encounters where the library staff member extended an invitation to the proxy to return in the future were all rated with “high satisfaction” and “willingness to return.” The following reference service actions were observed in at least half of the encounters: • Asked questions for clarification (20) • Avoided overwhelming the user with information (19) • Provided instruction on how to use information sources (18) • Explained what he / she was doing at every stage (17) • Demonstrated awareness of language barriers and modified his / her behaviour accordingly (16) • Had a respectful attitude toward the user and her question (16) • Looked approachable (15) • Used library jargon (12) The remaining reference service actions from the checklist were observed in less than half the encounters: • Accompanied the user to information sources (9) • Invited the user to return if she needed more help (6) • Asked the user if she had found what she needed (4) • Referred the user to someone else (2) The data collected from the narrative recordings of the reference encounters resulted in the identification of 17 themes. Most of these themes corresponded with the literature reviewed as important qualities for positive reference interactions. Nine of these themes were found to correlate with the proxy’s positive evaluation of the reference encounter: approachability, awareness of language barriers, asking questions, rephrasing, explanation, library jargon, instruction, early termination of interview, patience, and follow up. Conclusion – This preliminary study documents the actions of reference staff in academic libraries when answering a question from an international student. The researchers found a relationship between some library staff behaviours and the user’s level of satisfaction and likelihood to return to the staff member in the future. The research suggests that reference staff pay special attention to the needs of non-native English speakers in order to provide a positive reference encounter.
first_indexed 2024-12-23T19:49:10Z
format Article
id doaj.art-6728940ff42b4a86a18247a4052c3e6c
institution Directory Open Access Journal
issn 1715-720X
language English
last_indexed 2024-12-23T19:49:10Z
publishDate 2006-12-01
publisher University of Alberta
record_format Article
series Evidence Based Library and Information Practice
spelling doaj.art-6728940ff42b4a86a18247a4052c3e6c2022-12-21T17:33:25ZengUniversity of AlbertaEvidence Based Library and Information Practice1715-720X2006-12-011410.18438/B8NK5DAcademic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International StudentsLorie Andrea Kloda0McGill UniversityA review of: Curry, Ann and Deborah Copeman. “Reference Service to International Students: A Field Stimulation Research Study.” Journal of Academic Librarianship 31.5 (Sep. 2005): 409-20. Objective – To evaluate the quality of reference service provided to non-native, English-speaking international students in academic libraries. Design – Field stimulation (unobtrusive testing). Setting – Eleven college and university libraries in the lower mainland of British Columbia, Canada, in the fall of 2003. Subjects – Library staff offering reference service at one of the participating libraries. Methods – The study utilized field stimulation, whereby an individual, or “proxy,” posed as a library user and initiated a reference encounter with library staff at each institution. In each case the proxy asked the same question to the library staff member. After the interaction was completed the proxy recorded all observed behaviours. Data were collected using a checklist of actions; a narrative record written by the proxy; and several evaluative questions. Each library was visited by the same proxy on two separate occasions for a total of 22 visits, of which 20 instances resulted in usable data. The narrative recordings of the reference encounters were analyzed using an open coding process. Main results – In 75% of the cases, the proxy was “‘satisfied” or “very satisfied” with help received from the library staff member and was “likely to” or “definitely would return to the staff member” in the future. The reference encounters lasted between a few minutes to half an hour in length, with most lasting between 5 and 15 minutes. Encounters that were brief (less than 5 minutes) resulted in an evaluation of “dissatisfied” or “very dissatisfied” and “not likely to” or “definitely would not return.” Encounters where the library staff member extended an invitation to the proxy to return in the future were all rated with “high satisfaction” and “willingness to return.” The following reference service actions were observed in at least half of the encounters: • Asked questions for clarification (20) • Avoided overwhelming the user with information (19) • Provided instruction on how to use information sources (18) • Explained what he / she was doing at every stage (17) • Demonstrated awareness of language barriers and modified his / her behaviour accordingly (16) • Had a respectful attitude toward the user and her question (16) • Looked approachable (15) • Used library jargon (12) The remaining reference service actions from the checklist were observed in less than half the encounters: • Accompanied the user to information sources (9) • Invited the user to return if she needed more help (6) • Asked the user if she had found what she needed (4) • Referred the user to someone else (2) The data collected from the narrative recordings of the reference encounters resulted in the identification of 17 themes. Most of these themes corresponded with the literature reviewed as important qualities for positive reference interactions. Nine of these themes were found to correlate with the proxy’s positive evaluation of the reference encounter: approachability, awareness of language barriers, asking questions, rephrasing, explanation, library jargon, instruction, early termination of interview, patience, and follow up. Conclusion – This preliminary study documents the actions of reference staff in academic libraries when answering a question from an international student. The researchers found a relationship between some library staff behaviours and the user’s level of satisfaction and likelihood to return to the staff member in the future. The research suggests that reference staff pay special attention to the needs of non-native English speakers in order to provide a positive reference encounter.https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/eblip/index.php/EBLIP/article/view/100
spellingShingle Lorie Andrea Kloda
Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students
Evidence Based Library and Information Practice
title Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students
title_full Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students
title_fullStr Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students
title_full_unstemmed Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students
title_short Academic Librarians Should Be Sensitive to Language and Cultural Barriers When Providing Reference Service to International Students
title_sort academic librarians should be sensitive to language and cultural barriers when providing reference service to international students
url https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/eblip/index.php/EBLIP/article/view/100
work_keys_str_mv AT lorieandreakloda academiclibrariansshouldbesensitivetolanguageandculturalbarrierswhenprovidingreferenceservicetointernationalstudents