The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH
Titan's atmospheric inventory of oxygen compounds (H2O, CO2, CO) are thought to result from photochemistry acting on externally supplied oxygen species (O+, OH, H2O). These species potentially originate from two main sources: (1) cryogenic plumes from the active moon Enceladus and (2) micromete...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Published: |
American Astronomical Society
2018
|
| _version_ | 1826258527030607872 |
|---|---|
| author | Teanby, N Cordiner, M Nixon, C Irwin, P Horst, S Sylvestre, M Serigano, J Thelen, A Richards, A Charnley, S |
| author_facet | Teanby, N Cordiner, M Nixon, C Irwin, P Horst, S Sylvestre, M Serigano, J Thelen, A Richards, A Charnley, S |
| author_sort | Teanby, N |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Titan's atmospheric inventory of oxygen compounds (H2O, CO2, CO) are thought to result from photochemistry acting on externally supplied oxygen species (O+, OH, H2O). These species potentially originate from two main sources: (1) cryogenic plumes from the active moon Enceladus and (2) micrometeoroid ablation. Enceladus is already suspected to be the major O+ source, which is required for CO creation. However, photochemical models also require H2O and OH influx to reproduce observed quantities of CO2 and H2O. Here, we exploit sulphur as a tracer to investigate the oxygen source because it has very different relative abundances in micrometeorites (S/O ~ 10−2) and Enceladus' plumes (S/O ~ 10−5). Photochemical models predict most sulphur is converted to CS in the upper atmosphere, so we use Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations at ~340 GHz to search for CS emission. We determined stringent CS 3σ stratospheric upper limits of 0.0074 ppb (uniform above 100 km) and 0.0256 ppb (uniform above 200 km). These upper limits are not quite stringent enough to distinguish between Enceladus and micrometeorite sources at the 3σ level and a contribution from micrometeorites cannot be ruled out, especially if external flux is toward the lower end of current estimates. Only the high-flux micrometeorite source model of Hickson et al. can be rejected at 3σ. We determined a 3σ stratospheric upper limit for CH2NH of 0.35 ppb, which suggests cosmic rays may have a smaller influence in the lower stratosphere than predicted by some photochemical models. Disk-averaged C3H4 and C2H5CN profiles were determined and are consistent with previous ALMA and Cassini/CIRS measurements. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-06T18:35:21Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:0b08e12b-5c32-4c57-88cc-c771a2648204 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-06T18:35:21Z |
| publishDate | 2018 |
| publisher | American Astronomical Society |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:0b08e12b-5c32-4c57-88cc-c771a26482042022-03-26T09:27:20ZThe origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NHJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:0b08e12b-5c32-4c57-88cc-c771a2648204Symplectic Elements at OxfordAmerican Astronomical Society2018Teanby, NCordiner, MNixon, CIrwin, PHorst, SSylvestre, MSerigano, JThelen, ARichards, ACharnley, STitan's atmospheric inventory of oxygen compounds (H2O, CO2, CO) are thought to result from photochemistry acting on externally supplied oxygen species (O+, OH, H2O). These species potentially originate from two main sources: (1) cryogenic plumes from the active moon Enceladus and (2) micrometeoroid ablation. Enceladus is already suspected to be the major O+ source, which is required for CO creation. However, photochemical models also require H2O and OH influx to reproduce observed quantities of CO2 and H2O. Here, we exploit sulphur as a tracer to investigate the oxygen source because it has very different relative abundances in micrometeorites (S/O ~ 10−2) and Enceladus' plumes (S/O ~ 10−5). Photochemical models predict most sulphur is converted to CS in the upper atmosphere, so we use Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations at ~340 GHz to search for CS emission. We determined stringent CS 3σ stratospheric upper limits of 0.0074 ppb (uniform above 100 km) and 0.0256 ppb (uniform above 200 km). These upper limits are not quite stringent enough to distinguish between Enceladus and micrometeorite sources at the 3σ level and a contribution from micrometeorites cannot be ruled out, especially if external flux is toward the lower end of current estimates. Only the high-flux micrometeorite source model of Hickson et al. can be rejected at 3σ. We determined a 3σ stratospheric upper limit for CH2NH of 0.35 ppb, which suggests cosmic rays may have a smaller influence in the lower stratosphere than predicted by some photochemical models. Disk-averaged C3H4 and C2H5CN profiles were determined and are consistent with previous ALMA and Cassini/CIRS measurements. |
| spellingShingle | Teanby, N Cordiner, M Nixon, C Irwin, P Horst, S Sylvestre, M Serigano, J Thelen, A Richards, A Charnley, S The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH |
| title | The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH |
| title_full | The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH |
| title_fullStr | The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH |
| title_full_unstemmed | The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH |
| title_short | The origin of Titan's external oxygen: further constraints from ALMA upper limits on CS and CH2NH |
| title_sort | origin of titan s external oxygen further constraints from alma upper limits on cs and ch2nh |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT teanbyn theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT cordinerm theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT nixonc theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT irwinp theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT horsts theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT sylvestrem theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT seriganoj theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT thelena theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT richardsa theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT charnleys theoriginoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT teanbyn originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT cordinerm originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT nixonc originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT irwinp originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT horsts originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT sylvestrem originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT seriganoj originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT thelena originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT richardsa originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh AT charnleys originoftitansexternaloxygenfurtherconstraintsfromalmaupperlimitsoncsandch2nh |