Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial
BackgroundMost people affected by depression or anxiety disorders are treated solely by their primary care physician. Access to specialized mental health care is impeded by patients’ comorbidity and immobility in aging societies and long waiting times at the providers’ end. Video-based integrated ca...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
JMIR Publications
2021-03-01
|
| Series: | JMIR Mental Health |
| Online Access: | https://mental.jmir.org/2021/3/e22569 |
| _version_ | 1818300382055497728 |
|---|---|
| author | Tönnies, Justus Hartmann, Mechthild Wensing, Michel Szecsenyi, Joachim Peters-Klimm, Frank Brinster, Regina Weber, Dorothea Vomhof, Markus Icks, Andrea Friederich, Hans-Christoph Haun, Markus W |
| author_facet | Tönnies, Justus Hartmann, Mechthild Wensing, Michel Szecsenyi, Joachim Peters-Klimm, Frank Brinster, Regina Weber, Dorothea Vomhof, Markus Icks, Andrea Friederich, Hans-Christoph Haun, Markus W |
| author_sort | Tönnies, Justus |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | BackgroundMost people affected by depression or anxiety disorders are treated solely by their primary care physician. Access to specialized mental health care is impeded by patients’ comorbidity and immobility in aging societies and long waiting times at the providers’ end. Video-based integrated care models may leverage limited resources more efficiently and provide timely specialized care in primary care settings.
ObjectiveThe study aims to evaluate the feasibility of mental health specialist video consultations with primary care patients with depression or anxiety disorders.
MethodsParticipants were recruited by their primary care physicians during regular practice visits. Patients who had experienced at least moderate symptoms of depression and/or anxiety disorders were considered eligible for the study. Patients were randomized into 2 groups receiving either treatment-as-usual as provided by their general practitioner or up to 5 video consultations conducted by a mental health specialist. Video consultations focused on systematic diagnosis and proactive monitoring using validated clinical rating scales, the establishment of an effective working alliance, and a stepped-care algorithm within integrated care adjusting treatments based on clinical outcomes. Feasibility outcomes were recruitment, rate of loss to follow-up, acceptability of treatment, and attendance at sessions. Effectiveness outcomes included depression (Patient Health Questionnaire-9), anxiety (Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7), burden of specific somatic complaints (Somatic Symptom Disorder-B Criteria Scale-12), recovery (Recovery Assessment Scale-German [RAS-G]), and perception of chronic illness care (Patient Assessment of Chronic Illness Care), which were measured at baseline and 16 weeks postallocation by assessors blinded to the group allocation.
ResultsA total of 50 patients with depression and/or anxiety disorders were randomized, 23 in the intervention group and 27 in the treatment-as-usual group. The recruitment yield (number randomized per number screened) and the consent rate (number randomized per number eligible) were 69% (50/73) and 86% (50/58), respectively. Regarding acceptability, 87% (20/23) of the participants in the intervention group completed the intervention. Of the 108 planned video consultations, 102 (94.4%) were delivered. Follow-up rates were 96% (22/23) and 85% (23/27) for the intervention and control groups, respectively. The change from baseline scores at postmeasurement for the No Domination by Symptoms domain of recovery (RAS-G) was somewhat higher in the intervention group than in the control group (Mann-Whitney U test: rank-biserial r=0.19; 95% CI −0.09 to 0.46; P=.18). We did not detect any notable differences between the intervention and control groups in terms of other effectiveness outcomes. We did not observe any serious adverse events related to the trial.
ConclusionsThe intervention and study procedures were found to be feasible for patients, primary care practice staff, and mental health specialists. A sufficiently powered pragmatic trial on mental health specialist video consultations should be conducted to investigate their effectiveness in routine care.
Trial RegistrationGerman Clinical Trials Register DRKS00015812; https://www.drks.de/drks_web/navigate.do?navigationId=trial.HTML&TRIAL_ID=DRKS00015812. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-13T05:06:13Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-6dcef12e0ef941439e4f926be1da6958 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2368-7959 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-13T05:06:13Z |
| publishDate | 2021-03-01 |
| publisher | JMIR Publications |
| record_format | Article |
| series | JMIR Mental Health |
| spelling | doaj.art-6dcef12e0ef941439e4f926be1da69582022-12-21T23:58:40ZengJMIR PublicationsJMIR Mental Health2368-79592021-03-0183e2256910.2196/22569Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility TrialTönnies, JustusHartmann, MechthildWensing, MichelSzecsenyi, JoachimPeters-Klimm, FrankBrinster, ReginaWeber, DorotheaVomhof, MarkusIcks, AndreaFriederich, Hans-ChristophHaun, Markus WBackgroundMost people affected by depression or anxiety disorders are treated solely by their primary care physician. Access to specialized mental health care is impeded by patients’ comorbidity and immobility in aging societies and long waiting times at the providers’ end. Video-based integrated care models may leverage limited resources more efficiently and provide timely specialized care in primary care settings. ObjectiveThe study aims to evaluate the feasibility of mental health specialist video consultations with primary care patients with depression or anxiety disorders. MethodsParticipants were recruited by their primary care physicians during regular practice visits. Patients who had experienced at least moderate symptoms of depression and/or anxiety disorders were considered eligible for the study. Patients were randomized into 2 groups receiving either treatment-as-usual as provided by their general practitioner or up to 5 video consultations conducted by a mental health specialist. Video consultations focused on systematic diagnosis and proactive monitoring using validated clinical rating scales, the establishment of an effective working alliance, and a stepped-care algorithm within integrated care adjusting treatments based on clinical outcomes. Feasibility outcomes were recruitment, rate of loss to follow-up, acceptability of treatment, and attendance at sessions. Effectiveness outcomes included depression (Patient Health Questionnaire-9), anxiety (Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7), burden of specific somatic complaints (Somatic Symptom Disorder-B Criteria Scale-12), recovery (Recovery Assessment Scale-German [RAS-G]), and perception of chronic illness care (Patient Assessment of Chronic Illness Care), which were measured at baseline and 16 weeks postallocation by assessors blinded to the group allocation. ResultsA total of 50 patients with depression and/or anxiety disorders were randomized, 23 in the intervention group and 27 in the treatment-as-usual group. The recruitment yield (number randomized per number screened) and the consent rate (number randomized per number eligible) were 69% (50/73) and 86% (50/58), respectively. Regarding acceptability, 87% (20/23) of the participants in the intervention group completed the intervention. Of the 108 planned video consultations, 102 (94.4%) were delivered. Follow-up rates were 96% (22/23) and 85% (23/27) for the intervention and control groups, respectively. The change from baseline scores at postmeasurement for the No Domination by Symptoms domain of recovery (RAS-G) was somewhat higher in the intervention group than in the control group (Mann-Whitney U test: rank-biserial r=0.19; 95% CI −0.09 to 0.46; P=.18). We did not detect any notable differences between the intervention and control groups in terms of other effectiveness outcomes. We did not observe any serious adverse events related to the trial. ConclusionsThe intervention and study procedures were found to be feasible for patients, primary care practice staff, and mental health specialists. A sufficiently powered pragmatic trial on mental health specialist video consultations should be conducted to investigate their effectiveness in routine care. Trial RegistrationGerman Clinical Trials Register DRKS00015812; https://www.drks.de/drks_web/navigate.do?navigationId=trial.HTML&TRIAL_ID=DRKS00015812.https://mental.jmir.org/2021/3/e22569 |
| spellingShingle | Tönnies, Justus Hartmann, Mechthild Wensing, Michel Szecsenyi, Joachim Peters-Klimm, Frank Brinster, Regina Weber, Dorothea Vomhof, Markus Icks, Andrea Friederich, Hans-Christoph Haun, Markus W Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial JMIR Mental Health |
| title | Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial |
| title_full | Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial |
| title_fullStr | Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial |
| title_full_unstemmed | Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial |
| title_short | Mental Health Specialist Video Consultations Versus Treatment-as-Usual for Patients With Depression or Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: Randomized Controlled Feasibility Trial |
| title_sort | mental health specialist video consultations versus treatment as usual for patients with depression or anxiety disorders in primary care randomized controlled feasibility trial |
| url | https://mental.jmir.org/2021/3/e22569 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT tonniesjustus mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT hartmannmechthild mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT wensingmichel mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT szecsenyijoachim mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT petersklimmfrank mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT brinsterregina mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT weberdorothea mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT vomhofmarkus mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT icksandrea mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT friederichhanschristoph mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial AT haunmarkusw mentalhealthspecialistvideoconsultationsversustreatmentasusualforpatientswithdepressionoranxietydisordersinprimarycarerandomizedcontrolledfeasibilitytrial |