‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10
<strong>Extract: </strong> ‘The last stanza of Horace's poem’, writes Denis Feeney of Hor. Carm. 3.3, ‘declares virtually outright that he has just been “quoting” epic matter: “desine peruicax | referre sermones deorum et | magna modis tenuare paruis” (70–2)’. A poem that recounts t...
| Autor principal: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Idioma: | English |
| Publicat: |
Cambridge University Press
2020
|
| _version_ | 1826257001899884544 |
|---|---|
| author | Morgan, L |
| author_facet | Morgan, L |
| author_sort | Morgan, L |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <strong>Extract: </strong>
‘The last stanza of Horace's poem’, writes Denis Feeney of Hor. Carm. 3.3, ‘declares virtually outright that he has just been “quoting” epic matter: “desine peruicax | referre sermones deorum et | magna modis tenuare paruis” (70–2)’. A poem that recounts the doings of gods automatically demands comparison with epic, but if the speeches of gods are presented, all the more so. Horace's poem in fact evokes an episode within a specific epic poem, the Council of the Gods that occurred during the first book of Ennius’ Annales. But such divine councils are a ‘stock epic scene’, and rather more than that: they are moments when epic is at its most quintessentially epic. In simple terms, an epic poet ‘may underline the significance and increase the dramatic effect’ of a critical point in the narrative ‘by showing us that it exercised the gods’, and that analysis applies to any divine presence in a poem: if a key impulse of epic is to amplify the significance of human activity, those occasions when higher forces overtly assert their control of human destiny satisfy a number of fundamental preoccupations of the genre. But in the Council of the Gods we have the most developed and impressive realization of this divine concern for mortal existence, as well as a topos that in Rome at least achieved special status within the broader field of divine machinery in epic. That status is perhaps reflected in a tendency discernible in the Roman section of the tradition for such councils to fall early in the epic narrative, as if initiating the epic plot. If so, however, Virgil's Council at Aen. 10.1–117 defies expectation by failing to be convened until the plot of the epic is very far advanced indeed, and even then, as this article will consider, achieving strikingly less than one might expect of a plenary gathering of supernatural powers at an advanced stage in an epic narrative. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-06T18:11:13Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:03158e7e-6265-4f59-94d9-e8c5ed78876f |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-06T18:11:13Z |
| publishDate | 2020 |
| publisher | Cambridge University Press |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:03158e7e-6265-4f59-94d9-e8c5ed78876f2022-03-26T08:44:11Z‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:03158e7e-6265-4f59-94d9-e8c5ed78876fEnglishSymplectic Elements at OxfordCambridge University Press2020Morgan, L<strong>Extract: </strong> ‘The last stanza of Horace's poem’, writes Denis Feeney of Hor. Carm. 3.3, ‘declares virtually outright that he has just been “quoting” epic matter: “desine peruicax | referre sermones deorum et | magna modis tenuare paruis” (70–2)’. A poem that recounts the doings of gods automatically demands comparison with epic, but if the speeches of gods are presented, all the more so. Horace's poem in fact evokes an episode within a specific epic poem, the Council of the Gods that occurred during the first book of Ennius’ Annales. But such divine councils are a ‘stock epic scene’, and rather more than that: they are moments when epic is at its most quintessentially epic. In simple terms, an epic poet ‘may underline the significance and increase the dramatic effect’ of a critical point in the narrative ‘by showing us that it exercised the gods’, and that analysis applies to any divine presence in a poem: if a key impulse of epic is to amplify the significance of human activity, those occasions when higher forces overtly assert their control of human destiny satisfy a number of fundamental preoccupations of the genre. But in the Council of the Gods we have the most developed and impressive realization of this divine concern for mortal existence, as well as a topos that in Rome at least achieved special status within the broader field of divine machinery in epic. That status is perhaps reflected in a tendency discernible in the Roman section of the tradition for such councils to fall early in the epic narrative, as if initiating the epic plot. If so, however, Virgil's Council at Aen. 10.1–117 defies expectation by failing to be convened until the plot of the epic is very far advanced indeed, and even then, as this article will consider, achieving strikingly less than one might expect of a plenary gathering of supernatural powers at an advanced stage in an epic narrative. |
| spellingShingle | Morgan, L ‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10 |
| title | ‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10 |
| title_full | ‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10 |
| title_fullStr | ‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10 |
| title_full_unstemmed | ‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10 |
| title_short | ‘To heaven on a hook’ (Dio Cass. 60.35.4): Ennius, Lucilius and an ineffectual Council of the Gods in Aeneid 10 |
| title_sort | to heaven on a hook dio cass 60 35 4 ennius lucilius and an ineffectual council of the gods in aeneid 10 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT morganl toheavenonahookdiocass60354enniusluciliusandanineffectualcouncilofthegodsinaeneid10 |