National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models?
Resume. The actual, feasible and simultaneously "correct" models of digital NSDI of Ukraine are considered in the work. A model of the existed digital NSDI system of Ukraine is named “actual”. This model already differs from the model defined by the [1]. As the latter is unlikely to be imp...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
National University of Life and Environmental Sciences of Ukraine
2021-08-01
|
| Series: | Zemleustrìj, Kadastr ì Monìtorìng Zemelʹ |
| Online Access: | http://journals.nubip.edu.ua/index.php/Zemleustriy/article/view/15162 |
| _version_ | 1797972479365349376 |
|---|---|
| author | V. Chabaniuk O. Dyshlyk |
| author_facet | V. Chabaniuk O. Dyshlyk |
| author_sort | V. Chabaniuk |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Resume. The actual, feasible and simultaneously "correct" models of digital NSDI of Ukraine are considered in the work. A model of the existed digital NSDI system of Ukraine is named “actual”. This model already differs from the model defined by the [1]. As the latter is unlikely to be implemented in the near future, the issue of the digital feasible NSDI model of Ukraine in the next five years, which would take into account the actual model, is especially acute. In addition to feasibility, such a model must also be "correct", what is proposed in the article. The correct is called a model, the truth of which can be established by inductive or deductive reasoning. To do this, the correct model must be formalized enough so that everyone can verify the authors’ reasoning independently.
Understanding both actual and correct models of NSDI of Ukraine will help to properly organize and develop actual Spatial Infrastructure Activities (SpIA) in Ukraine, including the real[1] implementation of the [1]. Although the results of the article call into question its feasibility and substantiate an alternative viewpoint on the automation problem of NGDI/NSDI/SpIA. However, we are convinced that it is still possible to change the alternative viewpoint to a cooperative one, if by means of by-laws the models of NGDI (Law), NSDI (article) and, finally, SpIA are agreed upon
To prove the "correctness" of the feasible NSDI model, the theory of Relational cartography and its two main methods are used: Conceptual Frameworks and Solution Frameworks. In addition, the correspondence between Relational cartography and Model-Based Engineering is used.
Key words: NSDI; product model; process model; actual, feasible and «correct» model.
[1] Real. 1. Which exists in reality, true. Is used with: reality, life, existence, conditions, circumstances, fact, danger, force, wages, income. 2. One that can be implemented, executed: a real plan, a real program, a real task, a real deadline. 3. Which is based on taking into account and assessing the real conditions of reality: a real approach, a real view, a real policy.- accessed 2021-feb-14, http://slovopedia.org.ua/32/53408/32016.html (Ukrainian). |
| first_indexed | 2024-04-11T03:49:07Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-ddd844d61f31491a9d92b4aaa2b84bb1 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2306-1677 2518-7325 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-04-11T03:49:07Z |
| publishDate | 2021-08-01 |
| publisher | National University of Life and Environmental Sciences of Ukraine |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Zemleustrìj, Kadastr ì Monìtorìng Zemelʹ |
| spelling | doaj.art-ddd844d61f31491a9d92b4aaa2b84bb12023-01-02T02:17:36ZengNational University of Life and Environmental Sciences of UkraineZemleustrìj, Kadastr ì Monìtorìng Zemelʹ2306-16772518-73252021-08-010310.31548/zemleustriy2021.03.1113466National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models?V. Chabaniuk0O. Dyshlyk1Інститут географії Національної академії наук УкраїниТОВ «Геоматичні рішення»Resume. The actual, feasible and simultaneously "correct" models of digital NSDI of Ukraine are considered in the work. A model of the existed digital NSDI system of Ukraine is named “actual”. This model already differs from the model defined by the [1]. As the latter is unlikely to be implemented in the near future, the issue of the digital feasible NSDI model of Ukraine in the next five years, which would take into account the actual model, is especially acute. In addition to feasibility, such a model must also be "correct", what is proposed in the article. The correct is called a model, the truth of which can be established by inductive or deductive reasoning. To do this, the correct model must be formalized enough so that everyone can verify the authors’ reasoning independently. Understanding both actual and correct models of NSDI of Ukraine will help to properly organize and develop actual Spatial Infrastructure Activities (SpIA) in Ukraine, including the real[1] implementation of the [1]. Although the results of the article call into question its feasibility and substantiate an alternative viewpoint on the automation problem of NGDI/NSDI/SpIA. However, we are convinced that it is still possible to change the alternative viewpoint to a cooperative one, if by means of by-laws the models of NGDI (Law), NSDI (article) and, finally, SpIA are agreed upon To prove the "correctness" of the feasible NSDI model, the theory of Relational cartography and its two main methods are used: Conceptual Frameworks and Solution Frameworks. In addition, the correspondence between Relational cartography and Model-Based Engineering is used. Key words: NSDI; product model; process model; actual, feasible and «correct» model. [1] Real. 1. Which exists in reality, true. Is used with: reality, life, existence, conditions, circumstances, fact, danger, force, wages, income. 2. One that can be implemented, executed: a real plan, a real program, a real task, a real deadline. 3. Which is based on taking into account and assessing the real conditions of reality: a real approach, a real view, a real policy.- accessed 2021-feb-14, http://slovopedia.org.ua/32/53408/32016.html (Ukrainian).http://journals.nubip.edu.ua/index.php/Zemleustriy/article/view/15162 |
| spellingShingle | V. Chabaniuk O. Dyshlyk National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models? Zemleustrìj, Kadastr ì Monìtorìng Zemelʹ |
| title | National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models? |
| title_full | National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models? |
| title_fullStr | National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models? |
| title_full_unstemmed | National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models? |
| title_short | National spatial data infrastructure (NSDI) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously “correct” models? |
| title_sort | national spatial data infrastructure nsdi of ukraine what are its actual feasible and simultaneously correct models |
| url | http://journals.nubip.edu.ua/index.php/Zemleustriy/article/view/15162 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT vchabaniuk nationalspatialdatainfrastructurensdiofukrainewhatareitsactualfeasibleandsimultaneouslycorrectmodels AT odyshlyk nationalspatialdatainfrastructurensdiofukrainewhatareitsactualfeasibleandsimultaneouslycorrectmodels |