Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol
Introduction Total mesorectal excision is the standard of care for rectal cancer, which can be performed using open, laparoscopic, robot-assisted and transanal technique. Large prospective (randomised controlled) trials comparing these techniques are lacking, do not take into account the learning cu...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMJ Publishing Group
2022-08-01
|
| Series: | BMJ Open |
| Online Access: | https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/8/e057640.full |
| _version_ | 1817995567749398528 |
|---|---|
| author | Maarten Postma Roel Hompes A.H.W. Schiphorst Adelita Ranchor A. Pronk Ritch Geitenbeek Thijs Burghgraef David Zimmerman Marcel Dijkgraaf Paul Verheijen Esther Consten G.J.D. van Acker T.S. Aukema H.J. Belgers F.H. Beverdam J.G. Bloemen K. Bosscha S.O. Breukink P.P.L.O. Coene R.M.P.H. Crolla P. van Duijvendijk E.B. van Duyn I.F. Faneyte S.A.F. Fransen A.A.W. van Geloven M.F. Gerhards W.M.U. van Grevenstein K. Havenga I.H.J.T. de Hingh C. Hoff G. Kats J.W.A. Leijtens M.F. Lutke Holzik J. Melenhorst M.M. Poelman J.M.J. Schreinemakers C. Sietses A.B. Smits I Somers E.J. Spillenaar Bilgen H.B.A.C. Stockmann A.K. Talsma P.J. Tanis J. Tuynman E.G.G. Verdaasdonk F.A.R.M. Warmerdam H.L. van Westreenen D.D.E. Zimmerman |
| author_facet | Maarten Postma Roel Hompes A.H.W. Schiphorst Adelita Ranchor A. Pronk Ritch Geitenbeek Thijs Burghgraef David Zimmerman Marcel Dijkgraaf Paul Verheijen Esther Consten G.J.D. van Acker T.S. Aukema H.J. Belgers F.H. Beverdam J.G. Bloemen K. Bosscha S.O. Breukink P.P.L.O. Coene R.M.P.H. Crolla P. van Duijvendijk E.B. van Duyn I.F. Faneyte S.A.F. Fransen A.A.W. van Geloven M.F. Gerhards W.M.U. van Grevenstein K. Havenga I.H.J.T. de Hingh C. Hoff G. Kats J.W.A. Leijtens M.F. Lutke Holzik J. Melenhorst M.M. Poelman J.M.J. Schreinemakers C. Sietses A.B. Smits I Somers E.J. Spillenaar Bilgen H.B.A.C. Stockmann A.K. Talsma P.J. Tanis J. Tuynman E.G.G. Verdaasdonk F.A.R.M. Warmerdam H.L. van Westreenen D.D.E. Zimmerman |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Introduction Total mesorectal excision is the standard of care for rectal cancer, which can be performed using open, laparoscopic, robot-assisted and transanal technique. Large prospective (randomised controlled) trials comparing these techniques are lacking, do not take into account the learning curve and have short-term or long-term oncological results as their primary endpoint, without addressing quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness. Comparative data with regard to these outcomes are necessary to identify the optimal minimally invasive technique and provide guidelines for clinical application.Methods and analysis This trial will be a prospective observational multicentre cohort trial, aiming to compare laparoscopic, robot-assisted and transanal total mesorectal excision in adult patients with rectal cancer performed by experienced surgeons in dedicated centres. Data collection will be performed in collaboration with the prospective Dutch ColoRectal Audit and the Prospective Dutch ColoRectal Cancer Cohort. Quality of life at 1 year postoperatively will be the primary outcome. Functional outcomes, cost-effectiveness, short-term outcomes and long-term oncological outcomes will be the secondary outcomes. In total, 1200 patients will be enrolled over a period of 2 years in 26 dedicated centres in the Netherlands. The study is registered at https://www.trialregister.nl/9734 (NL9734).Ethics and dissemination Data will be collected through collaborating parties, who already obtained approval by their medical ethical committee. Participants will be included in the trial after having signed informed consent. Results of this study will be disseminated to participating centres, patient organisations, (inter)national society meetings and peer-reviewed journals. |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-14T02:08:03Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-77bfc4094b08413a9e85b3f1bc9da01d |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2044-6055 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-14T02:08:03Z |
| publishDate | 2022-08-01 |
| publisher | BMJ Publishing Group |
| record_format | Article |
| series | BMJ Open |
| spelling | doaj.art-77bfc4094b08413a9e85b3f1bc9da01d2022-12-22T02:18:34ZengBMJ Publishing GroupBMJ Open2044-60552022-08-0112810.1136/bmjopen-2021-057640Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol 0Maarten Postma1Roel Hompes2A.H.W. SchiphorstAdelita Ranchor3A. Pronk4Ritch Geitenbeek5Thijs Burghgraef6David Zimmerman7Marcel Dijkgraaf8Paul Verheijen9Esther Consten10G.J.D. van AckerT.S. AukemaH.J. BelgersF.H. BeverdamJ.G. BloemenK. BosschaS.O. BreukinkP.P.L.O. CoeneR.M.P.H. CrollaP. van DuijvendijkE.B. van DuynI.F. FaneyteS.A.F. FransenA.A.W. van GelovenM.F. GerhardsW.M.U. van GrevensteinK. HavengaI.H.J.T. de HinghC. HoffG. KatsJ.W.A. LeijtensM.F. Lutke HolzikJ. MelenhorstM.M. PoelmanJ.M.J. SchreinemakersC. SietsesA.B. SmitsI SomersE.J. Spillenaar BilgenH.B.A.C. StockmannA.K. TalsmaP.J. TanisJ. TuynmanE.G.G. VerdaasdonkF.A.R.M. WarmerdamH.L. van WestreenenD.D.E. Zimmerman3International CollaborationUnit of Global Health, Department of Health Sciences, University of Groningen, University Medical Center, Groningen, The NetherlandsSurgery, Amsterdam UMC,University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands4 Department of Health Psychology, University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The NetherlandsIRAS-TNODepartment of Surgery, University Medical Centre, Groningen, The NetherlandsDepartment of Surgery, University Medical Centre, Groningen, The NetherlandsDepartment of Surgery, Elisabeth-TweeSteden Ziekenhuis, Tilburg, The NetherlandsDepartment of Clinical Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Bioinformatics, UMC - Locatie AMC, Amsterdam, The NetherlandsDepartment of Surgery, Meander Medical Centre, Amersfoort, The NetherlandsDepartment of Surgery, Meander Medical Centre, Amersfoort, The NetherlandsIntroduction Total mesorectal excision is the standard of care for rectal cancer, which can be performed using open, laparoscopic, robot-assisted and transanal technique. Large prospective (randomised controlled) trials comparing these techniques are lacking, do not take into account the learning curve and have short-term or long-term oncological results as their primary endpoint, without addressing quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness. Comparative data with regard to these outcomes are necessary to identify the optimal minimally invasive technique and provide guidelines for clinical application.Methods and analysis This trial will be a prospective observational multicentre cohort trial, aiming to compare laparoscopic, robot-assisted and transanal total mesorectal excision in adult patients with rectal cancer performed by experienced surgeons in dedicated centres. Data collection will be performed in collaboration with the prospective Dutch ColoRectal Audit and the Prospective Dutch ColoRectal Cancer Cohort. Quality of life at 1 year postoperatively will be the primary outcome. Functional outcomes, cost-effectiveness, short-term outcomes and long-term oncological outcomes will be the secondary outcomes. In total, 1200 patients will be enrolled over a period of 2 years in 26 dedicated centres in the Netherlands. The study is registered at https://www.trialregister.nl/9734 (NL9734).Ethics and dissemination Data will be collected through collaborating parties, who already obtained approval by their medical ethical committee. Participants will be included in the trial after having signed informed consent. Results of this study will be disseminated to participating centres, patient organisations, (inter)national society meetings and peer-reviewed journals.https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/8/e057640.full |
| spellingShingle | Maarten Postma Roel Hompes A.H.W. Schiphorst Adelita Ranchor A. Pronk Ritch Geitenbeek Thijs Burghgraef David Zimmerman Marcel Dijkgraaf Paul Verheijen Esther Consten G.J.D. van Acker T.S. Aukema H.J. Belgers F.H. Beverdam J.G. Bloemen K. Bosscha S.O. Breukink P.P.L.O. Coene R.M.P.H. Crolla P. van Duijvendijk E.B. van Duyn I.F. Faneyte S.A.F. Fransen A.A.W. van Geloven M.F. Gerhards W.M.U. van Grevenstein K. Havenga I.H.J.T. de Hingh C. Hoff G. Kats J.W.A. Leijtens M.F. Lutke Holzik J. Melenhorst M.M. Poelman J.M.J. Schreinemakers C. Sietses A.B. Smits I Somers E.J. Spillenaar Bilgen H.B.A.C. Stockmann A.K. Talsma P.J. Tanis J. Tuynman E.G.G. Verdaasdonk F.A.R.M. Warmerdam H.L. van Westreenen D.D.E. Zimmerman Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol BMJ Open |
| title | Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol |
| title_full | Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol |
| title_fullStr | Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol |
| title_full_unstemmed | Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol |
| title_short | Prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life, functional outcomes and cost-effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in ‘dedicated centres’ in the Netherlands (VANTAGE trial): a protocol |
| title_sort | prospective multicentre observational cohort to assess quality of life functional outcomes and cost effectiveness following minimally invasive surgical techniques for rectal cancer in dedicated centres in the netherlands vantage trial a protocol |
| url | https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/8/e057640.full |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT maartenpostma prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT roelhompes prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT ahwschiphorst prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT adelitaranchor prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT apronk prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT ritchgeitenbeek prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT thijsburghgraef prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT davidzimmerman prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT marceldijkgraaf prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT paulverheijen prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT estherconsten prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT gjdvanacker prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT tsaukema prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT hjbelgers prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT fhbeverdam prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT jgbloemen prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT kbosscha prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT sobreukink prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT pplocoene prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT rmphcrolla prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT pvanduijvendijk prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT ebvanduyn prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT iffaneyte prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT saffransen prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT aawvangeloven prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT mfgerhards prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT wmuvangrevenstein prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT khavenga prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT ihjtdehingh prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT choff prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT gkats prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT jwaleijtens prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT mflutkeholzik prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT jmelenhorst prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT mmpoelman prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT jmjschreinemakers prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT csietses prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT absmits prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT isomers prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT ejspillenaarbilgen prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT hbacstockmann prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT aktalsma prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT pjtanis prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT jtuynman prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT eggverdaasdonk prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT farmwarmerdam prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT hlvanwestreenen prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol AT ddezimmerman prospectivemulticentreobservationalcohorttoassessqualityoflifefunctionaloutcomesandcosteffectivenessfollowingminimallyinvasivesurgicaltechniquesforrectalcancerindedicatedcentresinthenetherlandsvantagetrialaprotocol |