The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra
Using Chandra ACIS-S, we have obtained low-resolution imaging X-ray spectrophotometry of the Pluto system in support of the New Horizons flyby on 14 July 2015. Observations were obtained in a trial “seed” campaign conducted in one visit on 24 Feb 2014, and a follow-up campaign conducted soon after t...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Other Authors: | |
| Format: | Article |
| Published: |
Elsevier
2018
|
| Online Access: | http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/118162 |
| _version_ | 1826201096790474752 |
|---|---|
| author | Lisse, C.M. McNutt, R.L. Wolk, S.J. Bagenal, F. Stern, S.A. Gladstone, G.R. Cravens, T.E. Hill, M.E. Kollmann, P. Weaver, H.A. Strobel, D.F. Elliott, H.A. McComas, D.J. Snios, B.T. Bhardwaj, A. Chutjian, A. Young, L.A. Olkin, C.B. Ennico, K.A. Binzel, Richard P |
| author2 | Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences |
| author_facet | Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences Lisse, C.M. McNutt, R.L. Wolk, S.J. Bagenal, F. Stern, S.A. Gladstone, G.R. Cravens, T.E. Hill, M.E. Kollmann, P. Weaver, H.A. Strobel, D.F. Elliott, H.A. McComas, D.J. Snios, B.T. Bhardwaj, A. Chutjian, A. Young, L.A. Olkin, C.B. Ennico, K.A. Binzel, Richard P |
| author_sort | Lisse, C.M. |
| collection | MIT |
| description | Using Chandra ACIS-S, we have obtained low-resolution imaging X-ray spectrophotometry of the Pluto system in support of the New Horizons flyby on 14 July 2015. Observations were obtained in a trial “seed” campaign conducted in one visit on 24 Feb 2014, and a follow-up campaign conducted soon after the New Horizons flyby that consisted of 3 visits spanning 26 Jul to 03 Aug 2015. In a total of 174 ksec of on-target time, in the 0.31 to 0.60 keV passband, we measured 8 total photons in a co-moving 11 × 11 pixel2box (the 90% flux aperture determined by observations of fixed background sources in the field) measuring ∼121,000 × 121,000 km[superscript 2](or ∼100 × 100 R[subscript Pluto]) at Pluto. No photons were detected from 0.60 to 1.0 keV in this box during the same exposures. Allowing for background, we find a net signal of 6.8 counts and a statistical noise level of 1.2 counts, for a detection of Pluto in this passband at > 99.95% confidence. The Pluto photons do not have the spectral shape of the background, are coincident with a 90% flux aperture co-moving with Pluto, and are not confused with any background source, so we consider them as sourced from the Pluto system. The mean 0.31 - 0.60 keV X-ray power from Pluto is 200 +200/-100 MW, in the middle range of X-ray power levels seen for other known Solar System emission sources: auroral precipitation, solar X-ray scattering, and charge exchange (CXE) between solar wind (SW) ions and atmospheric neutrals. We eliminate auroral effects as a source, as Pluto has no known magnetic field and the New Horizons Alice UV spectrometer detected no airglow from Pluto during the flyby. Nano-scale atmospheric haze particles could lead to enhanced resonant scattering of solar X-rays from Pluto, but the energy signature of the detected photons does not match the solar spectrum and estimates of Pluto's scattered X-ray emission are 2 to 3 orders of magnitude below the 3.9 ± 0.7 × 10[superscript −5] cps found in our observations. Charge-exchange-driven emission from hydrogenic and heliogenic SW carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen (CNO) ions can produce the energy signature seen, and the 6 × 10[superscript 25] neutral gas escape rate from Pluto deduced from New Horizons’ data (Gladstone et al. 2016) can support the ∼3.0 +3.0/-1.5× 10[superscript 24] X-ray photons/s emission rate required by our observations. Using the solar wind proton density and speed measured by the Solar Wind Around Pluto (SWAP) instrument in the vicinity of Pluto at the time of the photon emissions, we find a factor of 40 +40/-20 lower SW minor ions flowing planarly into an 11 × 11 pixel[superscript 2], 90% flux box centered on Pluto than are needed to support the observed emission rate. Hence, the SW must be somehow significantly focused and enhanced within 60,000 km (projected) of Pluto for this mechanism to work. Keywords:
Pluto, atmosphere; Solar wind; Interplanetary medium; Spectroscopy |
| first_indexed | 2024-09-23T11:46:32Z |
| format | Article |
| id | mit-1721.1/118162 |
| institution | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| last_indexed | 2024-09-23T11:46:32Z |
| publishDate | 2018 |
| publisher | Elsevier |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | mit-1721.1/1181622022-09-27T21:50:21Z The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra Lisse, C.M. McNutt, R.L. Wolk, S.J. Bagenal, F. Stern, S.A. Gladstone, G.R. Cravens, T.E. Hill, M.E. Kollmann, P. Weaver, H.A. Strobel, D.F. Elliott, H.A. McComas, D.J. Snios, B.T. Bhardwaj, A. Chutjian, A. Young, L.A. Olkin, C.B. Ennico, K.A. Binzel, Richard P Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences Binzel, Richard P Using Chandra ACIS-S, we have obtained low-resolution imaging X-ray spectrophotometry of the Pluto system in support of the New Horizons flyby on 14 July 2015. Observations were obtained in a trial “seed” campaign conducted in one visit on 24 Feb 2014, and a follow-up campaign conducted soon after the New Horizons flyby that consisted of 3 visits spanning 26 Jul to 03 Aug 2015. In a total of 174 ksec of on-target time, in the 0.31 to 0.60 keV passband, we measured 8 total photons in a co-moving 11 × 11 pixel2box (the 90% flux aperture determined by observations of fixed background sources in the field) measuring ∼121,000 × 121,000 km[superscript 2](or ∼100 × 100 R[subscript Pluto]) at Pluto. No photons were detected from 0.60 to 1.0 keV in this box during the same exposures. Allowing for background, we find a net signal of 6.8 counts and a statistical noise level of 1.2 counts, for a detection of Pluto in this passband at > 99.95% confidence. The Pluto photons do not have the spectral shape of the background, are coincident with a 90% flux aperture co-moving with Pluto, and are not confused with any background source, so we consider them as sourced from the Pluto system. The mean 0.31 - 0.60 keV X-ray power from Pluto is 200 +200/-100 MW, in the middle range of X-ray power levels seen for other known Solar System emission sources: auroral precipitation, solar X-ray scattering, and charge exchange (CXE) between solar wind (SW) ions and atmospheric neutrals. We eliminate auroral effects as a source, as Pluto has no known magnetic field and the New Horizons Alice UV spectrometer detected no airglow from Pluto during the flyby. Nano-scale atmospheric haze particles could lead to enhanced resonant scattering of solar X-rays from Pluto, but the energy signature of the detected photons does not match the solar spectrum and estimates of Pluto's scattered X-ray emission are 2 to 3 orders of magnitude below the 3.9 ± 0.7 × 10[superscript −5] cps found in our observations. Charge-exchange-driven emission from hydrogenic and heliogenic SW carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen (CNO) ions can produce the energy signature seen, and the 6 × 10[superscript 25] neutral gas escape rate from Pluto deduced from New Horizons’ data (Gladstone et al. 2016) can support the ∼3.0 +3.0/-1.5× 10[superscript 24] X-ray photons/s emission rate required by our observations. Using the solar wind proton density and speed measured by the Solar Wind Around Pluto (SWAP) instrument in the vicinity of Pluto at the time of the photon emissions, we find a factor of 40 +40/-20 lower SW minor ions flowing planarly into an 11 × 11 pixel[superscript 2], 90% flux box centered on Pluto than are needed to support the observed emission rate. Hence, the SW must be somehow significantly focused and enhanced within 60,000 km (projected) of Pluto for this mechanism to work. Keywords: Pluto, atmosphere; Solar wind; Interplanetary medium; Spectroscopy 2018-09-21T15:57:15Z 2018-09-21T15:57:15Z 2016-07 2016-07 2018-09-19T17:54:05Z Article http://purl.org/eprint/type/JournalArticle 0019-1035 1090-2643 http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/118162 Lisse, C.M., R.L. McNutt, S.J. Wolk, F. Bagenal, S.A. Stern, G.R. Gladstone, T.E. Cravens, et al. “The Puzzling Detection of x-Rays from Pluto by Chandra.” Icarus 287 (May 2017): 103–109 © 2016 Elsevier Inc http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/J.ICARUS.2016.07.008 Icarus Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ application/pdf Elsevier arXiv |
| spellingShingle | Lisse, C.M. McNutt, R.L. Wolk, S.J. Bagenal, F. Stern, S.A. Gladstone, G.R. Cravens, T.E. Hill, M.E. Kollmann, P. Weaver, H.A. Strobel, D.F. Elliott, H.A. McComas, D.J. Snios, B.T. Bhardwaj, A. Chutjian, A. Young, L.A. Olkin, C.B. Ennico, K.A. Binzel, Richard P The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra |
| title | The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra |
| title_full | The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra |
| title_fullStr | The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra |
| title_full_unstemmed | The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra |
| title_short | The puzzling detection of x-rays from Pluto by Chandra |
| title_sort | puzzling detection of x rays from pluto by chandra |
| url | http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/118162 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT lissecm thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT mcnuttrl thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT wolksj thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT bagenalf thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT sternsa thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT gladstonegr thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT cravenste thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT hillme thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT kollmannp thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT weaverha thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT strobeldf thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT elliottha thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT mccomasdj thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT sniosbt thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT bhardwaja thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT chutjiana thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT youngla thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT olkincb thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT ennicoka thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT binzelrichardp thepuzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT lissecm puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT mcnuttrl puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT wolksj puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT bagenalf puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT sternsa puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT gladstonegr puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT cravenste puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT hillme puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT kollmannp puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT weaverha puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT strobeldf puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT elliottha puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT mccomasdj puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT sniosbt puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT bhardwaja puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT chutjiana puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT youngla puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT olkincb puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT ennicoka puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra AT binzelrichardp puzzlingdetectionofxraysfromplutobychandra |