Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently
Background: Rapid Advice Guidelines (RAG) provide decision makers with guidance to respond to public health emergencies by developing evidence-based recommendations in a short period of time with a scientific and standardized approach. However, the experience from the development process of a RAG ha...
| Główni autorzy: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Artykuł |
| Język: | English |
| Wydane: |
BioMed Central Ltd
2022
|
| Hasła przedmiotowe: | |
| Dostęp online: | https://repository.ugm.ac.id/284045/1/181.pdf |
| _version_ | 1826050736475078656 |
|---|---|
| author | Zhou, Qi Li, Qinyuan Estill, Janne Wang, Qi Wang, Zijun Shi, Qianling Zhang, Jingyi Zhang, Xiaobo Mathew, Joseph L. Smyth, Rosalind L. Nurdiati, Detty Fu, Zhou Xu, Hongmei Zheng, Xianlan Zhao, Xiaodong Lu, Quan Liu, Hui Xun, Yangqin Li, Weiguo Yang, Shu Feng, Xixi Wang, Mengshu Lei, Junqiang Luo, Xiaoping Wu, Liqun Lu, Xiaoxia Lee, Myeong Soo Zhao, Shunying Chan, Edwin Shih-Yen Qian, Yuan Tu, Wenwei Dong, Xiaoyan Li, Guobao Zhao, Ruiqiu He, Zhihui Zhao, Siya Liu, Xiao Li, Qiu Yang, Kehu Luo, Zhengxiu Liu, Enmei Chen, Yaolong |
| author_facet | Zhou, Qi Li, Qinyuan Estill, Janne Wang, Qi Wang, Zijun Shi, Qianling Zhang, Jingyi Zhang, Xiaobo Mathew, Joseph L. Smyth, Rosalind L. Nurdiati, Detty Fu, Zhou Xu, Hongmei Zheng, Xianlan Zhao, Xiaodong Lu, Quan Liu, Hui Xun, Yangqin Li, Weiguo Yang, Shu Feng, Xixi Wang, Mengshu Lei, Junqiang Luo, Xiaoping Wu, Liqun Lu, Xiaoxia Lee, Myeong Soo Zhao, Shunying Chan, Edwin Shih-Yen Qian, Yuan Tu, Wenwei Dong, Xiaoyan Li, Guobao Zhao, Ruiqiu He, Zhihui Zhao, Siya Liu, Xiao Li, Qiu Yang, Kehu Luo, Zhengxiu Liu, Enmei Chen, Yaolong |
| author_sort | Zhou, Qi |
| collection | UGM |
| description | Background: Rapid Advice Guidelines (RAG) provide decision makers with guidance to respond to public health emergencies by developing evidence-based recommendations in a short period of time with a scientific and standardized approach. However, the experience from the development process of a RAG has so far not been systematically summarized. Therefore, our working group will take the experience of the development of the RAG for children with COVID-19 as an example to systematically explore the methodology, advantages, and challenges in the development of the RAG. We shall propose suggestions and reflections for future research, in order to provide a more detailed reference for future development of RAGs. Result: The development of the RAG by a group of 67 researchers from 11 countries took 50 days from the official commencement of the work (January 28, 2020) to submission (March 17, 2020). A total of 21 meetings were held with a total duration of 48 h (average 2.3 h per meeting) and an average of 16.5 participants attending. Only two of the ten recommendations were fully supported by direct evidence for COVID-19, three recommendations were supported by indirect evidence only, and the proportion of COVID-19 studies among the body of evidence in the remaining five recommendations ranged between 10 and 83%. Six of the ten recommendations used COVID-19 preprints as evidence support, and up to 50% of the studies with direct evidence on COVID-19 were preprints. Conclusions: In order to respond to public health emergencies, the development of RAG also requires a clear and transparent formulation process, usually using a large amount of indirect and non-peer-reviewed evidence to support the formation of recommendations. Strict following of the WHO RAG handbook does not only enhance the transparency and clarity of the guideline, but also can speed up the guideline development process, thereby saving time and labor costs. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-14T00:09:17Z |
| format | Article |
| id | oai:generic.eprints.org:284045 |
| institution | Universiti Gadjah Mada |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-14T00:09:17Z |
| publishDate | 2022 |
| publisher | BioMed Central Ltd |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oai:generic.eprints.org:2840452023-11-28T01:29:17Z https://repository.ugm.ac.id/284045/ Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently Zhou, Qi Li, Qinyuan Estill, Janne Wang, Qi Wang, Zijun Shi, Qianling Zhang, Jingyi Zhang, Xiaobo Mathew, Joseph L. Smyth, Rosalind L. Nurdiati, Detty Fu, Zhou Xu, Hongmei Zheng, Xianlan Zhao, Xiaodong Lu, Quan Liu, Hui Xun, Yangqin Li, Weiguo Yang, Shu Feng, Xixi Wang, Mengshu Lei, Junqiang Luo, Xiaoping Wu, Liqun Lu, Xiaoxia Lee, Myeong Soo Zhao, Shunying Chan, Edwin Shih-Yen Qian, Yuan Tu, Wenwei Dong, Xiaoyan Li, Guobao Zhao, Ruiqiu He, Zhihui Zhao, Siya Liu, Xiao Li, Qiu Yang, Kehu Luo, Zhengxiu Liu, Enmei Chen, Yaolong Respiratory Diseases Background: Rapid Advice Guidelines (RAG) provide decision makers with guidance to respond to public health emergencies by developing evidence-based recommendations in a short period of time with a scientific and standardized approach. However, the experience from the development process of a RAG has so far not been systematically summarized. Therefore, our working group will take the experience of the development of the RAG for children with COVID-19 as an example to systematically explore the methodology, advantages, and challenges in the development of the RAG. We shall propose suggestions and reflections for future research, in order to provide a more detailed reference for future development of RAGs. Result: The development of the RAG by a group of 67 researchers from 11 countries took 50 days from the official commencement of the work (January 28, 2020) to submission (March 17, 2020). A total of 21 meetings were held with a total duration of 48 h (average 2.3 h per meeting) and an average of 16.5 participants attending. Only two of the ten recommendations were fully supported by direct evidence for COVID-19, three recommendations were supported by indirect evidence only, and the proportion of COVID-19 studies among the body of evidence in the remaining five recommendations ranged between 10 and 83%. Six of the ten recommendations used COVID-19 preprints as evidence support, and up to 50% of the studies with direct evidence on COVID-19 were preprints. Conclusions: In order to respond to public health emergencies, the development of RAG also requires a clear and transparent formulation process, usually using a large amount of indirect and non-peer-reviewed evidence to support the formation of recommendations. Strict following of the WHO RAG handbook does not only enhance the transparency and clarity of the guideline, but also can speed up the guideline development process, thereby saving time and labor costs. BioMed Central Ltd 2022 Article PeerReviewed application/pdf en https://repository.ugm.ac.id/284045/1/181.pdf Zhou, Qi and Li, Qinyuan and Estill, Janne and Wang, Qi and Wang, Zijun and Shi, Qianling and Zhang, Jingyi and Zhang, Xiaobo and Mathew, Joseph L. and Smyth, Rosalind L. and Nurdiati, Detty and Fu, Zhou and Xu, Hongmei and Zheng, Xianlan and Zhao, Xiaodong and Lu, Quan and Liu, Hui and Xun, Yangqin and Li, Weiguo and Yang, Shu and Feng, Xixi and Wang, Mengshu and Lei, Junqiang and Luo, Xiaoping and Wu, Liqun and Lu, Xiaoxia and Lee, Myeong Soo and Zhao, Shunying and Chan, Edwin Shih-Yen and Qian, Yuan and Tu, Wenwei and Dong, Xiaoyan and Li, Guobao and Zhao, Ruiqiu and He, Zhihui and Zhao, Siya and Liu, Xiao and Li, Qiu and Yang, Kehu and Luo, Zhengxiu and Liu, Enmei and Chen, Yaolong (2022) Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 22 (1). p. 89. ISSN 14712288 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12874-022-01545-5?utm_source=getftr&utm_medium=getftr&utm_campaign=getftr_pilot 10.1186/s12874-022-01545-5 |
| spellingShingle | Respiratory Diseases Zhou, Qi Li, Qinyuan Estill, Janne Wang, Qi Wang, Zijun Shi, Qianling Zhang, Jingyi Zhang, Xiaobo Mathew, Joseph L. Smyth, Rosalind L. Nurdiati, Detty Fu, Zhou Xu, Hongmei Zheng, Xianlan Zhao, Xiaodong Lu, Quan Liu, Hui Xun, Yangqin Li, Weiguo Yang, Shu Feng, Xixi Wang, Mengshu Lei, Junqiang Luo, Xiaoping Wu, Liqun Lu, Xiaoxia Lee, Myeong Soo Zhao, Shunying Chan, Edwin Shih-Yen Qian, Yuan Tu, Wenwei Dong, Xiaoyan Li, Guobao Zhao, Ruiqiu He, Zhihui Zhao, Siya Liu, Xiao Li, Qiu Yang, Kehu Luo, Zhengxiu Liu, Enmei Chen, Yaolong Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| title | Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| title_full | Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| title_fullStr | Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| title_full_unstemmed | Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| title_short | Methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with COVID-19: responding to the COVID-19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| title_sort | methodology and experiences of rapid advice guideline development for children with covid 19 responding to the covid 19 outbreak quickly and efficiently |
| topic | Respiratory Diseases |
| url | https://repository.ugm.ac.id/284045/1/181.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT zhouqi methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liqinyuan methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT estilljanne methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT wangqi methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT wangzijun methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT shiqianling methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhangjingyi methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhangxiaobo methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT mathewjosephl methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT smythrosalindl methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT nurdiatidetty methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT fuzhou methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT xuhongmei methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhengxianlan methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhaoxiaodong methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT luquan methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liuhui methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT xunyangqin methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liweiguo methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT yangshu methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT fengxixi methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT wangmengshu methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT leijunqiang methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT luoxiaoping methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT wuliqun methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT luxiaoxia methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT leemyeongsoo methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhaoshunying methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT chanedwinshihyen methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT qianyuan methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT tuwenwei methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT dongxiaoyan methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liguobao methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhaoruiqiu methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT hezhihui methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT zhaosiya methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liuxiao methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liqiu methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT yangkehu methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT luozhengxiu methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT liuenmei methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently AT chenyaolong methodologyandexperiencesofrapidadviceguidelinedevelopmentforchildrenwithcovid19respondingtothecovid19outbreakquicklyandefficiently |