Causal Emergence: When Distortions in a Map Obscure the Territory

We provide a critical assessment of the account of causal emergence presented in Erik Hoel’s 2017 article “When the map is better than the territory”. The account integrates causal and information theoretic concepts to explain under what circumstances there can be causal descriptions of a system at...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Frederick Eberhardt, Lin Lin Lee
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2022-03-01
Series:Philosophies
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2409-9287/7/2/30
Description
Summary:We provide a critical assessment of the account of causal emergence presented in Erik Hoel’s 2017 article “When the map is better than the territory”. The account integrates causal and information theoretic concepts to explain under what circumstances there can be causal descriptions of a system at multiple scales of analysis. We show that the causal macro variables implied by this account result in interventions with significant ambiguity, and that the operations of marginalization and abstraction do not commute. Both of these are desiderata that, we argue, any account of multi-scale causal analysis should be sensitive to. The problems we highlight in Hoel’s definition of causal emergence derive from the use of various averaging steps and the introduction of a maximum entropy distribution that is extraneous to the system under investigation.
ISSN:2409-9287