The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021
Genomic surveillance for SARS-CoV-2 lineages informs our understanding of possible future changes in transmissibility and vaccine efficacy and will be a high priority for public health for the foreseeable future. However, small changes in the frequency of one lineage over another are often difficult...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Other Authors: | |
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Microbiology Society
2023
|
| _version_ | 1797110488317820928 |
|---|---|
| author | Eales, O Page, AJ Tang, SN Walters, CE Wang, H Haw, D Trotter, AJ Le Viet, T Foster-Nyarko, E Prosolek, S Atchison, C Ashby, D Cooke, G Barclay, W Donnelly, CA O'Grady, J Volz, E Darzi, A Ward, H Elliott, P Riley, S |
| author2 | The COVID-19 Genomics UK (COGUK) Consortium |
| author_facet | The COVID-19 Genomics UK (COGUK) Consortium Eales, O Page, AJ Tang, SN Walters, CE Wang, H Haw, D Trotter, AJ Le Viet, T Foster-Nyarko, E Prosolek, S Atchison, C Ashby, D Cooke, G Barclay, W Donnelly, CA O'Grady, J Volz, E Darzi, A Ward, H Elliott, P Riley, S |
| author_sort | Eales, O |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Genomic surveillance for SARS-CoV-2 lineages informs our understanding of possible future changes in transmissibility and vaccine efficacy and will be a high priority for public health for the foreseeable future. However, small changes in the frequency of one lineage over another are often difficult to interpret because surveillance samples are obtained using a variety of methods all of which are known to contain biases. As a case study, using an approach which is largely free of biases, we here describe lineage dynamics and phylogenetic relationships of the Alpha and Beta variant in England during the first 3 months of 2021 using sequences obtained from a random community sample who provided a throat and nose swab for rt-PCR as part of the REal-time Assessment of Community Transmission-1 (REACT-1) study. Overall, diversity decreased during the first quarter of 2021, with the Alpha variant (first identified in Kent) becoming predominant, driven by a reproduction number 0.3 higher than for the prior wild-type. During January, positive samples were more likely to be Alpha in those aged 18 to 54 years old. Although individuals infected with the Alpha variant were no more likely to report one or more classic COVID-19 symptoms compared to those infected with wild-type, they were more likely to be antibody-positive 6 weeks after infection. Further, viral load was higher in those infected with the Alpha variant as measured by cycle threshold (Ct) values. The presence of infections with non-imported Beta variant (first identified in South Africa) during January, but not during February or March, suggests initial establishment in the community followed by fade-out. However, this occurred during a period of stringent social distancing. These results highlight how sequence data from representative community surveys such as REACT-1 can augment routine genomic surveillance during periods of lineage diversity. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T07:55:33Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:202ea829-b6db-4400-abda-acda4b828f43 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T07:55:33Z |
| publishDate | 2023 |
| publisher | Microbiology Society |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:202ea829-b6db-4400-abda-acda4b828f432023-08-21T16:14:17ZThe use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:202ea829-b6db-4400-abda-acda4b828f43EnglishSymplectic ElementsMicrobiology Society2023Eales, OPage, AJTang, SNWalters, CEWang, HHaw, DTrotter, AJLe Viet, TFoster-Nyarko, EProsolek, SAtchison, CAshby, DCooke, GBarclay, WDonnelly, CAO'Grady, JVolz, EDarzi, AWard, HElliott, PRiley, SThe COVID-19 Genomics UK (COGUK) ConsortiumGenomic surveillance for SARS-CoV-2 lineages informs our understanding of possible future changes in transmissibility and vaccine efficacy and will be a high priority for public health for the foreseeable future. However, small changes in the frequency of one lineage over another are often difficult to interpret because surveillance samples are obtained using a variety of methods all of which are known to contain biases. As a case study, using an approach which is largely free of biases, we here describe lineage dynamics and phylogenetic relationships of the Alpha and Beta variant in England during the first 3 months of 2021 using sequences obtained from a random community sample who provided a throat and nose swab for rt-PCR as part of the REal-time Assessment of Community Transmission-1 (REACT-1) study. Overall, diversity decreased during the first quarter of 2021, with the Alpha variant (first identified in Kent) becoming predominant, driven by a reproduction number 0.3 higher than for the prior wild-type. During January, positive samples were more likely to be Alpha in those aged 18 to 54 years old. Although individuals infected with the Alpha variant were no more likely to report one or more classic COVID-19 symptoms compared to those infected with wild-type, they were more likely to be antibody-positive 6 weeks after infection. Further, viral load was higher in those infected with the Alpha variant as measured by cycle threshold (Ct) values. The presence of infections with non-imported Beta variant (first identified in South Africa) during January, but not during February or March, suggests initial establishment in the community followed by fade-out. However, this occurred during a period of stringent social distancing. These results highlight how sequence data from representative community surveys such as REACT-1 can augment routine genomic surveillance during periods of lineage diversity. |
| spellingShingle | Eales, O Page, AJ Tang, SN Walters, CE Wang, H Haw, D Trotter, AJ Le Viet, T Foster-Nyarko, E Prosolek, S Atchison, C Ashby, D Cooke, G Barclay, W Donnelly, CA O'Grady, J Volz, E Darzi, A Ward, H Elliott, P Riley, S The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021 |
| title | The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021 |
| title_full | The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021 |
| title_fullStr | The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021 |
| title_full_unstemmed | The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021 |
| title_short | The use of representative community samples to assess SARS-CoV-2 lineage competition: Alpha outcompetes Beta and wild-type in England from January to March 2021 |
| title_sort | use of representative community samples to assess sars cov 2 lineage competition alpha outcompetes beta and wild type in england from january to march 2021 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT ealeso theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT pageaj theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT tangsn theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT waltersce theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT wangh theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT hawd theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT trotteraj theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT leviett theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT fosternyarkoe theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT prosoleks theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT atchisonc theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT ashbyd theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT cookeg theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT barclayw theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT donnellyca theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT ogradyj theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT volze theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT darzia theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT wardh theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT elliottp theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT rileys theuseofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT ealeso useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT pageaj useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT tangsn useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT waltersce useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT wangh useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT hawd useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT trotteraj useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT leviett useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT fosternyarkoe useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT prosoleks useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT atchisonc useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT ashbyd useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT cookeg useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT barclayw useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT donnellyca useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT ogradyj useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT volze useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT darzia useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT wardh useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT elliottp useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 AT rileys useofrepresentativecommunitysamplestoassesssarscov2lineagecompetitionalphaoutcompetesbetaandwildtypeinenglandfromjanuarytomarch2021 |