Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review

BackgroundHealth-enabling technologies (HETs) are information and communication technologies that promote individual health and well-being. An important application of HETs is telerehabilitation for patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders. Currently, there is no overview of HETs that assist...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Elgert, Lena, Steiner, Bianca, Saalfeld, Birgit, Marschollek, Michael, Wolf, Klaus-Hendrik
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: JMIR Publications 2021-02-01
Series:JMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies
Online Access:http://rehab.jmir.org/2021/1/e21107/
_version_ 1818915944711323648
author Elgert, Lena
Steiner, Bianca
Saalfeld, Birgit
Marschollek, Michael
Wolf, Klaus-Hendrik
author_facet Elgert, Lena
Steiner, Bianca
Saalfeld, Birgit
Marschollek, Michael
Wolf, Klaus-Hendrik
author_sort Elgert, Lena
collection DOAJ
description BackgroundHealth-enabling technologies (HETs) are information and communication technologies that promote individual health and well-being. An important application of HETs is telerehabilitation for patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders. Currently, there is no overview of HETs that assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home. ObjectiveThis scoping review provides a broad overview of HETs that assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home. It focuses on concepts and components of HETs, exercise program strategies, development phases, and reported outcomes. MethodsThe search strategy used Medical Subject Headings and text words related to the terms upper extremity, exercises, and information and communication technologies. The MEDLINE, Embase, IEEE Xplore, CINAHL, PEDro, and Scopus databases were searched. Two reviewers independently screened titles and abstracts and then full texts against predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria. A systematic narrative synthesis was performed. Overall, 8988 records published between 1997 and 2019 were screened. Finally, 70 articles introducing 56 HETs were included. ResultsIdentified HETs range from simple videoconferencing systems to mobile apps with video instructions to complex sensor-based technologies. Various software, sensor hardware, and hardware for output are in use. The most common hardware for output are PC displays (in 34 HETs). Microsoft Kinect cameras in connection with related software are frequently used as sensor hardware (in 27 HETs). The identified HETs provide direct or indirect instruction, monitoring, correction, assessment, information, or a reminder to exercise. Common parameters for exercise instructions are a patient’s range of motion (in 43 HETs), starting and final position (in 32 HETs), and exercise intensity (in 20 HETs). In total, 48 HETs provide visual instructions for the exercises; 29 HETs report on telerehabilitation aspects; 34 HETs only report on prototypes; and 15 HETs are evaluated for technical feasibility, acceptance, or usability, using different assessment instruments. Efficacy or effectiveness is demonstrated for only 8 HETs. In total, 18 articles report on patients’ evaluations. An interdisciplinary contribution to the development of technologies is found in 17 HETs. ConclusionsThere are various HETs, ranging from simple videoconferencing systems to complex sensor-based technologies for telerehabilitation, that assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home. Most HETs are not ready for practical use. Comparability is complicated by varying prototype status, different measurement instruments, missing telerehabilitation aspects, and few efficacy studies. Consequently, choosing an HET for daily use is difficult for health care professionals and decision makers. Prototype testing, usability, and acceptance tests with the later target group under real-life conditions as well as efficacy or effectiveness studies with patient-relevant core outcomes for every promising HET are required. Furthermore, health care professionals and patients should be more involved in the product design cycle to consider relevant practical aspects.
first_indexed 2024-12-20T00:10:20Z
format Article
id doaj.art-f3dc93356d314cb6be86b36f33b63537
institution Directory Open Access Journal
issn 2369-2529
language English
last_indexed 2024-12-20T00:10:20Z
publishDate 2021-02-01
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format Article
series JMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies
spelling doaj.art-f3dc93356d314cb6be86b36f33b635372022-12-21T20:00:32ZengJMIR PublicationsJMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies2369-25292021-02-0181e2110710.2196/21107Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping ReviewElgert, LenaSteiner, BiancaSaalfeld, BirgitMarschollek, MichaelWolf, Klaus-HendrikBackgroundHealth-enabling technologies (HETs) are information and communication technologies that promote individual health and well-being. An important application of HETs is telerehabilitation for patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders. Currently, there is no overview of HETs that assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home. ObjectiveThis scoping review provides a broad overview of HETs that assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home. It focuses on concepts and components of HETs, exercise program strategies, development phases, and reported outcomes. MethodsThe search strategy used Medical Subject Headings and text words related to the terms upper extremity, exercises, and information and communication technologies. The MEDLINE, Embase, IEEE Xplore, CINAHL, PEDro, and Scopus databases were searched. Two reviewers independently screened titles and abstracts and then full texts against predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria. A systematic narrative synthesis was performed. Overall, 8988 records published between 1997 and 2019 were screened. Finally, 70 articles introducing 56 HETs were included. ResultsIdentified HETs range from simple videoconferencing systems to mobile apps with video instructions to complex sensor-based technologies. Various software, sensor hardware, and hardware for output are in use. The most common hardware for output are PC displays (in 34 HETs). Microsoft Kinect cameras in connection with related software are frequently used as sensor hardware (in 27 HETs). The identified HETs provide direct or indirect instruction, monitoring, correction, assessment, information, or a reminder to exercise. Common parameters for exercise instructions are a patient’s range of motion (in 43 HETs), starting and final position (in 32 HETs), and exercise intensity (in 20 HETs). In total, 48 HETs provide visual instructions for the exercises; 29 HETs report on telerehabilitation aspects; 34 HETs only report on prototypes; and 15 HETs are evaluated for technical feasibility, acceptance, or usability, using different assessment instruments. Efficacy or effectiveness is demonstrated for only 8 HETs. In total, 18 articles report on patients’ evaluations. An interdisciplinary contribution to the development of technologies is found in 17 HETs. ConclusionsThere are various HETs, ranging from simple videoconferencing systems to complex sensor-based technologies for telerehabilitation, that assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home. Most HETs are not ready for practical use. Comparability is complicated by varying prototype status, different measurement instruments, missing telerehabilitation aspects, and few efficacy studies. Consequently, choosing an HET for daily use is difficult for health care professionals and decision makers. Prototype testing, usability, and acceptance tests with the later target group under real-life conditions as well as efficacy or effectiveness studies with patient-relevant core outcomes for every promising HET are required. Furthermore, health care professionals and patients should be more involved in the product design cycle to consider relevant practical aspects.http://rehab.jmir.org/2021/1/e21107/
spellingShingle Elgert, Lena
Steiner, Bianca
Saalfeld, Birgit
Marschollek, Michael
Wolf, Klaus-Hendrik
Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review
JMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies
title Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review
title_full Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review
title_fullStr Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review
title_full_unstemmed Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review
title_short Health-Enabling Technologies to Assist Patients With Musculoskeletal Shoulder Disorders When Exercising at Home: Scoping Review
title_sort health enabling technologies to assist patients with musculoskeletal shoulder disorders when exercising at home scoping review
url http://rehab.jmir.org/2021/1/e21107/
work_keys_str_mv AT elgertlena healthenablingtechnologiestoassistpatientswithmusculoskeletalshoulderdisorderswhenexercisingathomescopingreview
AT steinerbianca healthenablingtechnologiestoassistpatientswithmusculoskeletalshoulderdisorderswhenexercisingathomescopingreview
AT saalfeldbirgit healthenablingtechnologiestoassistpatientswithmusculoskeletalshoulderdisorderswhenexercisingathomescopingreview
AT marschollekmichael healthenablingtechnologiestoassistpatientswithmusculoskeletalshoulderdisorderswhenexercisingathomescopingreview
AT wolfklaushendrik healthenablingtechnologiestoassistpatientswithmusculoskeletalshoulderdisorderswhenexercisingathomescopingreview