The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law
(Series Information) European Papers - A Journal on Law and Integration, 2020 5(2), 1001-1020 | European Forum Insight of 24 September 2020 | (Table of Contents) I. Introduction. - II. Words have Wings: Opinion of AG Sharpston and the judgment of the Court. - II.1. Opinion of the AG (31 October 2019...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
European Papers (www.europeanpapers.eu)
2020-09-01
|
| Series: | European Papers |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.europeanpapers.eu/en/europeanforum/nh-case-wings-of-words-in-eu-antidiscrimination-law |
| _version_ | 1830161648878354432 |
|---|---|
| author | Uladzislau Belavusau |
| author_facet | Uladzislau Belavusau |
| author_sort | Uladzislau Belavusau |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | (Series Information) European Papers - A Journal on Law and Integration, 2020 5(2), 1001-1020 | European Forum Insight of 24 September 2020 | (Table of Contents) I. Introduction. - II. Words have Wings: Opinion of AG Sharpston and the judgment of the Court. - II.1. Opinion of the AG (31 October 2019). - II.2. Judgment of the Grand Chamber of the CJEU (23 April 2020). - III. Comment. - III.1. Is acte clair out of fashion in Luxembourg? - III.2. Clarifying achievements and missed opportunities of the NH case. - IV. Summary: Paroles, paroles, paroles. | (Abstract) This Insight examines a judgment of the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice in case C-507/17, NH v. Associa-zione Avvocatura per I Diritti LGBTI - Rete Lenford (23 April 2020). In its preliminary ruling, the Court deliberat-ed on whether a statement made by a senior lawyer at an Italian law firm during a media interview, abstractly asserting that he would never hire a gay colleague, constituted direct discrimination in terms of EU law, even though no specific vacancy opening was advertised at the time of the interview. Furthermore, the Court consid-ered whether a local LGBTI organization (an association of lawyers) had standing to bring a lawsuit for damages even though none of its affiliates were applying for a position at the law firm. The case fits the sequel - now forming a "Luxembourg trilogy" - of three judgments of the Court of Justice on similar matters of racist and ho-mophobic speech akin to direct discrimination in the employment context, with judgments in C-54/07 Feryn (10 July 2008) and C-81/12 Asociaţia ACCEPT (25 April 2013) preceding the C-507/17 NH and answering most of NH's outstanding questions. It remains questionable, therefore, whether the preliminary ruling of the Court of Justice in the NH case was even necessary in terms of the acte clair doctrine or whether this 2020 judgment substan-tively clarified EU anti-discrimination law. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-17T15:05:50Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-bd15d33167b24ef3b467b221e941518d |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2499-8249 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-17T15:05:50Z |
| publishDate | 2020-09-01 |
| publisher | European Papers (www.europeanpapers.eu) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | European Papers |
| spelling | doaj.art-bd15d33167b24ef3b467b221e941518d2022-12-21T21:43:48ZengEuropean Papers (www.europeanpapers.eu)European Papers2499-82492020-09-012020 521001102010.15166/2499-8249/395The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination LawUladzislau Belavusau0University of Amsterdam(Series Information) European Papers - A Journal on Law and Integration, 2020 5(2), 1001-1020 | European Forum Insight of 24 September 2020 | (Table of Contents) I. Introduction. - II. Words have Wings: Opinion of AG Sharpston and the judgment of the Court. - II.1. Opinion of the AG (31 October 2019). - II.2. Judgment of the Grand Chamber of the CJEU (23 April 2020). - III. Comment. - III.1. Is acte clair out of fashion in Luxembourg? - III.2. Clarifying achievements and missed opportunities of the NH case. - IV. Summary: Paroles, paroles, paroles. | (Abstract) This Insight examines a judgment of the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice in case C-507/17, NH v. Associa-zione Avvocatura per I Diritti LGBTI - Rete Lenford (23 April 2020). In its preliminary ruling, the Court deliberat-ed on whether a statement made by a senior lawyer at an Italian law firm during a media interview, abstractly asserting that he would never hire a gay colleague, constituted direct discrimination in terms of EU law, even though no specific vacancy opening was advertised at the time of the interview. Furthermore, the Court consid-ered whether a local LGBTI organization (an association of lawyers) had standing to bring a lawsuit for damages even though none of its affiliates were applying for a position at the law firm. The case fits the sequel - now forming a "Luxembourg trilogy" - of three judgments of the Court of Justice on similar matters of racist and ho-mophobic speech akin to direct discrimination in the employment context, with judgments in C-54/07 Feryn (10 July 2008) and C-81/12 Asociaţia ACCEPT (25 April 2013) preceding the C-507/17 NH and answering most of NH's outstanding questions. It remains questionable, therefore, whether the preliminary ruling of the Court of Justice in the NH case was even necessary in terms of the acte clair doctrine or whether this 2020 judgment substan-tively clarified EU anti-discrimination law.https://www.europeanpapers.eu/en/europeanforum/nh-case-wings-of-words-in-eu-antidiscrimination-lawassociazione avvocatura per i diritti lgbtiframework equality directive (2000)homophobic speechfreedom of expressionlgbti rightsdirect discrimination |
| spellingShingle | Uladzislau Belavusau The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law European Papers associazione avvocatura per i diritti lgbti framework equality directive (2000) homophobic speech freedom of expression lgbti rights direct discrimination |
| title | The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law |
| title_full | The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law |
| title_fullStr | The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law |
| title_full_unstemmed | The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law |
| title_short | The NH Case: On the 'Wings of Words' in EU Anti-discrimination Law |
| title_sort | nh case on the wings of words in eu anti discrimination law |
| topic | associazione avvocatura per i diritti lgbti framework equality directive (2000) homophobic speech freedom of expression lgbti rights direct discrimination |
| url | https://www.europeanpapers.eu/en/europeanforum/nh-case-wings-of-words-in-eu-antidiscrimination-law |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT uladzislaubelavusau thenhcaseonthewingsofwordsineuantidiscriminationlaw AT uladzislaubelavusau nhcaseonthewingsofwordsineuantidiscriminationlaw |