High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland
Abstract Seed limitation represents a fundamental constraint to the restoration of native plant communities, and practitioners often apply seed additions to overcome this barrier. However, surprisingly few studies have experimentally tested whether seed additions can increase diversity in herbaceous...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Wiley
2023-01-01
|
| Series: | Ecological Solutions and Evidence |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1002/2688-8319.12202 |
| _version_ | 1797858645694742528 |
|---|---|
| author | Andrew D. Kaul Noah D. Dell Bradley M. Delfeld Megan J. Engelhardt Quinn G. Long J. Leighton Reid Michael L. Saxton James C. Trager Matthew A. Albrecht |
| author_facet | Andrew D. Kaul Noah D. Dell Bradley M. Delfeld Megan J. Engelhardt Quinn G. Long J. Leighton Reid Michael L. Saxton James C. Trager Matthew A. Albrecht |
| author_sort | Andrew D. Kaul |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Seed limitation represents a fundamental constraint to the restoration of native plant communities, and practitioners often apply seed additions to overcome this barrier. However, surprisingly few studies have experimentally tested whether seed additions can increase diversity in herbaceous communities of oak woodlands, which have undergone large‐scale transformation due to logging, altered fire regimes and invasion by non‐native species. Previous studies suggest that structural (thinning of woody biomass) and process‐based (prescribed fire) restoration treatments alone are unlikely to restore the full breadth of taxonomic and functional diversity in the herb layer, which accounts for most species in woodland ecosystems. To explore whether seed additions can improve restoration outcomes in an oak woodland, we sowed high‐diversity seed mixes in paired transects (seeded vs. controls) along a topographic gradient in a degraded site undergoing restoration with non‐native shrub removal, selective tree thinning and prescribed fire. Seed mixes contained native forbs, grasses and sedges from locally sourced material (n = 169 total species) in the regional species pool, and were designed to match species' habitat affinity to appropriate locations along the topographic gradient. The herb flora was sampled pre‐seeding, and for two consecutive years after additions. Seed additions significantly altered community and functional composition, and increased native species richness by 29% (43.0 vs 55.4), and floristic quality by 30% relative to controls. However, fewer than half of the sown species were established 2 years after planting, suggesting that dispersal and establishment limitation are both important barriers to the recovery of the herb flora in oak woodlands. We also tested if species' sown abundance, conservatism or functional group predicted establishment success. Species sown at high abundances and less conservative species recruited the most reliably. Grass and forb establishment rates were more dependent on seeding rate than sedges or legumes, and the mechanisms behind this trend merit further investigation. We found that adding high‐diversity seed mixes in conjunction with non‐native shrub removal, canopy thinning and burning, can accelerate recovery of herbaceous communities in a highly degraded woodland. |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-09T21:16:43Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-dd8bde2c70f0430e87de8813f556b500 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2688-8319 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-09T21:16:43Z |
| publishDate | 2023-01-01 |
| publisher | Wiley |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Ecological Solutions and Evidence |
| spelling | doaj.art-dd8bde2c70f0430e87de8813f556b5002023-03-28T08:12:29ZengWileyEcological Solutions and Evidence2688-83192023-01-0141n/an/a10.1002/2688-8319.12202High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodlandAndrew D. Kaul0Noah D. Dell1Bradley M. Delfeld2Megan J. Engelhardt3Quinn G. Long4J. Leighton Reid5Michael L. Saxton6James C. Trager7Matthew A. Albrecht8Center for Conservation and Sustainable Development Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USACenter for Conservation and Sustainable Development Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USACenter for Conservation and Sustainable Development Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USAShaw Nature Reserve Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USAShaw Nature Reserve Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USASchool of Plant and Environmental Sciences Virginia Tech Blacksburg Virginia USAShaw Nature Reserve Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USAShaw Nature Reserve Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USACenter for Conservation and Sustainable Development Missouri Botanical Garden St. Louis Missouri USAAbstract Seed limitation represents a fundamental constraint to the restoration of native plant communities, and practitioners often apply seed additions to overcome this barrier. However, surprisingly few studies have experimentally tested whether seed additions can increase diversity in herbaceous communities of oak woodlands, which have undergone large‐scale transformation due to logging, altered fire regimes and invasion by non‐native species. Previous studies suggest that structural (thinning of woody biomass) and process‐based (prescribed fire) restoration treatments alone are unlikely to restore the full breadth of taxonomic and functional diversity in the herb layer, which accounts for most species in woodland ecosystems. To explore whether seed additions can improve restoration outcomes in an oak woodland, we sowed high‐diversity seed mixes in paired transects (seeded vs. controls) along a topographic gradient in a degraded site undergoing restoration with non‐native shrub removal, selective tree thinning and prescribed fire. Seed mixes contained native forbs, grasses and sedges from locally sourced material (n = 169 total species) in the regional species pool, and were designed to match species' habitat affinity to appropriate locations along the topographic gradient. The herb flora was sampled pre‐seeding, and for two consecutive years after additions. Seed additions significantly altered community and functional composition, and increased native species richness by 29% (43.0 vs 55.4), and floristic quality by 30% relative to controls. However, fewer than half of the sown species were established 2 years after planting, suggesting that dispersal and establishment limitation are both important barriers to the recovery of the herb flora in oak woodlands. We also tested if species' sown abundance, conservatism or functional group predicted establishment success. Species sown at high abundances and less conservative species recruited the most reliably. Grass and forb establishment rates were more dependent on seeding rate than sedges or legumes, and the mechanisms behind this trend merit further investigation. We found that adding high‐diversity seed mixes in conjunction with non‐native shrub removal, canopy thinning and burning, can accelerate recovery of herbaceous communities in a highly degraded woodland.https://doi.org/10.1002/2688-8319.12202ground vegetationinter‐seedingoakopen forestrestorationseed limitation |
| spellingShingle | Andrew D. Kaul Noah D. Dell Bradley M. Delfeld Megan J. Engelhardt Quinn G. Long J. Leighton Reid Michael L. Saxton James C. Trager Matthew A. Albrecht High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland Ecological Solutions and Evidence ground vegetation inter‐seeding oak open forest restoration seed limitation |
| title | High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland |
| title_full | High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland |
| title_fullStr | High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland |
| title_full_unstemmed | High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland |
| title_short | High‐diversity seed additions promote herb‐layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland |
| title_sort | high diversity seed additions promote herb layer recovery during restoration of degraded oak woodland |
| topic | ground vegetation inter‐seeding oak open forest restoration seed limitation |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1002/2688-8319.12202 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT andrewdkaul highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT noahddell highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT bradleymdelfeld highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT meganjengelhardt highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT quinnglong highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT jleightonreid highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT michaellsaxton highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT jamesctrager highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland AT matthewaalbrecht highdiversityseedadditionspromoteherblayerrecoveryduringrestorationofdegradedoakwoodland |