A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania
IntroductionAge-disparate transactional sex (ADTS) is associated with HIV, unintended pregnancy, school dropout and violence, yet few interventions have successfully prevented it, and none have set ADTS prevention as their primary outcome. This exploratory evaluation aimed to assess indications of c...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2022-12-01
|
Series: | Frontiers in Reproductive Health |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frph.2022.1000853/full |
_version_ | 1811311237795938304 |
---|---|
author | Marjorie Pichon Daniel J Carter Lottie Howard-Merrill Revocatus Sono Veronicah Gimunta Oscar Rutenge Yandé Thiaw Kirsten Stoebenau Nancy Perrin Ana Maria Buller |
author_facet | Marjorie Pichon Daniel J Carter Lottie Howard-Merrill Revocatus Sono Veronicah Gimunta Oscar Rutenge Yandé Thiaw Kirsten Stoebenau Nancy Perrin Ana Maria Buller |
author_sort | Marjorie Pichon |
collection | DOAJ |
description | IntroductionAge-disparate transactional sex (ADTS) is associated with HIV, unintended pregnancy, school dropout and violence, yet few interventions have successfully prevented it, and none have set ADTS prevention as their primary outcome. This exploratory evaluation aimed to assess indications of change after exposure to the Learning Initiative on Norms, Exploitation and Abuse (LINEA) intervention, a mass-media, gender-transformative social norms intervention aimed at preventing ADTS in Tanzania.MethodsIn a condensed implementation 331 participants were instructed to listen to the LINEA radio drama over seven weeks, and 60 were randomly allocated to household discussion sessions about content. In-depth interviews (n = 81) from girls aged 12–16 years, and women and men caregivers were collected at baseline (September 2021), midline (November) and endline (December 2021). Surveys were conducted (n = 120) at baseline and endline using the Norms and Attitudes on ADTS Scale (NAATSS) and the Gender Roles and Male Provision Expectations (GRMPE) scale. Interviews were thematically analyzed using a framework approach. Age-stratified linear regression models adjusted for baseline scores were used to measure association between the intervention and endline scale scores.ResultsLongitudinal data were available from 59 qualitative (73%) and 95 quantitative participants (79%). Qualitative evidence revealed the drama facilitated family conversations about adolescent challenges, allowing caregivers to advise daughters. Some girls gained confidence to refuse men's gifts, learning that accepting them could necessitate sexual reciprocation. Some caregivers felt increased responsibility for supporting girls in the community to avoid ADTS. Blame for ADTS shifted for some from girls to men, suggesting increased understanding of inequitable power dynamics and reductions in victim blaming. Marginal quantitative evidence revealed that highly exposed girls had improved gender equitable beliefs on the GRMPE (β = −6.26; 95% CI: −12.94, 0.42). Moderately exposed men had increased gender inequitable norms on the NAATSS subscale (β = 0.42 95% CI: 0.05, 0.79), but there was no effect in highly exposed men.ConclusionsGiven the small sample results should be interpreted cautiously. Our initial findings indicate high engagement with the LINEA intervention shows promise in shifting knowledge, behaviors, and attitudes, beliefs and social norms driving ADTS in Shinyanga, Tanzania, supporting a robust impact evaluation. |
first_indexed | 2024-04-13T10:15:24Z |
format | Article |
id | doaj.art-779255acc2134b29a6db83c00b5e6d49 |
institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
issn | 2673-3153 |
language | English |
last_indexed | 2024-04-13T10:15:24Z |
publishDate | 2022-12-01 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | Article |
series | Frontiers in Reproductive Health |
spelling | doaj.art-779255acc2134b29a6db83c00b5e6d492022-12-22T02:50:46ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Reproductive Health2673-31532022-12-01410.3389/frph.2022.10008531000853A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in TanzaniaMarjorie Pichon0Daniel J Carter1Lottie Howard-Merrill2Revocatus Sono3Veronicah Gimunta4Oscar Rutenge5Yandé Thiaw6Kirsten Stoebenau7Nancy Perrin8Ana Maria Buller9Gender Violence & Health Centre, Department of Global Health and Development, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United KingdomGender Violence & Health Centre, Department of Global Health and Development, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United KingdomDepartment of Education, Practice and Society, Institute of Education, University College London, London, United KingdomAdolescent Girls and Young Women Department, Amani Girls Home, Mwanza, United Republic of TanzaniaAdolescent Girls and Young Women Department, Amani Girls Home, Mwanza, United Republic of TanzaniaTanganyika Christian Refugee Service, Shinyanga Unit, United Republic of TanzaniaGender Violence & Health Centre, Department of Global Health and Development, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United KingdomDepartment of Behavioral and Community Health, School of Public Health, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, United StatesDepartment of Behavioral and Community Health, Johns Hopkins School of Nursing, Baltimore, MD, United StatesGender Violence & Health Centre, Department of Global Health and Development, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United KingdomIntroductionAge-disparate transactional sex (ADTS) is associated with HIV, unintended pregnancy, school dropout and violence, yet few interventions have successfully prevented it, and none have set ADTS prevention as their primary outcome. This exploratory evaluation aimed to assess indications of change after exposure to the Learning Initiative on Norms, Exploitation and Abuse (LINEA) intervention, a mass-media, gender-transformative social norms intervention aimed at preventing ADTS in Tanzania.MethodsIn a condensed implementation 331 participants were instructed to listen to the LINEA radio drama over seven weeks, and 60 were randomly allocated to household discussion sessions about content. In-depth interviews (n = 81) from girls aged 12–16 years, and women and men caregivers were collected at baseline (September 2021), midline (November) and endline (December 2021). Surveys were conducted (n = 120) at baseline and endline using the Norms and Attitudes on ADTS Scale (NAATSS) and the Gender Roles and Male Provision Expectations (GRMPE) scale. Interviews were thematically analyzed using a framework approach. Age-stratified linear regression models adjusted for baseline scores were used to measure association between the intervention and endline scale scores.ResultsLongitudinal data were available from 59 qualitative (73%) and 95 quantitative participants (79%). Qualitative evidence revealed the drama facilitated family conversations about adolescent challenges, allowing caregivers to advise daughters. Some girls gained confidence to refuse men's gifts, learning that accepting them could necessitate sexual reciprocation. Some caregivers felt increased responsibility for supporting girls in the community to avoid ADTS. Blame for ADTS shifted for some from girls to men, suggesting increased understanding of inequitable power dynamics and reductions in victim blaming. Marginal quantitative evidence revealed that highly exposed girls had improved gender equitable beliefs on the GRMPE (β = −6.26; 95% CI: −12.94, 0.42). Moderately exposed men had increased gender inequitable norms on the NAATSS subscale (β = 0.42 95% CI: 0.05, 0.79), but there was no effect in highly exposed men.ConclusionsGiven the small sample results should be interpreted cautiously. Our initial findings indicate high engagement with the LINEA intervention shows promise in shifting knowledge, behaviors, and attitudes, beliefs and social norms driving ADTS in Shinyanga, Tanzania, supporting a robust impact evaluation.https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frph.2022.1000853/fulltransactional sexage-disparate sexgender-based violence (GBV)social norms interventionmass media interventionsevaluation |
spellingShingle | Marjorie Pichon Daniel J Carter Lottie Howard-Merrill Revocatus Sono Veronicah Gimunta Oscar Rutenge Yandé Thiaw Kirsten Stoebenau Nancy Perrin Ana Maria Buller A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania Frontiers in Reproductive Health transactional sex age-disparate sex gender-based violence (GBV) social norms intervention mass media interventions evaluation |
title | A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania |
title_full | A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania |
title_fullStr | A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania |
title_full_unstemmed | A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania |
title_short | A mixed-methods, exploratory, quasi-experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age-disparate transactional sex in Tanzania |
title_sort | mixed methods exploratory quasi experimental evaluation of a radio drama intervention to prevent age disparate transactional sex in tanzania |
topic | transactional sex age-disparate sex gender-based violence (GBV) social norms intervention mass media interventions evaluation |
url | https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frph.2022.1000853/full |
work_keys_str_mv | AT marjoriepichon amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT danieljcarter amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT lottiehowardmerrill amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT revocatussono amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT veronicahgimunta amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT oscarrutenge amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT yandethiaw amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT kirstenstoebenau amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT nancyperrin amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT anamariabuller amixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT marjoriepichon mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT danieljcarter mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT lottiehowardmerrill mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT revocatussono mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT veronicahgimunta mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT oscarrutenge mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT yandethiaw mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT kirstenstoebenau mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT nancyperrin mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania AT anamariabuller mixedmethodsexploratoryquasiexperimentalevaluationofaradiodramainterventiontopreventagedisparatetransactionalsexintanzania |