Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus.
Diagnosis of scrub typhus, caused by the bacterium Orientia tsutsugamushi, is challenging because of the overlap of its non-specific symptoms with other infections coupled with the lack of sufficient data on the performance of diagnostic tests. Early diagnosis of scrub typhus is crucial to improve o...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
2020-11-01
|
| Series: | PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0008747 |
| _version_ | 1819026965157380096 |
|---|---|
| author | Kavitha Kannan Rebecca John Debasree Kundu Divya Dayanand Kundavaram P P Abhilash Alice Joan Mathuram Anand Zachariah Sowmya Sathyendra Samuel G Hansdak O C Abraham Karthik Gunasekaran Ramya Iyadurai Asha M Abraham John Antony Jude Prakash Binesh Lal Yesudhason Balaji Veeraraghavan M L Kavitha Linda R Jose M N Sumana Kavitha Saravu George M Varghese |
| author_facet | Kavitha Kannan Rebecca John Debasree Kundu Divya Dayanand Kundavaram P P Abhilash Alice Joan Mathuram Anand Zachariah Sowmya Sathyendra Samuel G Hansdak O C Abraham Karthik Gunasekaran Ramya Iyadurai Asha M Abraham John Antony Jude Prakash Binesh Lal Yesudhason Balaji Veeraraghavan M L Kavitha Linda R Jose M N Sumana Kavitha Saravu George M Varghese |
| author_sort | Kavitha Kannan |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Diagnosis of scrub typhus, caused by the bacterium Orientia tsutsugamushi, is challenging because of the overlap of its non-specific symptoms with other infections coupled with the lack of sufficient data on the performance of diagnostic tests. Early diagnosis of scrub typhus is crucial to improve outcomes and this study evaluates the diagnostic performance of various tests. The present study aims at assessing the accuracy of various rapid diagnostic tests, serologic tests, and nucleic acid amplification methods on well-characterized patient samples. Adult patients with acute febrile illness and manifestations suggestive of scrub typhus confirmed by positive PCR in the blood, eschar or tissue were characterized as cases. Patients with acute febrile illness and a confirmed alternate etiology such as culture-confirmed typhoid, smear/PCR positive for malaria, PCR/NS1 antigen positive for dengue, PCR positive for influenza, PCR/MAT positive for leptospirosis, PCR positive for spotted fever were characterized as controls with other infections. The healthy controls consisted of subjects from the same geographic region. We performed the following tests on blood samples for scrub typhus and calculated the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value: (1) Quantitative real time PCR using 47kDa gene (qPCR); (2) Conventional PCR using 56kDa gene (cPCR); (3) Loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay (LAMP assay); (4) Immunofluorescence assay (IFA); (5) Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA); (6) Weil-Felix test(WF test); and (7) Immunochromatographic Rapid Diagnostic Test (RDT).Among the 316 participants, 158 had confirmed scrub typhus (cases) and 158 were controls. ELISA and RDT detecting Orientia tsutsugamushi specific IgM antibodies had excellent discriminative potential with sensitivities and specificities of 92%, 94% and 92%, 92% respectively. The sensitivity and specificity of IFA were found to be 95% and 74% respectively. IgM serology had a false positivity rate of 8% with other acute febrile illnesses such as dengue, leptospirosis and spotted fever due to the nonspecific binding of the pentavalent IgM. LAMP assay had 91.7% sensitivity and 77.2% specificity while qPCR provided excellent sensitivity (97%) and perfect specificity. In conclusion, ELISA and RDT detecting Orientia tsutsugamushi specific IgM antibodies have excellent sensitivity and specificity while the accuracy of IFA is suboptimal for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. Given its perfect specificity and superior sensitivity, qPCR is preferred for diagnostic confirmation in reference laboratories particularly for diagnosis of early disease with less than 7 days duration. This study provides a comprehensive evaluation of all currently available diagnostic tests for scrub typhus. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-21T05:34:57Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-694e914426304e0e9d571fc85f755651 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1935-2727 1935-2735 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-21T05:34:57Z |
| publishDate | 2020-11-01 |
| publisher | Public Library of Science (PLoS) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases |
| spelling | doaj.art-694e914426304e0e9d571fc85f7556512022-12-21T19:14:26ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases1935-27271935-27352020-11-011411e000874710.1371/journal.pntd.0008747Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus.Kavitha KannanRebecca JohnDebasree KunduDivya DayanandKundavaram P P AbhilashAlice Joan MathuramAnand ZachariahSowmya SathyendraSamuel G HansdakO C AbrahamKarthik GunasekaranRamya IyaduraiAsha M AbrahamJohn Antony Jude PrakashBinesh Lal YesudhasonBalaji VeeraraghavanM L KavithaLinda R JoseM N SumanaKavitha SaravuGeorge M VargheseDiagnosis of scrub typhus, caused by the bacterium Orientia tsutsugamushi, is challenging because of the overlap of its non-specific symptoms with other infections coupled with the lack of sufficient data on the performance of diagnostic tests. Early diagnosis of scrub typhus is crucial to improve outcomes and this study evaluates the diagnostic performance of various tests. The present study aims at assessing the accuracy of various rapid diagnostic tests, serologic tests, and nucleic acid amplification methods on well-characterized patient samples. Adult patients with acute febrile illness and manifestations suggestive of scrub typhus confirmed by positive PCR in the blood, eschar or tissue were characterized as cases. Patients with acute febrile illness and a confirmed alternate etiology such as culture-confirmed typhoid, smear/PCR positive for malaria, PCR/NS1 antigen positive for dengue, PCR positive for influenza, PCR/MAT positive for leptospirosis, PCR positive for spotted fever were characterized as controls with other infections. The healthy controls consisted of subjects from the same geographic region. We performed the following tests on blood samples for scrub typhus and calculated the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value: (1) Quantitative real time PCR using 47kDa gene (qPCR); (2) Conventional PCR using 56kDa gene (cPCR); (3) Loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay (LAMP assay); (4) Immunofluorescence assay (IFA); (5) Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA); (6) Weil-Felix test(WF test); and (7) Immunochromatographic Rapid Diagnostic Test (RDT).Among the 316 participants, 158 had confirmed scrub typhus (cases) and 158 were controls. ELISA and RDT detecting Orientia tsutsugamushi specific IgM antibodies had excellent discriminative potential with sensitivities and specificities of 92%, 94% and 92%, 92% respectively. The sensitivity and specificity of IFA were found to be 95% and 74% respectively. IgM serology had a false positivity rate of 8% with other acute febrile illnesses such as dengue, leptospirosis and spotted fever due to the nonspecific binding of the pentavalent IgM. LAMP assay had 91.7% sensitivity and 77.2% specificity while qPCR provided excellent sensitivity (97%) and perfect specificity. In conclusion, ELISA and RDT detecting Orientia tsutsugamushi specific IgM antibodies have excellent sensitivity and specificity while the accuracy of IFA is suboptimal for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. Given its perfect specificity and superior sensitivity, qPCR is preferred for diagnostic confirmation in reference laboratories particularly for diagnosis of early disease with less than 7 days duration. This study provides a comprehensive evaluation of all currently available diagnostic tests for scrub typhus.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0008747 |
| spellingShingle | Kavitha Kannan Rebecca John Debasree Kundu Divya Dayanand Kundavaram P P Abhilash Alice Joan Mathuram Anand Zachariah Sowmya Sathyendra Samuel G Hansdak O C Abraham Karthik Gunasekaran Ramya Iyadurai Asha M Abraham John Antony Jude Prakash Binesh Lal Yesudhason Balaji Veeraraghavan M L Kavitha Linda R Jose M N Sumana Kavitha Saravu George M Varghese Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases |
| title | Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. |
| title_full | Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. |
| title_fullStr | Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. |
| title_full_unstemmed | Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. |
| title_short | Performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus. |
| title_sort | performance of molecular and serologic tests for the diagnosis of scrub typhus |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0008747 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT kavithakannan performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT rebeccajohn performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT debasreekundu performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT divyadayanand performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT kundavaramppabhilash performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT alicejoanmathuram performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT anandzachariah performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT sowmyasathyendra performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT samuelghansdak performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT ocabraham performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT karthikgunasekaran performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT ramyaiyadurai performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT ashamabraham performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT johnantonyjudeprakash performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT bineshlalyesudhason performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT balajiveeraraghavan performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT mlkavitha performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT lindarjose performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT mnsumana performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT kavithasaravu performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus AT georgemvarghese performanceofmolecularandserologictestsforthediagnosisofscrubtyphus |