Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms
We have previously described the importance of using multiple indicators for reporting national farm-level antimicrobial use (AMU) information, but the distribution of flock-level AMU and how these indicators relate to each other has not yet been fully explored. Using farm-level surveillance data (2...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2020-10-01
|
| Series: | Frontiers in Veterinary Science |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fvets.2020.567872/full |
| _version_ | 1819046236534079488 |
|---|---|
| author | Agnes Agunos Sheryl P. Gow David F. Léger Anne E. Deckert Carolee A. Carson Angelina L. Bosman Stefanie Kadykalo Richard J. Reid-Smith |
| author_facet | Agnes Agunos Sheryl P. Gow David F. Léger Anne E. Deckert Carolee A. Carson Angelina L. Bosman Stefanie Kadykalo Richard J. Reid-Smith |
| author_sort | Agnes Agunos |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | We have previously described the importance of using multiple indicators for reporting national farm-level antimicrobial use (AMU) information, but the distribution of flock-level AMU and how these indicators relate to each other has not yet been fully explored. Using farm-level surveillance data (2013–2019), for broiler chickens (n = 947 flocks) and turkeys (n = 427), this study aims to (1) characterize flock-level AMU and identify high users, (2) identify appropriate AMU indicators and biomass denominator [population correction unit (PCU) vs. kg weight at pre-slaughter], and (3) make recommendations on the application to veterinarian-producer and national-level reporting. Diverse AMU patterns were identified in broiler chickens (156 patterns) and turkeys (68 patterns); of these, bacitracin, reported by 25% of broiler chicken and 19% of turkey producers, was the most frequently occurring pattern. Depending on the indicator chosen, variations in reported quantity of use, temporal trends and relative ranking of the antimicrobials changed. Quantitative AMU analysis yielded the following results for broiler chickens: mean 134 mg/PCU; 507 number (n) of Canadian (CA) defined daily doses (DDDvet) per 1,000 chicken-days and 18 nDDDvetCA/PCU. Analysis in turkey flocks yielded the following: mean 64 mg/PCU, 99 nDDDvetCA/1,000 turkey-days at risk and 9 nDDDvetCA/PCU. Flocks were categorized based on the percentiles of the mg/PCU distribution: “medium” to “low” users (≤75th percentile) and “high” users (>75th percentile). The odds of being a high user in both broiler chickens and turkeys were significantly increased: if water medications were used, and if trimethoprim-sulfonamides, bacitracins, and tetracyclines were used. Pairwise correlation analysis showed moderate correlation between mg/PCU and the nDDDvetCA/1,000 animal days at risk and between mg/PCU and nDDDvetCA/PCU. Significantly high correlation between nDDDvetCA/1,000 animal days at risk and nDDDvetCA/PCU was observed, suggestive that either of these could be used for routine monitoring of trends in AMU. One source of discrepancy between the indicators was the antimicrobial. Understanding the choice of parameter input and effects on reporting trends in AMU will inform surveillance reporting best practices to help industry understand the impacts of their AMU reduction strategies and to best communicate the information to veterinarians, their producers, and other stakeholders. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-21T10:41:16Z |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj.art-fc6a8273aba34b88b2491a72489fb6ca |
| institution | Directory Open Access Journal |
| issn | 2297-1769 |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-21T10:41:16Z |
| publishDate | 2020-10-01 |
| publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Frontiers in Veterinary Science |
| spelling | doaj.art-fc6a8273aba34b88b2491a72489fb6ca2022-12-21T19:06:55ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Veterinary Science2297-17692020-10-01710.3389/fvets.2020.567872567872Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey FarmsAgnes AgunosSheryl P. GowDavid F. LégerAnne E. DeckertCarolee A. CarsonAngelina L. BosmanStefanie KadykaloRichard J. Reid-SmithWe have previously described the importance of using multiple indicators for reporting national farm-level antimicrobial use (AMU) information, but the distribution of flock-level AMU and how these indicators relate to each other has not yet been fully explored. Using farm-level surveillance data (2013–2019), for broiler chickens (n = 947 flocks) and turkeys (n = 427), this study aims to (1) characterize flock-level AMU and identify high users, (2) identify appropriate AMU indicators and biomass denominator [population correction unit (PCU) vs. kg weight at pre-slaughter], and (3) make recommendations on the application to veterinarian-producer and national-level reporting. Diverse AMU patterns were identified in broiler chickens (156 patterns) and turkeys (68 patterns); of these, bacitracin, reported by 25% of broiler chicken and 19% of turkey producers, was the most frequently occurring pattern. Depending on the indicator chosen, variations in reported quantity of use, temporal trends and relative ranking of the antimicrobials changed. Quantitative AMU analysis yielded the following results for broiler chickens: mean 134 mg/PCU; 507 number (n) of Canadian (CA) defined daily doses (DDDvet) per 1,000 chicken-days and 18 nDDDvetCA/PCU. Analysis in turkey flocks yielded the following: mean 64 mg/PCU, 99 nDDDvetCA/1,000 turkey-days at risk and 9 nDDDvetCA/PCU. Flocks were categorized based on the percentiles of the mg/PCU distribution: “medium” to “low” users (≤75th percentile) and “high” users (>75th percentile). The odds of being a high user in both broiler chickens and turkeys were significantly increased: if water medications were used, and if trimethoprim-sulfonamides, bacitracins, and tetracyclines were used. Pairwise correlation analysis showed moderate correlation between mg/PCU and the nDDDvetCA/1,000 animal days at risk and between mg/PCU and nDDDvetCA/PCU. Significantly high correlation between nDDDvetCA/1,000 animal days at risk and nDDDvetCA/PCU was observed, suggestive that either of these could be used for routine monitoring of trends in AMU. One source of discrepancy between the indicators was the antimicrobial. Understanding the choice of parameter input and effects on reporting trends in AMU will inform surveillance reporting best practices to help industry understand the impacts of their AMU reduction strategies and to best communicate the information to veterinarians, their producers, and other stakeholders.https://www.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fvets.2020.567872/fullantimicrobial useindicatorsturkeysbroiler chickenssurveillanceCanada |
| spellingShingle | Agnes Agunos Sheryl P. Gow David F. Léger Anne E. Deckert Carolee A. Carson Angelina L. Bosman Stefanie Kadykalo Richard J. Reid-Smith Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms Frontiers in Veterinary Science antimicrobial use indicators turkeys broiler chickens surveillance Canada |
| title | Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms |
| title_full | Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms |
| title_fullStr | Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms |
| title_full_unstemmed | Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms |
| title_short | Antimicrobial Use Indices—The Value of Reporting Antimicrobial Use in Multiple Ways Using Data From Canadian Broiler Chicken and Turkey Farms |
| title_sort | antimicrobial use indices the value of reporting antimicrobial use in multiple ways using data from canadian broiler chicken and turkey farms |
| topic | antimicrobial use indicators turkeys broiler chickens surveillance Canada |
| url | https://www.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fvets.2020.567872/full |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT agnesagunos antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT sherylpgow antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT davidfleger antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT anneedeckert antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT caroleeacarson antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT angelinalbosman antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT stefaniekadykalo antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms AT richardjreidsmith antimicrobialuseindicesthevalueofreportingantimicrobialuseinmultiplewaysusingdatafromcanadianbroilerchickenandturkeyfarms |