Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia
Študija z raziskavo novinarskega sporočanja o projektu poskusnega izračuna vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji zapolnjuje vrzel pri raziskovanju medijske podobe geodetskega dela in skupnosti. Kvantitativna analiza vsebine in kvalitativna kritična diskurzivna analiza novinarskih prispevkov o tem projek...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Association of Surveyors of Slovenia (Zveza geodetov Slovenije)
2011-01-01
|
| Series: | Geodetski Vestnik |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://www.geodetski-vestnik.com/55/3/gv55-3_530-545.pdf |
| _version_ | 1818835448109203456 |
|---|---|
| author | Karmen Erjavec Melita Poler Kovačič |
| author_facet | Karmen Erjavec Melita Poler Kovačič |
| author_sort | Karmen Erjavec |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Študija z raziskavo novinarskega sporočanja o projektu poskusnega izračuna vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji zapolnjuje vrzel pri raziskovanju medijske podobe geodetskega dela in skupnosti. Kvantitativna analiza vsebine in kvalitativna kritična diskurzivna analiza novinarskih prispevkov o tem projektu v petih slovenskih dnevnih časopisih razkrivata prevladujoče negativno stališče glede njegove uspešnosti, saj je bil v skupno skoraj 60 % novinarskih prispevkih označen negativno, pozitivno stališče pa je bilo najti le v približno 12 % prispevkov. Tudi analiza tem kaže, da so časniki poudarjali predvsem negativne plati projekta. Analiza virov potrjuje ključno vlogo uradnih virov, zlasti Geodetske uprave RS (Gurs), nepričakovano pa so se kot vir razmeroma veliko pojavljali »navadni državljani«. Kvalitativna analiza je omogočila natančen vpogled v prevladujočo osnovno trditev o nezadovoljstvu lastnikov z delom Gursa ter v precej redkeje zastopani trditvi o dobro opravljenem delu Gursa ter izvedbi obsežnega in pomembnega projekta. Analiza poimenovanj razkriva, kako so novinarji z uporabo besed s skrajno negativno konotacijo in čustveno zaznamovanimi opisi negativnih izkušenj bralcev konstruirali pomen, ki zmanjšuje ugled Gursa in geodetske skupnosti. Rezultati vzbujajo dvom, ali so bili državljani dobro obveščeni o projektu. Postavlja se tudi vprašanje, ali je bila strategija komuniciranja geodetske skupnosti z mediji dovolj dobro načrtovana in izvajana ; By researching news reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia, this study fills a gap in researching media images of the work and community of geodesy. A quantitative content analysis and a critical discourse analysis of news items on this project in five Slovenian daily newspapers reveal a predominantly negative view of its success, as almost 60% of news items described it negatively, while a positive view was found only in nearly 12% of reports. An analysis of topics also shows that newspapers emphasized the negative aspects of the project above all. An analysis of sources confirms the key role of official sources, particularly the Surveying and Mapping Authority of the Republic Slovenia (GURS). ‘Ordinary citizens’ were unexpectedly used as a source relatively frequently. The qualitative analysis enabled a precise insight into the prevalent macro-proposition about owners’ discontent with the work of GURS and into the much less frequently included macro-propositions about GURS performing its work well, and about its carrying out an extensive, important project. An analysis of the words used reveals how journalists, by using words with extremely negative connotations and emotional descriptions of readers’ experiences, constructed a meaning that diminishes the reputation of GURS and the geodesic community. The results raise doubts about whether the citizens were well informed about the project. A question also appears about whether the strategy of the geodesic community’s communication with the media has been planned and performed well enough. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-19T02:50:52Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-b9eebdd8094b427c9ec8dbf424f0453b |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 0351-0271 1581-1328 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-19T02:50:52Z |
| publishDate | 2011-01-01 |
| publisher | Association of Surveyors of Slovenia (Zveza geodetov Slovenije) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Geodetski Vestnik |
| spelling | doaj.art-b9eebdd8094b427c9ec8dbf424f0453b2022-12-21T20:38:40ZengAssociation of Surveyors of Slovenia (Zveza geodetov Slovenije)Geodetski Vestnik0351-02711581-13282011-01-0155530545Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in SloveniaKarmen ErjavecMelita Poler KovačičŠtudija z raziskavo novinarskega sporočanja o projektu poskusnega izračuna vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji zapolnjuje vrzel pri raziskovanju medijske podobe geodetskega dela in skupnosti. Kvantitativna analiza vsebine in kvalitativna kritična diskurzivna analiza novinarskih prispevkov o tem projektu v petih slovenskih dnevnih časopisih razkrivata prevladujoče negativno stališče glede njegove uspešnosti, saj je bil v skupno skoraj 60 % novinarskih prispevkih označen negativno, pozitivno stališče pa je bilo najti le v približno 12 % prispevkov. Tudi analiza tem kaže, da so časniki poudarjali predvsem negativne plati projekta. Analiza virov potrjuje ključno vlogo uradnih virov, zlasti Geodetske uprave RS (Gurs), nepričakovano pa so se kot vir razmeroma veliko pojavljali »navadni državljani«. Kvalitativna analiza je omogočila natančen vpogled v prevladujočo osnovno trditev o nezadovoljstvu lastnikov z delom Gursa ter v precej redkeje zastopani trditvi o dobro opravljenem delu Gursa ter izvedbi obsežnega in pomembnega projekta. Analiza poimenovanj razkriva, kako so novinarji z uporabo besed s skrajno negativno konotacijo in čustveno zaznamovanimi opisi negativnih izkušenj bralcev konstruirali pomen, ki zmanjšuje ugled Gursa in geodetske skupnosti. Rezultati vzbujajo dvom, ali so bili državljani dobro obveščeni o projektu. Postavlja se tudi vprašanje, ali je bila strategija komuniciranja geodetske skupnosti z mediji dovolj dobro načrtovana in izvajana ; By researching news reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia, this study fills a gap in researching media images of the work and community of geodesy. A quantitative content analysis and a critical discourse analysis of news items on this project in five Slovenian daily newspapers reveal a predominantly negative view of its success, as almost 60% of news items described it negatively, while a positive view was found only in nearly 12% of reports. An analysis of topics also shows that newspapers emphasized the negative aspects of the project above all. An analysis of sources confirms the key role of official sources, particularly the Surveying and Mapping Authority of the Republic Slovenia (GURS). ‘Ordinary citizens’ were unexpectedly used as a source relatively frequently. The qualitative analysis enabled a precise insight into the prevalent macro-proposition about owners’ discontent with the work of GURS and into the much less frequently included macro-propositions about GURS performing its work well, and about its carrying out an extensive, important project. An analysis of the words used reveals how journalists, by using words with extremely negative connotations and emotional descriptions of readers’ experiences, constructed a meaning that diminishes the reputation of GURS and the geodesic community. The results raise doubts about whether the citizens were well informed about the project. A question also appears about whether the strategy of the geodesic community’s communication with the media has been planned and performed well enough.http://www.geodetski-vestnik.com/55/3/gv55-3_530-545.pdfjournalismmass mediareal estate valuetest calculationSlovenianovinarstvomnožični medijivrednost nepremičninposkusni izračunSlovenija |
| spellingShingle | Karmen Erjavec Melita Poler Kovačič Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia Geodetski Vestnik journalism mass media real estate value test calculation Slovenia novinarstvo množični mediji vrednost nepremičnin poskusni izračun Slovenija |
| title | Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia |
| title_full | Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia |
| title_fullStr | Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia |
| title_full_unstemmed | Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia |
| title_short | Novinarsko sporočanje o poskusnem izračunu vrednosti nepremičnin v Sloveniji : News reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in Slovenia |
| title_sort | novinarsko sporocanje o poskusnem izracunu vrednosti nepremicnin v sloveniji news reporting on the test calculation of real estate value in slovenia |
| topic | journalism mass media real estate value test calculation Slovenia novinarstvo množični mediji vrednost nepremičnin poskusni izračun Slovenija |
| url | http://www.geodetski-vestnik.com/55/3/gv55-3_530-545.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT karmenerjavec novinarskosporocanjeoposkusnemizracunuvrednostinepremicninvslovenijinewsreportingonthetestcalculationofrealestatevalueinslovenia AT melitapolerkovacic novinarskosporocanjeoposkusnemizracunuvrednostinepremicninvslovenijinewsreportingonthetestcalculationofrealestatevalueinslovenia |