A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation
The topic of reincarnation is one that has been discussed in a number of different fields, under different headings and with different methods. For example, this topic has been discussed in philosophy in relation to the soul. This is because reincarnation implies that a soul is transferred from one...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Center for Religious Sciences Kom, Belgrade
2018-01-01
|
| Series: | Kom: Časopis za Religijske Nauke |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://scindeks-clanci.ceon.rs/data/pdf/2334-6396/2018/2334-63961802069H.pdf |
| _version_ | 1818495064463114240 |
|---|---|
| author | Husain Agha Shiraz |
| author_facet | Husain Agha Shiraz |
| author_sort | Husain Agha Shiraz |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | The topic of reincarnation is one that has been discussed in a number of different fields, under different headings and with different methods. For example, this topic has been discussed in philosophy in relation to the soul. This is because reincarnation implies that a soul is transferred from one body to another. When philosophers discuss reincarnation, they do so by using reason. However, this topic has also been discussed in theology, in the section concerned with the Afterlife. This is because sometimes reincarnation is presented as an alternative to the concept of Ma'ad - the reattachment of human souls to their bodies in another world, with the purpose of being judged and recompensed for the actions they did in this world. When theologians treat this topic, they do so from a rational-religious perspective. For the most part, Muslim scholars have denied the possibility of reincarnation. However, some of them say that it is something that is rationally impossible. Others say that it is rationally possible but does not occur - as religion tells us. Generally, philosophers were of the opinion that reincarnation is something that is rationally impossible. They have presented many philosophical proofs to substantiate this claim. One of the philosophers who discussed this subject at length was Avicenna. He was adamant about the impossibility of reincarnation and presented some complicated rational proofs for this matter. One of the proofs provided by Avicenna was one in which he presented a number of different scenarios in which this phenomenon might occur. Avicenna proved that all of these scenarios are impossible. As a result, reincarnation must also be impossible. In another proof, Avicenna said that reincarnation is something that goes against intuition and would lead to one person's being two people. There are numerous problems with both of Avicenna's proofs and therefore they must be rejected or reconstructed. This article seeks to present these proofs in a structured manner and then to critique them. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-10T18:15:17Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-71288cb92b4545e4839f1986c5f2ba55 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2334-6396 2334-8046 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-10T18:15:17Z |
| publishDate | 2018-01-01 |
| publisher | Center for Religious Sciences Kom, Belgrade |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Kom: Časopis za Religijske Nauke |
| spelling | doaj.art-71288cb92b4545e4839f1986c5f2ba552022-12-22T01:38:21ZengCenter for Religious Sciences Kom, BelgradeKom: Časopis za Religijske Nauke2334-63962334-80462018-01-017269882334-63961802069HA critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnationHusain Agha Shiraz0Faculty of Philosophy, Al-Mustafa International University, Qom, I.R. IranThe topic of reincarnation is one that has been discussed in a number of different fields, under different headings and with different methods. For example, this topic has been discussed in philosophy in relation to the soul. This is because reincarnation implies that a soul is transferred from one body to another. When philosophers discuss reincarnation, they do so by using reason. However, this topic has also been discussed in theology, in the section concerned with the Afterlife. This is because sometimes reincarnation is presented as an alternative to the concept of Ma'ad - the reattachment of human souls to their bodies in another world, with the purpose of being judged and recompensed for the actions they did in this world. When theologians treat this topic, they do so from a rational-religious perspective. For the most part, Muslim scholars have denied the possibility of reincarnation. However, some of them say that it is something that is rationally impossible. Others say that it is rationally possible but does not occur - as religion tells us. Generally, philosophers were of the opinion that reincarnation is something that is rationally impossible. They have presented many philosophical proofs to substantiate this claim. One of the philosophers who discussed this subject at length was Avicenna. He was adamant about the impossibility of reincarnation and presented some complicated rational proofs for this matter. One of the proofs provided by Avicenna was one in which he presented a number of different scenarios in which this phenomenon might occur. Avicenna proved that all of these scenarios are impossible. As a result, reincarnation must also be impossible. In another proof, Avicenna said that reincarnation is something that goes against intuition and would lead to one person's being two people. There are numerous problems with both of Avicenna's proofs and therefore they must be rejected or reconstructed. This article seeks to present these proofs in a structured manner and then to critique them.https://scindeks-clanci.ceon.rs/data/pdf/2334-6396/2018/2334-63961802069H.pdfreincarnationAvicennareasonafter-lifesoul |
| spellingShingle | Husain Agha Shiraz A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation Kom: Časopis za Religijske Nauke reincarnation Avicenna reason after-life soul |
| title | A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation |
| title_full | A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation |
| title_fullStr | A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation |
| title_full_unstemmed | A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation |
| title_short | A critical analysis of Avicenna's proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation |
| title_sort | critical analysis of avicenna s proofs of the impossibility of human reincarnation |
| topic | reincarnation Avicenna reason after-life soul |
| url | https://scindeks-clanci.ceon.rs/data/pdf/2334-6396/2018/2334-63961802069H.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT husainaghashiraz acriticalanalysisofavicennasproofsoftheimpossibilityofhumanreincarnation AT husainaghashiraz criticalanalysisofavicennasproofsoftheimpossibilityofhumanreincarnation |