Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience
BackgroundThere is growing interest in using mobile apps and online tools to support postsecondary student mental health, but most of these solutions have suboptimal user engagement in real-world settings. Poor engagement can limit long-term effectiveness and usefulness of these tools. Previous lite...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
JMIR Publications
2021-04-01
|
| Series: | JMIR Mental Health |
| Online Access: | https://mental.jmir.org/2021/4/e23447 |
| _version_ | 1818902060769214464 |
|---|---|
| author | Wong, Howard W Lo, Brian Shi, Jenny Hollenberg, Elisa Abi-Jaoude, Alexxa Johnson, Andrew Chaim, Gloria Cleverley, Kristin Henderson, Joanna Levinson, Andrea Robb, Janine Voineskos, Aristotle Wiljer, David |
| author_facet | Wong, Howard W Lo, Brian Shi, Jenny Hollenberg, Elisa Abi-Jaoude, Alexxa Johnson, Andrew Chaim, Gloria Cleverley, Kristin Henderson, Joanna Levinson, Andrea Robb, Janine Voineskos, Aristotle Wiljer, David |
| author_sort | Wong, Howard W |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | BackgroundThere is growing interest in using mobile apps and online tools to support postsecondary student mental health, but most of these solutions have suboptimal user engagement in real-world settings. Poor engagement can limit long-term effectiveness and usefulness of these tools. Previous literature has proposed several theories that link factors such as low usability and poor user-centered design to app disengagement. However, few studies provide direct evidence showing what factors contribute to suboptimal user engagement in the context of mobile mental health apps for postsecondary students.
ObjectiveThis study focuses on understanding postsecondary students’ attitudes and behaviors when using Thought Spot, a co-designed mental health app and online platform, to understand factors related to engagement and user experience.
MethodsStudents who were given access to Thought Spot for 6 months during a randomized trial of the intervention were invited to participate in one-on-one semistructured interviews. The interviews explored participants’ overall experiences and perceptions of the app, along with factors that affected their usage of various features. All interviews were recorded, and template analysis was used to analyze transcripts.
ResultsUser satisfaction was mixed among users of Thought Spot. The degree of engagement with the app appeared to be affected by factors that can be grouped into 5 themes: (1) Students valued detailed, inclusive, and relevant content; (2) Technical glitches and a lack of integration with other apps affected the overall user experience and satisfaction with the app; (3) Using the app to support peers or family can increase engagement; (4) Crowdsourced information from peers about mental health resources drove user engagement, but was difficult to obtain; and (5) Users often turned to the app when they had an immediate need for mental health information, rather than using it to track mental health information over time.
ConclusionsContent, user experience, user-centeredness, and peer support are important determinants of user engagement with mobile mental health apps among postsecondary students. In this study, participants disengaged when the app did not meet their expectations on these determinants. Future studies on user engagement should further explore the effectiveness of different features and the relative importance of various criteria for high-quality apps. Further focus on these issues may inform the creation of interventions that increase student engagement and align with their mental health needs.
Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov NCT03412461; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03412461
International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID)RR2-10.2196/resprot.6446 |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-19T20:29:39Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-cd799bb8893748fc858c1463e18f164d |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2368-7959 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-19T20:29:39Z |
| publishDate | 2021-04-01 |
| publisher | JMIR Publications |
| record_format | Article |
| series | JMIR Mental Health |
| spelling | doaj.art-cd799bb8893748fc858c1463e18f164d2022-12-21T20:06:45ZengJMIR PublicationsJMIR Mental Health2368-79592021-04-0184e2344710.2196/23447Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User ExperienceWong, Howard WLo, BrianShi, JennyHollenberg, ElisaAbi-Jaoude, AlexxaJohnson, AndrewChaim, GloriaCleverley, KristinHenderson, JoannaLevinson, AndreaRobb, JanineVoineskos, AristotleWiljer, DavidBackgroundThere is growing interest in using mobile apps and online tools to support postsecondary student mental health, but most of these solutions have suboptimal user engagement in real-world settings. Poor engagement can limit long-term effectiveness and usefulness of these tools. Previous literature has proposed several theories that link factors such as low usability and poor user-centered design to app disengagement. However, few studies provide direct evidence showing what factors contribute to suboptimal user engagement in the context of mobile mental health apps for postsecondary students. ObjectiveThis study focuses on understanding postsecondary students’ attitudes and behaviors when using Thought Spot, a co-designed mental health app and online platform, to understand factors related to engagement and user experience. MethodsStudents who were given access to Thought Spot for 6 months during a randomized trial of the intervention were invited to participate in one-on-one semistructured interviews. The interviews explored participants’ overall experiences and perceptions of the app, along with factors that affected their usage of various features. All interviews were recorded, and template analysis was used to analyze transcripts. ResultsUser satisfaction was mixed among users of Thought Spot. The degree of engagement with the app appeared to be affected by factors that can be grouped into 5 themes: (1) Students valued detailed, inclusive, and relevant content; (2) Technical glitches and a lack of integration with other apps affected the overall user experience and satisfaction with the app; (3) Using the app to support peers or family can increase engagement; (4) Crowdsourced information from peers about mental health resources drove user engagement, but was difficult to obtain; and (5) Users often turned to the app when they had an immediate need for mental health information, rather than using it to track mental health information over time. ConclusionsContent, user experience, user-centeredness, and peer support are important determinants of user engagement with mobile mental health apps among postsecondary students. In this study, participants disengaged when the app did not meet their expectations on these determinants. Future studies on user engagement should further explore the effectiveness of different features and the relative importance of various criteria for high-quality apps. Further focus on these issues may inform the creation of interventions that increase student engagement and align with their mental health needs. Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov NCT03412461; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03412461 International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID)RR2-10.2196/resprot.6446https://mental.jmir.org/2021/4/e23447 |
| spellingShingle | Wong, Howard W Lo, Brian Shi, Jenny Hollenberg, Elisa Abi-Jaoude, Alexxa Johnson, Andrew Chaim, Gloria Cleverley, Kristin Henderson, Joanna Levinson, Andrea Robb, Janine Voineskos, Aristotle Wiljer, David Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience JMIR Mental Health |
| title | Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience |
| title_full | Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience |
| title_fullStr | Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience |
| title_full_unstemmed | Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience |
| title_short | Postsecondary Student Engagement With a Mental Health App and Online Platform (Thought Spot): Qualitative Study of User Experience |
| title_sort | postsecondary student engagement with a mental health app and online platform thought spot qualitative study of user experience |
| url | https://mental.jmir.org/2021/4/e23447 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT wonghowardw postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT lobrian postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT shijenny postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT hollenbergelisa postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT abijaoudealexxa postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT johnsonandrew postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT chaimgloria postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT cleverleykristin postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT hendersonjoanna postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT levinsonandrea postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT robbjanine postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT voineskosaristotle postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience AT wiljerdavid postsecondarystudentengagementwithamentalhealthappandonlineplatformthoughtspotqualitativestudyofuserexperience |