Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?

We would like to ask ourselves whether the serial form leads us to rethink the terms of the debate between surrealism and mimesis. Is the question of reality the same in cinema and in a TV series? The series Rome (HBO, 2005–7) contributes to a genre with realist pretensions: the Peplum or epic in th...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Vivien Bessières
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Groupe de Recherche Identités et Cultures 2012-05-01
Series:TV Series
Subjects:
Online Access:http://journals.openedition.org/tvseries/1066
_version_ 1818691217855086592
author Vivien Bessières
author_facet Vivien Bessières
author_sort Vivien Bessières
collection DOAJ
description We would like to ask ourselves whether the serial form leads us to rethink the terms of the debate between surrealism and mimesis. Is the question of reality the same in cinema and in a TV series? The series Rome (HBO, 2005–7) contributes to a genre with realist pretensions: the Peplum or epic in the United States. From one art to the other, does the genre modify its relationship with the real? It appears that, from the film to the series, realism and space-time are constantly confronted with generic requirements. Each realist genre constitutes its own plausibility. In this perspective, a series is not more “true” than a film, and historical reality is always more or less deformed in service of the fiction. Only the choice operated in the historical material is changed — from an art of events to an art of the everyday. The topos of the gladiatorial combat, for example, receives an entirely different treatment on the big screen and the small screen. In Gladiator, it is an exceptional event, which takes place in the Coliseum, and is attended by the emperor and his court. In Rome, it is a common way of dispensing justice. The combat takes place in a temporary wooden structure, and only the commoners are present. Films and series make their choice within the historical material according two different logics: grand evenemential history for the first; the daily lives of common people for the second. Finally, this new cutting of the real concurs with the recent evolution of the historical discipline.
first_indexed 2024-12-17T12:38:23Z
format Article
id doaj.art-f4c9ddc9c503453ebde25dc21321ccbf
institution Directory Open Access Journal
issn 2266-0909
language English
last_indexed 2024-12-17T12:38:23Z
publishDate 2012-05-01
publisher Groupe de Recherche Identités et Cultures
record_format Article
series TV Series
spelling doaj.art-f4c9ddc9c503453ebde25dc21321ccbf2022-12-21T21:48:10ZengGroupe de Recherche Identités et CulturesTV Series2266-09092012-05-01110.4000/tvseries.1066Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?Vivien BessièresWe would like to ask ourselves whether the serial form leads us to rethink the terms of the debate between surrealism and mimesis. Is the question of reality the same in cinema and in a TV series? The series Rome (HBO, 2005–7) contributes to a genre with realist pretensions: the Peplum or epic in the United States. From one art to the other, does the genre modify its relationship with the real? It appears that, from the film to the series, realism and space-time are constantly confronted with generic requirements. Each realist genre constitutes its own plausibility. In this perspective, a series is not more “true” than a film, and historical reality is always more or less deformed in service of the fiction. Only the choice operated in the historical material is changed — from an art of events to an art of the everyday. The topos of the gladiatorial combat, for example, receives an entirely different treatment on the big screen and the small screen. In Gladiator, it is an exceptional event, which takes place in the Coliseum, and is attended by the emperor and his court. In Rome, it is a common way of dispensing justice. The combat takes place in a temporary wooden structure, and only the commoners are present. Films and series make their choice within the historical material according two different logics: grand evenemential history for the first; the daily lives of common people for the second. Finally, this new cutting of the real concurs with the recent evolution of the historical discipline.http://journals.openedition.org/tvseries/1066RomeGladiatorrealismepic
spellingShingle Vivien Bessières
Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?
TV Series
Rome
Gladiator
realism
epic
title Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?
title_full Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?
title_fullStr Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?
title_full_unstemmed Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?
title_short Rome : un péplum enfin réaliste ?
title_sort rome un peplum enfin realiste
topic Rome
Gladiator
realism
epic
url http://journals.openedition.org/tvseries/1066
work_keys_str_mv AT vivienbessieres romeunpeplumenfinrealiste