“A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial
This paper is the outcome of a research inside Rio de Janeiro’s State Court. The methodology consists in a dialogue I intended to do between law, which I studied under graduation, and anthropology, that I was introduced to, when I was under my post graduati...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Centro Universitário de Valença
2020-07-01
|
| Series: | Revista Interdisciplinar de Direito |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://revistas.faa.edu.br/index.php/FDV/article/view/842/606 |
| _version_ | 1828489908180746240 |
|---|---|
| author | Bárbara Gomes Lupetti Baptista |
| author_facet | Bárbara Gomes Lupetti Baptista |
| author_sort | Bárbara Gomes Lupetti Baptista |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | This paper is the outcome of a research inside Rio de Janeiro’s State Court. The methodology consists in a dialogue I intended to do between law, which I studied under graduation, and anthropology, that I was introduced to, when I was under my post graduation studies. The research allows understanding that the principle of judicial 76impartiality consists in a belief, discursively constructed inside the judicial field, and it works as a structuring category inside the judiciary. However, the discursive belief strikes against the empirical reality, as the fieldwork data shows. Judge’s subjective aspects directly interfere during the decision making. It suggests that judge’s morality and sense of justice interfere during the process and often in its result. Between the paradox of “seeming impartial” and the fact of “being humans” the judges describe their dilemmas and the challenges they experience when they try “not to contaminate” their essential impartiality. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-11T10:34:15Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-f010badbe62d4fa2a736ecc6fc3310e2 |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 1518-8167 2447-4290 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-11T10:34:15Z |
| publishDate | 2020-07-01 |
| publisher | Centro Universitário de Valença |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Revista Interdisciplinar de Direito |
| spelling | doaj.art-f010badbe62d4fa2a736ecc6fc3310e22022-12-22T01:10:46ZengCentro Universitário de ValençaRevista Interdisciplinar de Direito1518-81672447-42902020-07-01181759510.24859/fdv.2020.1.004“A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicialBárbara Gomes Lupetti BaptistaThis paper is the outcome of a research inside Rio de Janeiro’s State Court. The methodology consists in a dialogue I intended to do between law, which I studied under graduation, and anthropology, that I was introduced to, when I was under my post graduation studies. The research allows understanding that the principle of judicial 76impartiality consists in a belief, discursively constructed inside the judicial field, and it works as a structuring category inside the judiciary. However, the discursive belief strikes against the empirical reality, as the fieldwork data shows. Judge’s subjective aspects directly interfere during the decision making. It suggests that judge’s morality and sense of justice interfere during the process and often in its result. Between the paradox of “seeming impartial” and the fact of “being humans” the judges describe their dilemmas and the challenges they experience when they try “not to contaminate” their essential impartiality.http://revistas.faa.edu.br/index.php/FDV/article/view/842/606lawanthropologyprinciple of judicial impartialitytruthjustice |
| spellingShingle | Bárbara Gomes Lupetti Baptista “A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial Revista Interdisciplinar de Direito law anthropology principle of judicial impartiality truth justice |
| title | “A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial |
| title_full | “A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial |
| title_fullStr | “A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial |
| title_full_unstemmed | “A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial |
| title_short | “A Minha Verdade é a Minha Justiça”: atualizando os significados atribuídos ao princípio da imparcialidade judicial |
| title_sort | a minha verdade e a minha justica atualizando os significados atribuidos ao principio da imparcialidade judicial |
| topic | law anthropology principle of judicial impartiality truth justice |
| url | http://revistas.faa.edu.br/index.php/FDV/article/view/842/606 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT barbaragomeslupettibaptista aminhaverdadeeaminhajusticaatualizandoossignificadosatribuidosaoprincipiodaimparcialidadejudicial |