How do pilot and feasibility studies inform randomised placebo-controlled trials in surgery? A systematic review

How do pilot and feasibility studies inform randomised placebo-controlled trials in surgery? A systematic review

Introduction Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) with a placebo comparator are considered the gold standard study design when evaluating healthcare interventions. These are challenging to design and deliver in surgery. Guidance recommends pilot and feasibility work to optimise main trial design and...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors:	Jane M Blazeby, David J Beard, Natalie S Blencowe, Sian Cousins, Katy Chalmers, Marion K Campbell, Alexander Gormley
Format:	Article
Language:	English
Published:	BMJ Publishing Group 2023-11-01
Series:	BMJ Open
Online Access:	https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/13/11/e071094.full

Similar Items

Key methodological issues for the design and delivery of placebo controlled randomised trials of invasive procedures, including surgery: A systematic review
by: Cousins, S, et al.
Published: (2019)

Optimising the design and delivery of placebo surgical interventions in randomised controlled trials: The DITTO framework
by: Cousins, S, et al.
Published: (2019)

Further considerations for placebo controls in surgical trials
by: Marion K. Campbell, et al.
Published: (2023-06-01)

Reporting of key methodological issues in placebo-controlled trials of surgery needs improvement: a systematic review
by: Cousins, S, et al.
Published: (2019)

Optimizing the design of invasive placebo interventions in randomized controlled trials
by: Cousins, S, et al.
Published: (2020)

Further considerations for placebo controls in surgical trials
by: Campbell, MK, et al.
Published: (2023)

Recommendations for optimising pilot and feasibility work in surgery
by: K. Fairhurst, et al.
Published: (2024-04-01)

Understanding stage of innovation of invasive procedures and devices: protocol for a systematic review and thematic analysis
by: Jane M Blazeby, et al.
Published: (2022-02-01)

Feasibility of surgical randomised controlled trials with a placebo arm: a systematic review
by: Wartolowska, K, et al.
Published: (2016)

Interventions in randomised controlled trials in surgery: issues to consider during trial design
by: Blencowe, N, et al.
Published: (2015)

CONSORT 2010 Statement: extension to randomised pilot and feasibility trials
by: Eldridge, S, et al.
Published: (2016)

CONSORT 2010 statement: extension to randomised pilot and feasibility trials
by: Eldridge, S, et al.
Published: (2016)

The feasibility of performing a randomised controlled trial for femoroacetabular impingement surgery.
by: Palmer, A, et al.
Published: (2013)

SUcceSS, SUrgery for Spinal Stenosis: protocol of a randomised, placebo-controlled trial
by: Anderson, D, et al.
Published: (2019)

Impact of question order on prioritisation of outcomes in the development of a core outcome set: a randomised controlled trial
by: Sara T. Brookes, et al.
Published: (2018-01-01)

Developing a placebo-controlled trial in surgery: Issues of design, acceptability and feasibility
by: McDonald AM, et al.
Published: (2011-02-01)

The Effect of Dietary Supplementation on Aggressive Behaviour in Australian Adult Male Prisoners: A Feasibility and Pilot Study for a Randomised, Double Blind Placebo Controlled Trial
by: Colin H. Cortie, et al.
Published: (2020-08-01)

Randomised placebo-controlled trials of surgery – ethical analysis and guidelines
by: Savulescu, J, et al.
Published: (2016)

Comparing open and minimally invasive surgical procedures for oesophagectomy in the treatment of cancer: the ROMIO (Randomised Oesophagectomy: Minimally Invasive or Open) feasibility study and pilot trial
by: Chris Metcalfe, et al.
Published: (2016-06-01)

Guidelines for reporting non-randomised pilot and feasibility studies
by: Gillian A. Lancaster, et al.
Published: (2019-10-01)

Qualitative documentary analysis of guidance on information provision and consent for the introduction of innovative invasive procedures including surgeries within NHS organisations’ policies in England and Wales
by: Jane M Blazeby, et al.
Published: (2022-09-01)

A non-randomised feasibility study of a mHealth follow-up program in bariatric surgery
by: Charlene Wright, et al.
Published: (2023-10-01)

Placebo comparator group selection and use in surgical trials: the ASPIRE project including expert workshop
by: David J Beard, et al.
Published: (2021-09-01)

Hand Osteoarthritis: investigating Pain Effects of estrogen-containing therapy (HOPE-e): a protocol for a feasibility randomised placebo-controlled trial
by: Ioana R. Marian, et al.
Published: (2021-06-01)

Injection versus Decompression for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome-Pilot trial (INDICATE-P)-protocol for a randomised feasibility study.
by: Mason, W, et al.
Published: (2017)

Injection versus Decompression for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome-Pilot trial (INDICATE-P)—protocol for a randomised feasibility study
by: Will Mason, et al.
Published: (2017-04-01)

Accounting for the placebo effect of surgery in surgical trials?
by: Beard, D, et al.
Published: (2013)

A mixed methods case study investigating how randomised controlled trials (RCTs) are reported, understood and interpreted in practice
by: Ben E. Byrne, et al.
Published: (2020-05-01)

Benefits and harms of placebo in surgical randomised clinical trials: a systematic review
by: Wartolowska, K, et al.
Published: (2013)

A pilot randomised controlled trial of physical activity facilitation for older adults: feasibility study findings
by: Gemma S. Morgan, et al.
Published: (2019-03-01)

Considerations and methods for placebo controls in surgical trials (ASPIRE guidelines)
by: Beard, DJ, et al.
Published: (2020)

Defining Feasibility and Pilot Studies in Preparation for Randomised Controlled Trials: Development of a Conceptual Framework.
by: Sandra M Eldridge, et al.
Published: (2016-01-01)

High-definition transcranial infraslow pink noise stimulation for chronic low back pain: protocol for a pilot, safety and feasibility randomised placebo-controlled trial
by: Ramakrishnan Mani, et al.
Published: (2022-06-01)

The By-Band study: gastric bypass or adjustable gastric band surgery to treat morbid obesity: study protocol for a multi-centre randomised controlled trial with an internal pilot phase.
by: Rogers, C, et al.
Published: (2014)

Benefits and harms of placebo in surgical randomised clinical trials: a systematic review
by: Wartolowska, K, et al.
Published: (2014)

Challenges of conducting a randomised placebo-controlled trial of spinal surgery: the SUcceSS trial of lumbar spine decompression
by: Emma Kwan-Yee Ho, et al.
Published: (2023-12-01)

OptiBreech collaborative care versus standard care for women with a breech-presenting fetus at term: A pilot parallel group randomised trial to evaluate the feasibility of a randomised trial nested within a cohort
by: Shawn Walker, et al.
Published: (2023-01-01)

Risperidone versus placebo for aggression following traumatic brain injury: a feasibility randomised controlled trial
by: Shoumitro Deb, et al.
Published: (2020-09-01)

Delivering successful randomized controlled trials in surgery: Methods to optimize collaboration and study design
by: Blencowe, N, et al.
Published: (2017)

The PROB-PD trial: a pilot, randomised, placebo-controlled study protocol to evaluate the feasibility and potential efficacy of probiotics in modulating peripheral immunity in subjects with Parkinson’s disease
by: Stefano Martini, et al.
Published: (2023-05-01)