Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading

This paper presents the response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to earthquake loads. The following earthquakes were applied to the base of the structure: (a) North Ridge, (b) Llolleo, (c) El Centro and (d) Llolleo for the second time. The earthquake displacement signals had to b...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: A Elvin, H C Uzoegbo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: South African Institution of Civil Engineering 2011-04-01
Series:Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineers
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1021-20192011000100003
_version_ 1797712544902676480
author A Elvin
H C Uzoegbo
author_facet A Elvin
H C Uzoegbo
author_sort A Elvin
collection DOAJ
description This paper presents the response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to earthquake loads. The following earthquakes were applied to the base of the structure: (a) North Ridge, (b) Llolleo, (c) El Centro and (d) Llolleo for the second time. The earthquake displacement signals had to be filtered by removing the slow-varying frequency components so that the available servo-hydraulic test machine could be used. The filtering produced acceptably low error when comparing the applied histories with the real earthquake histories. A 4 x 4 m structure was constructed on a 1o of freedom shake table out of mortarless interlocking bricks with minimum reinforcement. A 2 560 kg mass was superimposed on the structure to model the roof. The test structure was instrumented with accelerometers and LVDTs. The results showed that the simulated Llolleo earthquakes caused the most damage. This damage was minor: several bricks cracked, other bricks shifted, vertical gaps opened up between the bricks, and the skim plaster spalled in several places. The Llolleo earthquake damage was estimated to be Grade 2 on the European Macroseismic Scale (EMS). During the earthquake simulations the walls deflected up to 42 mm. However, the maximum permanent deformation recorded due to bricks shifting was only 4,6 mm - a small fraction of the wall thickness. Although the peak ground acceleration (PGA) was 0,7 g, the maximum acceleration experienced by the structure at a door opening was 3,4 g. The tests were concluded by applying two harmonic base excitations. The first 5 Hz harmonic test, which corresponded to the undamaged structure's resonant frequency, produced less damage than the Llolleo earthquake. The second 15 s, 3 Hz sinusoidal base motion, which corresponded to the damaged structure's resonant frequency, caused major damage (EMS Grade 4). Despite major cracks in two walls forming the characteristic "X" failure, the structure continued to support the roof mass. Video analysis clearly demonstrated that dry stacking can result in large brick movements when the base is excited. The ability of the test structure to withstand the applied earthquakes and base harmonic motions is attributed to energy absorption and dissipation due to inter-brick friction and bricks cracking and crushing.
first_indexed 2024-03-12T07:23:20Z
format Article
id doaj.art-82203c8a08434cba8f59f3b0e5dc20f4
institution Directory Open Access Journal
issn 1021-2019
language English
last_indexed 2024-03-12T07:23:20Z
publishDate 2011-04-01
publisher South African Institution of Civil Engineering
record_format Article
series Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineers
spelling doaj.art-82203c8a08434cba8f59f3b0e5dc20f42023-09-02T22:15:42ZengSouth African Institution of Civil EngineeringJournal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineers1021-20192011-04-015312232Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loadingA ElvinH C UzoegboThis paper presents the response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to earthquake loads. The following earthquakes were applied to the base of the structure: (a) North Ridge, (b) Llolleo, (c) El Centro and (d) Llolleo for the second time. The earthquake displacement signals had to be filtered by removing the slow-varying frequency components so that the available servo-hydraulic test machine could be used. The filtering produced acceptably low error when comparing the applied histories with the real earthquake histories. A 4 x 4 m structure was constructed on a 1o of freedom shake table out of mortarless interlocking bricks with minimum reinforcement. A 2 560 kg mass was superimposed on the structure to model the roof. The test structure was instrumented with accelerometers and LVDTs. The results showed that the simulated Llolleo earthquakes caused the most damage. This damage was minor: several bricks cracked, other bricks shifted, vertical gaps opened up between the bricks, and the skim plaster spalled in several places. The Llolleo earthquake damage was estimated to be Grade 2 on the European Macroseismic Scale (EMS). During the earthquake simulations the walls deflected up to 42 mm. However, the maximum permanent deformation recorded due to bricks shifting was only 4,6 mm - a small fraction of the wall thickness. Although the peak ground acceleration (PGA) was 0,7 g, the maximum acceleration experienced by the structure at a door opening was 3,4 g. The tests were concluded by applying two harmonic base excitations. The first 5 Hz harmonic test, which corresponded to the undamaged structure's resonant frequency, produced less damage than the Llolleo earthquake. The second 15 s, 3 Hz sinusoidal base motion, which corresponded to the damaged structure's resonant frequency, caused major damage (EMS Grade 4). Despite major cracks in two walls forming the characteristic "X" failure, the structure continued to support the roof mass. Video analysis clearly demonstrated that dry stacking can result in large brick movements when the base is excited. The ability of the test structure to withstand the applied earthquakes and base harmonic motions is attributed to energy absorption and dissipation due to inter-brick friction and bricks cracking and crushing.http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1021-20192011000100003earthquake testingfull-scale testingbrick structurebrick frictionenergy dissipation
spellingShingle A Elvin
H C Uzoegbo
Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineers
earthquake testing
full-scale testing
brick structure
brick friction
energy dissipation
title Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
title_full Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
title_fullStr Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
title_full_unstemmed Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
title_short Response of a full-scale dry-stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
title_sort response of a full scale dry stack masonry structure subject to experimentally applied earthquake loading
topic earthquake testing
full-scale testing
brick structure
brick friction
energy dissipation
url http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1021-20192011000100003
work_keys_str_mv AT aelvin responseofafullscaledrystackmasonrystructuresubjecttoexperimentallyappliedearthquakeloading
AT hcuzoegbo responseofafullscaledrystackmasonrystructuresubjecttoexperimentallyappliedearthquakeloading