Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency
Category: Hindfoot Introduction/Purpose: Spring ligament tear is often present in advanced stages of the AAFD. Anatomic studies have demonstrated that the superficial deltoid ligament blends with the superomedial spring ligament to provide medial tibiotalar and talonavicular stability. Reconstructio...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
SAGE Publishing
2018-09-01
|
| Series: | Foot & Ankle Orthopaedics |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1177/2473011418S00327 |
| _version_ | 1818879323595079680 |
|---|---|
| author | Ashlee MacDonald MD David Ciufo MD Emma Knapp BS Hani Awad John Ketz MD Adolph Flemister MD Jonathan Deland MD Irvin Oh MD |
| author_facet | Ashlee MacDonald MD David Ciufo MD Emma Knapp BS Hani Awad John Ketz MD Adolph Flemister MD Jonathan Deland MD Irvin Oh MD |
| author_sort | Ashlee MacDonald MD |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Category: Hindfoot Introduction/Purpose: Spring ligament tear is often present in advanced stages of the AAFD. Anatomic studies have demonstrated that the superficial deltoid ligament blends with the superomedial spring ligament to provide medial tibiotalar and talonavicular stability. Reconstruction of combined deltoid-spring ligament, or the Tibiocalcaneonvaicular ligament (TCNL) was proposed to augment medial stability in advanced AAFD with large spring ligament tears. A tendon allograft is placed to cross three peritalar (tibiotalar, talonavicular and subtalar) joints to augment medial stability. We aimed to 1) investigate the kinematic effects of TCNL reconstruction in cadaveric flatfoot model with medial ligament insufficiency, and 2) compare TCNL reconstruction with anatomic spring and anatomic deltoid ligament reconstructions (Figure 1). We hypothesized that TCNL reconstruction is effective in restoring peritalar kinematics. Methods: Five fresh-frozen cadaveric foot specimens were employed. Advanced stage flatfoot model was created by sectioning the medial and inferior talonavicular interosseous ligament and extending the release 2 cm proximally along the superomedial spring ligament. Cyclic axial load of 1150 N under a hydraulic loading frame with constant 350 N Achilles tendon load were applied until >15° talo-first metatarsal abduction was achieved. Bone tunnels were drilled for three reconstruction types, and the peroneus longus tendon was configured to reconstruct the 1) anatomic spring ligament, 2) anatomic deltoid ligament, and 3) TCNL. Reflective markers were mounted on the tibia, talus, navicula, calcaneus and first metatarsus. Each reconstruction type was loaded with 800 N ground reaction force, and kinematics of the peritalar joints were captured by 4-camera motion capture system. Forefoot abduction angle, Meary’s angle, and hindfoot valgus were calculated and compared to the severe flatfoot prior to reconstruction and to each using two-way ANOVA. Results: In creating the flatfoot deformity, both the tibiotalar and subtalar joints demonstrated an increase in valgus deformity by 5.6+3.7° and 6.1+5.3°, respectively, compared to the initial measurements. When comparing to the flatfoot deformity, the TCNL reconstruction achieved a significant improvement in percent correction of total hindfoot valgus (59.7+21.1%, p=0.017) and forefoot abduction angle (83.4+17.7%, p<0.01). The spring ligament reconstruction also demonstrated a significant improvement in forefoot abduction correction compared to the flatfoot (52+10.6%, p<0.05). No other reconstruction technique achieved a statistically significant improvement in percent correction compared to the flatfoot model in forefoot or hindfoot alignments. Additionally, no statistical differences were noted in the percent correction when comparing the three reconstructive techniques to each other. Conclusion: In advanced stage cadaveric flatfoot with spring ligament tear, we found increased valgus alignment at both the tibiotalar and subtalar joints. This kinematic changes reflects increased strain across the medial peritalar ligaments. The deltoid-spring ligament complex (TCNL) reconstruction demonstrated significantly improved alignment of hindfoot valgus and forefoot abduction compared to the severe flatfoot condition. This finding suggests that in addition to osseous correction and tendon transfer, the TCNL reconstruction may serve as an important component in augmenting medial stability in advanced AAFD with medial ligament insufficiency. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-19T14:28:15Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-80f7682677af4141a62df08f001c2ddc |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2473-0114 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-19T14:28:15Z |
| publishDate | 2018-09-01 |
| publisher | SAGE Publishing |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Foot & Ankle Orthopaedics |
| spelling | doaj.art-80f7682677af4141a62df08f001c2ddc2022-12-21T20:17:33ZengSAGE PublishingFoot & Ankle Orthopaedics2473-01142018-09-01310.1177/2473011418S00327Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament InsufficiencyAshlee MacDonald MDDavid Ciufo MDEmma Knapp BSHani AwadJohn Ketz MDAdolph Flemister MDJonathan Deland MDIrvin Oh MDCategory: Hindfoot Introduction/Purpose: Spring ligament tear is often present in advanced stages of the AAFD. Anatomic studies have demonstrated that the superficial deltoid ligament blends with the superomedial spring ligament to provide medial tibiotalar and talonavicular stability. Reconstruction of combined deltoid-spring ligament, or the Tibiocalcaneonvaicular ligament (TCNL) was proposed to augment medial stability in advanced AAFD with large spring ligament tears. A tendon allograft is placed to cross three peritalar (tibiotalar, talonavicular and subtalar) joints to augment medial stability. We aimed to 1) investigate the kinematic effects of TCNL reconstruction in cadaveric flatfoot model with medial ligament insufficiency, and 2) compare TCNL reconstruction with anatomic spring and anatomic deltoid ligament reconstructions (Figure 1). We hypothesized that TCNL reconstruction is effective in restoring peritalar kinematics. Methods: Five fresh-frozen cadaveric foot specimens were employed. Advanced stage flatfoot model was created by sectioning the medial and inferior talonavicular interosseous ligament and extending the release 2 cm proximally along the superomedial spring ligament. Cyclic axial load of 1150 N under a hydraulic loading frame with constant 350 N Achilles tendon load were applied until >15° talo-first metatarsal abduction was achieved. Bone tunnels were drilled for three reconstruction types, and the peroneus longus tendon was configured to reconstruct the 1) anatomic spring ligament, 2) anatomic deltoid ligament, and 3) TCNL. Reflective markers were mounted on the tibia, talus, navicula, calcaneus and first metatarsus. Each reconstruction type was loaded with 800 N ground reaction force, and kinematics of the peritalar joints were captured by 4-camera motion capture system. Forefoot abduction angle, Meary’s angle, and hindfoot valgus were calculated and compared to the severe flatfoot prior to reconstruction and to each using two-way ANOVA. Results: In creating the flatfoot deformity, both the tibiotalar and subtalar joints demonstrated an increase in valgus deformity by 5.6+3.7° and 6.1+5.3°, respectively, compared to the initial measurements. When comparing to the flatfoot deformity, the TCNL reconstruction achieved a significant improvement in percent correction of total hindfoot valgus (59.7+21.1%, p=0.017) and forefoot abduction angle (83.4+17.7%, p<0.01). The spring ligament reconstruction also demonstrated a significant improvement in forefoot abduction correction compared to the flatfoot (52+10.6%, p<0.05). No other reconstruction technique achieved a statistically significant improvement in percent correction compared to the flatfoot model in forefoot or hindfoot alignments. Additionally, no statistical differences were noted in the percent correction when comparing the three reconstructive techniques to each other. Conclusion: In advanced stage cadaveric flatfoot with spring ligament tear, we found increased valgus alignment at both the tibiotalar and subtalar joints. This kinematic changes reflects increased strain across the medial peritalar ligaments. The deltoid-spring ligament complex (TCNL) reconstruction demonstrated significantly improved alignment of hindfoot valgus and forefoot abduction compared to the severe flatfoot condition. This finding suggests that in addition to osseous correction and tendon transfer, the TCNL reconstruction may serve as an important component in augmenting medial stability in advanced AAFD with medial ligament insufficiency.https://doi.org/10.1177/2473011418S00327 |
| spellingShingle | Ashlee MacDonald MD David Ciufo MD Emma Knapp BS Hani Awad John Ketz MD Adolph Flemister MD Jonathan Deland MD Irvin Oh MD Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency Foot & Ankle Orthopaedics |
| title | Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency |
| title_full | Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency |
| title_fullStr | Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency |
| title_full_unstemmed | Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency |
| title_short | Tibiocalcaneonavicular Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Flatfoot Deformity with Medial Ligament Insufficiency |
| title_sort | tibiocalcaneonavicular ligament reconstruction in simulated flatfoot deformity with medial ligament insufficiency |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1177/2473011418S00327 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT ashleemacdonaldmd tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT davidciufomd tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT emmaknappbs tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT haniawad tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT johnketzmd tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT adolphflemistermd tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT jonathandelandmd tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency AT irvinohmd tibiocalcaneonavicularligamentreconstructioninsimulatedflatfootdeformitywithmedialligamentinsufficiency |