Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills

This article presents a techno-economic analysis of upgrading a Photovoltaic (PV) power system at large. A comparative study has been carried out considering various technical and economic factors like per unit cost, annual load, energy demand growth, and PV panel efficiency, annual performance deg...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Arslan Ahmed, Syed Ali Abbas Kazmi, Mustafa Anwar, Adeel Waqas
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: The University of Lahore 2023-10-01
Series:Pakistan Journal of Engineering & Technology
Subjects:
Online Access:https://hpej.net/journals/pakjet/article/view/2638
_version_ 1797659277160087552
author Arslan Ahmed
Syed Ali Abbas Kazmi
Mustafa Anwar
Adeel Waqas
author_facet Arslan Ahmed
Syed Ali Abbas Kazmi
Mustafa Anwar
Adeel Waqas
author_sort Arslan Ahmed
collection DOAJ
description This article presents a techno-economic analysis of upgrading a Photovoltaic (PV) power system at large. A comparative study has been carried out considering various technical and economic factors like per unit cost, annual load, energy demand growth, and PV panel efficiency, annual performance degradation of system, cost of electricity, payback period, initial capital expenditure, and rate of return in the form of saving in energy bills. The PV system is proposed to be upgraded from 1 MW to 2 MW at the National University of Sciences & Technology (NUST), Islamabad. The PV system is subject to be upgraded due to the growth rate of annual load and amount saved by PV contribution, which has been forecasted using data trends of the above-mentioned technical and economic factors. While considering these factors, four economic models have been evaluated and compared, which include Self-Built via Contractor with self-financing, Self-Built with bank financing, Power purchase agreement (PPA), also known as rental agreement and Built, Own, Operate & Transfer (BOOT) model. Merits and demerits of these models have been discussed, and the most feasible model has been proposed based on the mentioned key factors and long-term sustainable development goals (SDG) for affordable clean energy to contribute to climate action, i.e., adaptation of renewable energy resources (RER) and reduction of greenhouse gases (GHG).
first_indexed 2024-03-11T18:11:36Z
format Article
id doaj.art-d7c3bb6aac2a4c56bf0badcc0804e761
institution Directory Open Access Journal
issn 2664-2042
2664-2050
language English
last_indexed 2024-03-11T18:11:36Z
publishDate 2023-10-01
publisher The University of Lahore
record_format Article
series Pakistan Journal of Engineering & Technology
spelling doaj.art-d7c3bb6aac2a4c56bf0badcc0804e7612023-10-16T13:06:12ZengThe University of LahorePakistan Journal of Engineering & Technology2664-20422664-20502023-10-016310.51846/vol6iss3pp16-24Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy BillsArslan Ahmed0Syed Ali Abbas Kazmi1Mustafa Anwar2Adeel Waqas3Department of Electrical Power Engineering, USPCAE, NUST, Islamabad, PakistanDepartment of Electrical Power Engineering, USPCASE, NUST, Islamabad, PakistanDepartment of Energy Systems Engineering, USPCASE, NUST, Islamabad, PakistanDepartment of Energy Systems Engineering, USPCASE, NUST, Islamabad, Pakistan This article presents a techno-economic analysis of upgrading a Photovoltaic (PV) power system at large. A comparative study has been carried out considering various technical and economic factors like per unit cost, annual load, energy demand growth, and PV panel efficiency, annual performance degradation of system, cost of electricity, payback period, initial capital expenditure, and rate of return in the form of saving in energy bills. The PV system is proposed to be upgraded from 1 MW to 2 MW at the National University of Sciences & Technology (NUST), Islamabad. The PV system is subject to be upgraded due to the growth rate of annual load and amount saved by PV contribution, which has been forecasted using data trends of the above-mentioned technical and economic factors. While considering these factors, four economic models have been evaluated and compared, which include Self-Built via Contractor with self-financing, Self-Built with bank financing, Power purchase agreement (PPA), also known as rental agreement and Built, Own, Operate & Transfer (BOOT) model. Merits and demerits of these models have been discussed, and the most feasible model has been proposed based on the mentioned key factors and long-term sustainable development goals (SDG) for affordable clean energy to contribute to climate action, i.e., adaptation of renewable energy resources (RER) and reduction of greenhouse gases (GHG). https://hpej.net/journals/pakjet/article/view/2638Annual Load GrowthAnnual Energy SavingCapital ExpenditurePayback PeriodPower Purchase AgreementRenewable Energy Resources
spellingShingle Arslan Ahmed
Syed Ali Abbas Kazmi
Mustafa Anwar
Adeel Waqas
Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills
Pakistan Journal of Engineering & Technology
Annual Load Growth
Annual Energy Saving
Capital Expenditure
Payback Period
Power Purchase Agreement
Renewable Energy Resources
title Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills
title_full Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills
title_fullStr Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills
title_full_unstemmed Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills
title_short Comparison of Techno-Economic Models for Upgrading PV System without Net-Metering Option and Long Term Impact on Energy Bills
title_sort comparison of techno economic models for upgrading pv system without net metering option and long term impact on energy bills
topic Annual Load Growth
Annual Energy Saving
Capital Expenditure
Payback Period
Power Purchase Agreement
Renewable Energy Resources
url https://hpej.net/journals/pakjet/article/view/2638
work_keys_str_mv AT arslanahmed comparisonoftechnoeconomicmodelsforupgradingpvsystemwithoutnetmeteringoptionandlongtermimpactonenergybills
AT syedaliabbaskazmi comparisonoftechnoeconomicmodelsforupgradingpvsystemwithoutnetmeteringoptionandlongtermimpactonenergybills
AT mustafaanwar comparisonoftechnoeconomicmodelsforupgradingpvsystemwithoutnetmeteringoptionandlongtermimpactonenergybills
AT adeelwaqas comparisonoftechnoeconomicmodelsforupgradingpvsystemwithoutnetmeteringoptionandlongtermimpactonenergybills