TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE
Vitgenšteiniška tiesos ir tikrumo sampratos analizė reikalauja bent paviršutiniškai išmanyti tradicinę tiesos interpretaciją. Straipsnyje ši interpretacija trumpai aptariama atsižvelgiant į tris tiesos aspektus - ontologinį, loginį ir etinį. Veikale "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus" Wittge...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Vilnius University Press
2003-01-01
|
| Series: | Problemos |
| Online Access: | https://www12032.vu.lt/problemos/article/view/4131 |
| _version_ | 1797383538347081728 |
|---|---|
| author | Albinas Plėšnys |
| author_facet | Albinas Plėšnys |
| author_sort | Albinas Plėšnys |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description |
Vitgenšteiniška tiesos ir tikrumo sampratos analizė reikalauja bent paviršutiniškai išmanyti tradicinę tiesos interpretaciją. Straipsnyje ši interpretacija trumpai aptariama atsižvelgiant į tris tiesos aspektus - ontologinį, loginį ir etinį. Veikale "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus" Wittgensteinas pateikia konkrečią ontologinę koncepciją, kuria remdamasis suformuluoja savąją tiesos sampratą. "Filosofiniuose tyrinėjimuose" pagrindine tampa kalbinio žaidimo sąvoka. Vėlyvasis Wittgensteinas nepripažįsta jokių išankstinių taisyklių ar prielaidų, kurios leistų apibrėžti pasaulio struktūrą ir nurodytų teiginių priimtinumo sąlygas. Atsisakęs apriorinės ir vienintelės ontologinės schemos, jis atsisako ir ontologinės tiesos koncepcijos, pakeisdamas ją tikrumo sąvoka, kuri yra vidinė kalbinio žaidimo ypatybė. Jo nuomone, tikrumas reiškia tik tai, kad neegzistuoja alternatyvaus kalbinio žaidimo, kuris leistų manyti kitaip.
Prasminiai žodžiai: loginis vaizdas, loginė erdvė, kalbinis žaidimas, tiesa, tikrumas.
THE TRUTH AND CERTAINTY IN WITTGENSTEIN?S PHILOSOPHY
Albinas Plėšnys
Summary
Truth can be treated from at least three viewpoints. First, truth is an ontological concept, subordinated to that ontological model to which a particular philosopher adheres. In the Aristotelian philosophical tradition, truth is a transcendental concept, expressing the relationship between being and cognition. The Aristotelian tradition describes truth as the correspondence between the thing and the intellect - veritas est adaequatio rei et intellectus.
The second aspect of truth is logical. Its essence could be formulated in the following way: is it possible to use the concept of truth logically correctly and precisely in a language, characterized by an exact structure? In his famous article The Semantic Conception of Truth and the Foundations of Semantics Alfred Tarski proved that a logically irreproachable conception of truth is possible if the object language and the metalanguage are discerned.
The third aspect of truth is ethical, but it is not the topic of present discussion.
In his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus Ludwig Wittgenstein proposed the ontological model by means of which he formulated the conception of truth as the correspondence of facts to reality in a logical space. The conception of truth here turns into a basis of distinguishing between what can be talked about and what should be passed over in silence.
Truth is one of the major problems in Tractatus. The later Wittgenstein abandoned his ontological scheme and a related conception of exact truth. In Philosophical Investigations the central issue is the concept of the language-game. The language-game consists not only of linguistic rules and names of objects. The whole process of using words, for Wittgenstein, is a certain part of an activity and a form of life. Later Wittgenstein does not recognize any a priori instructions or rules, which would allow to determine the correctness of the proposition or the structure of the world. Having abandoned the a priori and the only ontological scheme, Wittgenstein abandons the conception of ontological truth as well, treating certainty as an internal feature of the language-game. In his opinion, subjective certainty means merely that there does not exist an alternative language-game which could raise doubts about certainty.
Keywords: certainty, language-game, truth, logical space, logical picture.
|
| first_indexed | 2024-03-08T21:22:25Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-aa42965036de4cc29ef75bbe047fca1b |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1392-1126 2424-6158 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-08T21:22:25Z |
| publishDate | 2003-01-01 |
| publisher | Vilnius University Press |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Problemos |
| spelling | doaj.art-aa42965036de4cc29ef75bbe047fca1b2023-12-21T08:58:30ZengVilnius University PressProblemos1392-11262424-61582003-01-0164TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJEAlbinas Plėšnys Vitgenšteiniška tiesos ir tikrumo sampratos analizė reikalauja bent paviršutiniškai išmanyti tradicinę tiesos interpretaciją. Straipsnyje ši interpretacija trumpai aptariama atsižvelgiant į tris tiesos aspektus - ontologinį, loginį ir etinį. Veikale "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus" Wittgensteinas pateikia konkrečią ontologinę koncepciją, kuria remdamasis suformuluoja savąją tiesos sampratą. "Filosofiniuose tyrinėjimuose" pagrindine tampa kalbinio žaidimo sąvoka. Vėlyvasis Wittgensteinas nepripažįsta jokių išankstinių taisyklių ar prielaidų, kurios leistų apibrėžti pasaulio struktūrą ir nurodytų teiginių priimtinumo sąlygas. Atsisakęs apriorinės ir vienintelės ontologinės schemos, jis atsisako ir ontologinės tiesos koncepcijos, pakeisdamas ją tikrumo sąvoka, kuri yra vidinė kalbinio žaidimo ypatybė. Jo nuomone, tikrumas reiškia tik tai, kad neegzistuoja alternatyvaus kalbinio žaidimo, kuris leistų manyti kitaip. Prasminiai žodžiai: loginis vaizdas, loginė erdvė, kalbinis žaidimas, tiesa, tikrumas. THE TRUTH AND CERTAINTY IN WITTGENSTEIN?S PHILOSOPHY Albinas Plėšnys Summary Truth can be treated from at least three viewpoints. First, truth is an ontological concept, subordinated to that ontological model to which a particular philosopher adheres. In the Aristotelian philosophical tradition, truth is a transcendental concept, expressing the relationship between being and cognition. The Aristotelian tradition describes truth as the correspondence between the thing and the intellect - veritas est adaequatio rei et intellectus. The second aspect of truth is logical. Its essence could be formulated in the following way: is it possible to use the concept of truth logically correctly and precisely in a language, characterized by an exact structure? In his famous article The Semantic Conception of Truth and the Foundations of Semantics Alfred Tarski proved that a logically irreproachable conception of truth is possible if the object language and the metalanguage are discerned. The third aspect of truth is ethical, but it is not the topic of present discussion. In his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus Ludwig Wittgenstein proposed the ontological model by means of which he formulated the conception of truth as the correspondence of facts to reality in a logical space. The conception of truth here turns into a basis of distinguishing between what can be talked about and what should be passed over in silence. Truth is one of the major problems in Tractatus. The later Wittgenstein abandoned his ontological scheme and a related conception of exact truth. In Philosophical Investigations the central issue is the concept of the language-game. The language-game consists not only of linguistic rules and names of objects. The whole process of using words, for Wittgenstein, is a certain part of an activity and a form of life. Later Wittgenstein does not recognize any a priori instructions or rules, which would allow to determine the correctness of the proposition or the structure of the world. Having abandoned the a priori and the only ontological scheme, Wittgenstein abandons the conception of ontological truth as well, treating certainty as an internal feature of the language-game. In his opinion, subjective certainty means merely that there does not exist an alternative language-game which could raise doubts about certainty. Keywords: certainty, language-game, truth, logical space, logical picture. https://www12032.vu.lt/problemos/article/view/4131 |
| spellingShingle | Albinas Plėšnys TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE Problemos |
| title | TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE |
| title_full | TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE |
| title_fullStr | TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE |
| title_full_unstemmed | TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE |
| title_short | TIESA IR TIKRUMAS WITTGENSTEINO FILOSOFIJOJE |
| title_sort | tiesa ir tikrumas wittgensteino filosofijoje |
| url | https://www12032.vu.lt/problemos/article/view/4131 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT albinasplesnys tiesairtikrumaswittgensteinofilosofijoje |