Improved quality and quantity of written feedback is associated with a structured feedback proforma

Facilitating the provision of detailed, deep and useful feedback is an important design feature of any educational programme. Here we evaluate feedback provided to medical students completing short transferable skills projects. Feedback quantity and depth were evaluated before and after a simple int...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Philip M. Newton, Melisa J. Wallace, Judy McKimm
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Korea Health Personnel Licensing Examination Institute 2012-08-01
Series:Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions
Subjects:
Online Access:http://jeehp.org/upload/jeehp-9-10.pdf
Description
Summary:Facilitating the provision of detailed, deep and useful feedback is an important design feature of any educational programme. Here we evaluate feedback provided to medical students completing short transferable skills projects. Feedback quantity and depth were evaluated before and after a simple intervention to change the structure of the feedback-provision form from a blank free-text feedback form to a structured proforma that asked a pair of short questions for each of the six domains being assessed. Each pair of questions consisted of asking the marker ?占퐓hat was done well???and ?占퐓hat changes would improve the assignment???Changing the form was associated with a significant increase in the quantity of the feedback and in the amount and quality of feedback provided to students. We also observed that, for these double-marked projects, the marker designated as ?占퐉arker 1??consistently wrote more feedback than the marker designated ?占퐉arker 2??
ISSN:1975-5937