First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO
Interferometric gravitational wave detectors operate with high optical power in their arms in order to achieve high shot-noise limited strain sensitivity. A significant limitation to increasing the optical power is the phenomenon of three-mode parametric instabilities, in which the laser field in th...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Other Authors: | |
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
American Physical Society
2017
|
| Online Access: | http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/108741 https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8459-4499 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1983-3187 |
| _version_ | 1811077680859185152 |
|---|---|
| author | Blair, Carl Abbott, Richard Aston, Stuart Betzwieser, Joseph Blair, David DeRosa, Ryan Frolov, Valera Grote, Hartmut Hardwick, Terra Liu, Jian Lormand, Marc Mullavey, Adam O’Reilly, Brian Zhao, Chunnong Abbott, B. P. Abbott, T. D. Adams, C. Adhikari, R. X. Anderson, S. B. Ananyeva, A. Appert, S. Arai, K. Ballmer, S. W. Barker, D. Barr, B. Barsotti, L. Bartlett, J. Bartos, I. Batch, J. C. Bell, A. S. Billingsley, G. Birch, J. Biscans, S. Biwer, C. Bork, R. Brooks, A. F. Ciani, G. Clara, F. Countryman, S. T. Cowart, M. J. Coyne, D. C. Cumming, A. Cunningham, L. Danzmann, K. Da Silva Costa, C. F. Daw, E. J. DeBra, D. DeSalvo, R. Dooley, K. L. Doravari, S. Driggers, J. C. Dwyer, S. E. Effler, A. Etzel, T. Evans, T. M. Factourovich, M. Fair, H. Fernández Galiana, A. Fisher, R. P. Fulda, P. Fyffe, M. Giaime, J. A. Giardina, K. D. Goetz, E. Goetz, R. Gray, C. Gushwa, K. E. Gustafson, E. K. Gustafson, R. Hall, E. D. Hammond, G. Hanks, J. Hanson, J. Harry, G. M. Heintze, M. C. Heptonstall, A. W. Hough, J. Izumi, K. Jones, R. Kandhasamy, S. Karki, S. Kasprzack, M. Kaufer, S. Kawabe, K. Kijbunchoo, N. King, E. J. King, P. J. Kissel, J. S. Korth, W. Z. Kuehn, G. Landry, M. Lantz, B. Lockerbie, N. A. Lundgren, A. P. MacInnis, M. Macleod, D. M. Márka, S. Márka, Z. Markosyan, A. S. Maros, E. Martin, I. W. Martynov, D. V. Mason, K. Massinger, T. J. Matichard, F. Mavalvala, N. McCarthy, R. McClelland, D. E. McCormick, S. McIntyre, G. McIver, J. Mendell, G. Merilh, E. L. Meyers, P. M. Mittleman, R. Moreno, G. Mueller, G. Munch, J. Nuttall, L. K. Oberling, J. Oppermann, P. Oram, Richard J. Ottaway, D. J. Overmier, H. Palamos, J. R. Paris, H. R. Parker, W. Pele, A. Penn, S. Phelps, M. Pierro, V. Pinto, I. Principe, M. Prokhorov, L. G. Puncken, O. Quetschke, V. Quintero, E. A. Raab, F. J. Radkins, H. Raffai, P. Reid, S. Reitze, D. H. Robertson, N. A. Rollins, J. G. Roma, V. J. Romie, J. H. Rowan, S. Ryan, K. Sadecki, T. Sanchez, E. J. Sandberg, V. Savage, R. L. Schofield, R. M. S. Sellers, D. Shaddock, D. A. Shaffer, T. J. Shapiro, B. Shawhan, P. Shoemaker, D. H. Sigg, D. Slagmolen, B. J. J. Smith, B. Smith, J. R. Sorazu, B. Staley, A. Strain, K. A. Tanner, D. B. Taylor, R. Thomas, M. Thomas, P. Thorne, K. A. Thrane, E. Torrie, C. I. Traylor, G. Vajente, G. Valdes, G. van Veggel, A. A. Vecchio, A. Veitch, P. J. Venkateswara, K. Vo, T. Vorvick, C. Walker, M. Ward, R. L. Warner, J. Weaver, B. Weiss, R. Weßels, P. Willke, B. Wipf, C. C. Worden, J. Wu, G. Yamamoto, H. Yancey, C. C. Yu, Hang Yu, Haocun Zhang, L. Zucker, M. E. Zweizig, J. Gras, Slawomir Evans, Matthew J Fritschel, Peter K Miller, John |
| author2 | LIGO (Observatory : Massachusetts Institute of Technology) |
| author_facet | LIGO (Observatory : Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Blair, Carl Abbott, Richard Aston, Stuart Betzwieser, Joseph Blair, David DeRosa, Ryan Frolov, Valera Grote, Hartmut Hardwick, Terra Liu, Jian Lormand, Marc Mullavey, Adam O’Reilly, Brian Zhao, Chunnong Abbott, B. P. Abbott, T. D. Adams, C. Adhikari, R. X. Anderson, S. B. Ananyeva, A. Appert, S. Arai, K. Ballmer, S. W. Barker, D. Barr, B. Barsotti, L. Bartlett, J. Bartos, I. Batch, J. C. Bell, A. S. Billingsley, G. Birch, J. Biscans, S. Biwer, C. Bork, R. Brooks, A. F. Ciani, G. Clara, F. Countryman, S. T. Cowart, M. J. Coyne, D. C. Cumming, A. Cunningham, L. Danzmann, K. Da Silva Costa, C. F. Daw, E. J. DeBra, D. DeSalvo, R. Dooley, K. L. Doravari, S. Driggers, J. C. Dwyer, S. E. Effler, A. Etzel, T. Evans, T. M. Factourovich, M. Fair, H. Fernández Galiana, A. Fisher, R. P. Fulda, P. Fyffe, M. Giaime, J. A. Giardina, K. D. Goetz, E. Goetz, R. Gray, C. Gushwa, K. E. Gustafson, E. K. Gustafson, R. Hall, E. D. Hammond, G. Hanks, J. Hanson, J. Harry, G. M. Heintze, M. C. Heptonstall, A. W. Hough, J. Izumi, K. Jones, R. Kandhasamy, S. Karki, S. Kasprzack, M. Kaufer, S. Kawabe, K. Kijbunchoo, N. King, E. J. King, P. J. Kissel, J. S. Korth, W. Z. Kuehn, G. Landry, M. Lantz, B. Lockerbie, N. A. Lundgren, A. P. MacInnis, M. Macleod, D. M. Márka, S. Márka, Z. Markosyan, A. S. Maros, E. Martin, I. W. Martynov, D. V. Mason, K. Massinger, T. J. Matichard, F. Mavalvala, N. McCarthy, R. McClelland, D. E. McCormick, S. McIntyre, G. McIver, J. Mendell, G. Merilh, E. L. Meyers, P. M. Mittleman, R. Moreno, G. Mueller, G. Munch, J. Nuttall, L. K. Oberling, J. Oppermann, P. Oram, Richard J. Ottaway, D. J. Overmier, H. Palamos, J. R. Paris, H. R. Parker, W. Pele, A. Penn, S. Phelps, M. Pierro, V. Pinto, I. Principe, M. Prokhorov, L. G. Puncken, O. Quetschke, V. Quintero, E. A. Raab, F. J. Radkins, H. Raffai, P. Reid, S. Reitze, D. H. Robertson, N. A. Rollins, J. G. Roma, V. J. Romie, J. H. Rowan, S. Ryan, K. Sadecki, T. Sanchez, E. J. Sandberg, V. Savage, R. L. Schofield, R. M. S. Sellers, D. Shaddock, D. A. Shaffer, T. J. Shapiro, B. Shawhan, P. Shoemaker, D. H. Sigg, D. Slagmolen, B. J. J. Smith, B. Smith, J. R. Sorazu, B. Staley, A. Strain, K. A. Tanner, D. B. Taylor, R. Thomas, M. Thomas, P. Thorne, K. A. Thrane, E. Torrie, C. I. Traylor, G. Vajente, G. Valdes, G. van Veggel, A. A. Vecchio, A. Veitch, P. J. Venkateswara, K. Vo, T. Vorvick, C. Walker, M. Ward, R. L. Warner, J. Weaver, B. Weiss, R. Weßels, P. Willke, B. Wipf, C. C. Worden, J. Wu, G. Yamamoto, H. Yancey, C. C. Yu, Hang Yu, Haocun Zhang, L. Zucker, M. E. Zweizig, J. Gras, Slawomir Evans, Matthew J Fritschel, Peter K Miller, John |
| author_sort | Blair, Carl |
| collection | MIT |
| description | Interferometric gravitational wave detectors operate with high optical power in their arms in order to achieve high shot-noise limited strain sensitivity. A significant limitation to increasing the optical power is the phenomenon of three-mode parametric instabilities, in which the laser field in the arm cavities is scattered into higher-order optical modes by acoustic modes of the cavity mirrors. The optical modes can further drive the acoustic modes via radiation pressure, potentially producing an exponential buildup. One proposed technique to stabilize parametric instability is active damping of acoustic modes. We report here the first demonstration of damping a parametrically unstable mode using active feedback forces on the cavity mirror. A 15 538 Hz mode that grew exponentially with a time constant of 182 sec was damped using electrostatic actuation, with a resulting decay time constant of 23 sec. An average control force of 0.03 nN was required to maintain the acoustic mode at its minimum amplitude. |
| first_indexed | 2024-09-23T10:46:52Z |
| format | Article |
| id | mit-1721.1/108741 |
| institution | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-09-23T10:46:52Z |
| publishDate | 2017 |
| publisher | American Physical Society |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | mit-1721.1/1087412024-07-12T16:39:36Z First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO Blair, Carl Abbott, Richard Aston, Stuart Betzwieser, Joseph Blair, David DeRosa, Ryan Frolov, Valera Grote, Hartmut Hardwick, Terra Liu, Jian Lormand, Marc Mullavey, Adam O’Reilly, Brian Zhao, Chunnong Abbott, B. P. Abbott, T. D. Adams, C. Adhikari, R. X. Anderson, S. B. Ananyeva, A. Appert, S. Arai, K. Ballmer, S. W. Barker, D. Barr, B. Barsotti, L. Bartlett, J. Bartos, I. Batch, J. C. Bell, A. S. Billingsley, G. Birch, J. Biscans, S. Biwer, C. Bork, R. Brooks, A. F. Ciani, G. Clara, F. Countryman, S. T. Cowart, M. J. Coyne, D. C. Cumming, A. Cunningham, L. Danzmann, K. Da Silva Costa, C. F. Daw, E. J. DeBra, D. DeSalvo, R. Dooley, K. L. Doravari, S. Driggers, J. C. Dwyer, S. E. Effler, A. Etzel, T. Evans, T. M. Factourovich, M. Fair, H. Fernández Galiana, A. Fisher, R. P. Fulda, P. Fyffe, M. Giaime, J. A. Giardina, K. D. Goetz, E. Goetz, R. Gray, C. Gushwa, K. E. Gustafson, E. K. Gustafson, R. Hall, E. D. Hammond, G. Hanks, J. Hanson, J. Harry, G. M. Heintze, M. C. Heptonstall, A. W. Hough, J. Izumi, K. Jones, R. Kandhasamy, S. Karki, S. Kasprzack, M. Kaufer, S. Kawabe, K. Kijbunchoo, N. King, E. J. King, P. J. Kissel, J. S. Korth, W. Z. Kuehn, G. Landry, M. Lantz, B. Lockerbie, N. A. Lundgren, A. P. MacInnis, M. Macleod, D. M. Márka, S. Márka, Z. Markosyan, A. S. Maros, E. Martin, I. W. Martynov, D. V. Mason, K. Massinger, T. J. Matichard, F. Mavalvala, N. McCarthy, R. McClelland, D. E. McCormick, S. McIntyre, G. McIver, J. Mendell, G. Merilh, E. L. Meyers, P. M. Mittleman, R. Moreno, G. Mueller, G. Munch, J. Nuttall, L. K. Oberling, J. Oppermann, P. Oram, Richard J. Ottaway, D. J. Overmier, H. Palamos, J. R. Paris, H. R. Parker, W. Pele, A. Penn, S. Phelps, M. Pierro, V. Pinto, I. Principe, M. Prokhorov, L. G. Puncken, O. Quetschke, V. Quintero, E. A. Raab, F. J. Radkins, H. Raffai, P. Reid, S. Reitze, D. H. Robertson, N. A. Rollins, J. G. Roma, V. J. Romie, J. H. Rowan, S. Ryan, K. Sadecki, T. Sanchez, E. J. Sandberg, V. Savage, R. L. Schofield, R. M. S. Sellers, D. Shaddock, D. A. Shaffer, T. J. Shapiro, B. Shawhan, P. Shoemaker, D. H. Sigg, D. Slagmolen, B. J. J. Smith, B. Smith, J. R. Sorazu, B. Staley, A. Strain, K. A. Tanner, D. B. Taylor, R. Thomas, M. Thomas, P. Thorne, K. A. Thrane, E. Torrie, C. I. Traylor, G. Vajente, G. Valdes, G. van Veggel, A. A. Vecchio, A. Veitch, P. J. Venkateswara, K. Vo, T. Vorvick, C. Walker, M. Ward, R. L. Warner, J. Weaver, B. Weiss, R. Weßels, P. Willke, B. Wipf, C. C. Worden, J. Wu, G. Yamamoto, H. Yancey, C. C. Yu, Hang Yu, Haocun Zhang, L. Zucker, M. E. Zweizig, J. Gras, Slawomir Evans, Matthew J Fritschel, Peter K Miller, John LIGO (Observatory : Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Gras, Slawomir Evans, Matthew J Fritschel, Peter K Miller, John Interferometric gravitational wave detectors operate with high optical power in their arms in order to achieve high shot-noise limited strain sensitivity. A significant limitation to increasing the optical power is the phenomenon of three-mode parametric instabilities, in which the laser field in the arm cavities is scattered into higher-order optical modes by acoustic modes of the cavity mirrors. The optical modes can further drive the acoustic modes via radiation pressure, potentially producing an exponential buildup. One proposed technique to stabilize parametric instability is active damping of acoustic modes. We report here the first demonstration of damping a parametrically unstable mode using active feedback forces on the cavity mirror. A 15 538 Hz mode that grew exponentially with a time constant of 182 sec was damped using electrostatic actuation, with a resulting decay time constant of 23 sec. An average control force of 0.03 nN was required to maintain the acoustic mode at its minimum amplitude. National Science Foundation (U.S.) (PHY-0757058) National Science Foundation (U.S.) (PHY-0823459) Australian Research Council 2017-05-08T15:41:01Z 2017-05-08T15:41:01Z 2017-04 2016-11 2017-04-11T22:00:05Z Article http://purl.org/eprint/type/JournalArticle 0031-9007 1079-7114 http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/108741 Blair, Carl et al. “First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO.” Physical Revew Letters 118.157 (2017): 151102–31. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8459-4499 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1983-3187 en http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.151102 Physical Review Letters Article is made available in accordance with the publisher's policy and may be subject to US copyright law. Please refer to the publisher's site for terms of use. American Physical Society application/pdf American Physical Society American Physical Society |
| spellingShingle | Blair, Carl Abbott, Richard Aston, Stuart Betzwieser, Joseph Blair, David DeRosa, Ryan Frolov, Valera Grote, Hartmut Hardwick, Terra Liu, Jian Lormand, Marc Mullavey, Adam O’Reilly, Brian Zhao, Chunnong Abbott, B. P. Abbott, T. D. Adams, C. Adhikari, R. X. Anderson, S. B. Ananyeva, A. Appert, S. Arai, K. Ballmer, S. W. Barker, D. Barr, B. Barsotti, L. Bartlett, J. Bartos, I. Batch, J. C. Bell, A. S. Billingsley, G. Birch, J. Biscans, S. Biwer, C. Bork, R. Brooks, A. F. Ciani, G. Clara, F. Countryman, S. T. Cowart, M. J. Coyne, D. C. Cumming, A. Cunningham, L. Danzmann, K. Da Silva Costa, C. F. Daw, E. J. DeBra, D. DeSalvo, R. Dooley, K. L. Doravari, S. Driggers, J. C. Dwyer, S. E. Effler, A. Etzel, T. Evans, T. M. Factourovich, M. Fair, H. Fernández Galiana, A. Fisher, R. P. Fulda, P. Fyffe, M. Giaime, J. A. Giardina, K. D. Goetz, E. Goetz, R. Gray, C. Gushwa, K. E. Gustafson, E. K. Gustafson, R. Hall, E. D. Hammond, G. Hanks, J. Hanson, J. Harry, G. M. Heintze, M. C. Heptonstall, A. W. Hough, J. Izumi, K. Jones, R. Kandhasamy, S. Karki, S. Kasprzack, M. Kaufer, S. Kawabe, K. Kijbunchoo, N. King, E. J. King, P. J. Kissel, J. S. Korth, W. Z. Kuehn, G. Landry, M. Lantz, B. Lockerbie, N. A. Lundgren, A. P. MacInnis, M. Macleod, D. M. Márka, S. Márka, Z. Markosyan, A. S. Maros, E. Martin, I. W. Martynov, D. V. Mason, K. Massinger, T. J. Matichard, F. Mavalvala, N. McCarthy, R. McClelland, D. E. McCormick, S. McIntyre, G. McIver, J. Mendell, G. Merilh, E. L. Meyers, P. M. Mittleman, R. Moreno, G. Mueller, G. Munch, J. Nuttall, L. K. Oberling, J. Oppermann, P. Oram, Richard J. Ottaway, D. J. Overmier, H. Palamos, J. R. Paris, H. R. Parker, W. Pele, A. Penn, S. Phelps, M. Pierro, V. Pinto, I. Principe, M. Prokhorov, L. G. Puncken, O. Quetschke, V. Quintero, E. A. Raab, F. J. Radkins, H. Raffai, P. Reid, S. Reitze, D. H. Robertson, N. A. Rollins, J. G. Roma, V. J. Romie, J. H. Rowan, S. Ryan, K. Sadecki, T. Sanchez, E. J. Sandberg, V. Savage, R. L. Schofield, R. M. S. Sellers, D. Shaddock, D. A. Shaffer, T. J. Shapiro, B. Shawhan, P. Shoemaker, D. H. Sigg, D. Slagmolen, B. J. J. Smith, B. Smith, J. R. Sorazu, B. Staley, A. Strain, K. A. Tanner, D. B. Taylor, R. Thomas, M. Thomas, P. Thorne, K. A. Thrane, E. Torrie, C. I. Traylor, G. Vajente, G. Valdes, G. van Veggel, A. A. Vecchio, A. Veitch, P. J. Venkateswara, K. Vo, T. Vorvick, C. Walker, M. Ward, R. L. Warner, J. Weaver, B. Weiss, R. Weßels, P. Willke, B. Wipf, C. C. Worden, J. Wu, G. Yamamoto, H. Yancey, C. C. Yu, Hang Yu, Haocun Zhang, L. Zucker, M. E. Zweizig, J. Gras, Slawomir Evans, Matthew J Fritschel, Peter K Miller, John First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO |
| title | First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO |
| title_full | First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO |
| title_fullStr | First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO |
| title_full_unstemmed | First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO |
| title_short | First Demonstration of Electrostatic Damping of Parametric Instability at Advanced LIGO |
| title_sort | first demonstration of electrostatic damping of parametric instability at advanced ligo |
| url | http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/108741 https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8459-4499 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1983-3187 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT blaircarl firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT abbottrichard firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT astonstuart firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT betzwieserjoseph firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT blairdavid firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT derosaryan firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT frolovvalera firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT grotehartmut firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT hardwickterra firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT liujian firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT lormandmarc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mullaveyadam firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT oreillybrian firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT zhaochunnong firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT abbottbp firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT abbotttd firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT adamsc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT adhikarirx firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT andersonsb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT ananyevaa firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT apperts firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT araik firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT ballmersw firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT barkerd firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT barrb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT barsottil firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT bartlettj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT bartosi firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT batchjc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT bellas firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT billingsleyg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT birchj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT biscanss firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT biwerc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT borkr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT brooksaf firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT cianig firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT claraf firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT countrymanst firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT cowartmj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT coynedc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT cumminga firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT cunninghaml firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT danzmannk firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT dasilvacostacf firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT dawej firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT debrad firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT desalvor firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT dooleykl firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT doravaris firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT driggersjc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT dwyerse firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT efflera firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT etzelt firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT evanstm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT factourovichm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT fairh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT fernandezgalianaa firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT fisherrp firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT fuldap firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT fyffem firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT giaimeja firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT giardinakd firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT goetze firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT goetzr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT grayc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT gushwake firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT gustafsonek firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT gustafsonr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT halled firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT hammondg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT hanksj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT hansonj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT harrygm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT heintzemc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT heptonstallaw firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT houghj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT izumik firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT jonesr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kandhasamys firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT karkis firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kasprzackm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kaufers firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kawabek firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kijbunchoon firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kingej firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kingpj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kisseljs firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT korthwz firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT kuehng firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT landrym firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT lantzb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT lockerbiena firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT lundgrenap firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT macinnism firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT macleoddm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT markas firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT markaz firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT markosyanas firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT marose firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT martiniw firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT martynovdv firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT masonk firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT massingertj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT matichardf firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mavalvalan firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mccarthyr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mcclellandde firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mccormicks firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mcintyreg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mciverj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mendellg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT merilhel firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT meyerspm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT mittlemanr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT morenog firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT muellerg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT munchj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT nuttalllk firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT oberlingj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT oppermannp firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT oramrichardj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT ottawaydj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT overmierh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT palamosjr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT parishr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT parkerw firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT pelea firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT penns firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT phelpsm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT pierrov firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT pintoi firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT principem firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT prokhorovlg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT punckeno firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT quetschkev firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT quinteroea firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT raabfj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT radkinsh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT raffaip firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT reids firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT reitzedh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT robertsonna firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT rollinsjg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT romavj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT romiejh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT rowans firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT ryank firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT sadeckit firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT sanchezej firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT sandbergv firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT savagerl firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT schofieldrms firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT sellersd firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT shaddockda firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT shaffertj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT shapirob firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT shawhanp firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT shoemakerdh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT siggd firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT slagmolenbjj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT smithb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT smithjr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT sorazub firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT staleya firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT strainka firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT tannerdb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT taylorr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT thomasm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT thomasp firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT thorneka firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT thranee firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT torrieci firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT traylorg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT vajenteg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT valdesg firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT vanveggelaa firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT vecchioa firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT veitchpj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT venkateswarak firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT vot firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT vorvickc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT walkerm firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT wardrl firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT warnerj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT weaverb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT weissr firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT weßelsp firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT willkeb firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT wipfcc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT wordenj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT wug firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT yamamotoh firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT yanceycc firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT yuhang firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT yuhaocun firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT zhangl firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT zuckerme firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT zweizigj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT grasslawomir firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT evansmatthewj firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT fritschelpeterk firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo AT millerjohn firstdemonstrationofelectrostaticdampingofparametricinstabilityatadvancedligo |