A critical analysis of the proportionality test in human rights adjudication

A critical analysis of the proportionality test in human rights adjudication

In this thesis I argue against the proportionality test in human rights adjudication, and provide a framework for understanding the proportionality debate. I identify two accounts of proportionality. One sees proportionality as a doctrinal tool aimed at maximising rights and public interests. The ot...

Fuld beskrivelse

Bibliografiske detaljer
Main Authors:	Urbina, F, Francisco Urbina
Andre forfattere:	Finnis, J
Format:	Thesis
Sprog:	English
Udgivet:	2013
Fag:	Constitutional & administrative law Law Philosophy of law Legal philosophy Human rights

Lignende værker

Law and religious organizations: exceptions, non-interference and justification
af: Norton, JE
Udgivet: (2012)

The effect of the institutional features of the Indian system of personal laws on personal religious autonomy
af: Ahmed, F
Udgivet: (2008)

Kelsen and Raz on the continuity of legal systems: applying the accounts in an Australian context
af: Spagnolo, B
Udgivet: (2013)

An autonomy-based foundation for legal protection against discrimination
af: Khaitan, T
Udgivet: (2010)

The bases for the authority of the Australian Constitution
af: Daley, J
Udgivet: (1999)

Towards a theory of adjudication: some issues of method and principle
af: Brady, P
Udgivet: (2014)

Are cultural rights human rights? A cosmopolitan conception of cultural rights
af: Metcalfe, E, et al.
Udgivet: (2000)

The impact of implied constitutional principles on fundamental rights adjudication in common law jurisdictions
af: Wheatle, S, et al.
Udgivet: (2013)

Methods of deference in human rights adjudication
af: Chan, S
Udgivet: (2022)

Deference in international human rights law
af: Legg, A
Udgivet: (2011)

The architecture of rights
af: Frydrych, D
Udgivet: (2015)

The many faces of the reasonable person
af: Gardner, J
Udgivet: (2015)

Interpretive provisions in human rights legislation: a comparative analysis
af: Coxon, B
Udgivet: (2013)

Religious autonomy and the personal law system
af: Ahmed, F
Udgivet: (2012)

New horizons: incorporating socio-economic rights in a British Bill of Rights
af: Fredman, S
Udgivet: (2010)

Towards a principled doctrine of the margin of appreciation in international human rights law
af: Legg, A
Udgivet: (2007)

Legislative and adjudicative ideals: the role of political morality in statutory interpretation
af: Greene, S
Udgivet: (2022)

Experienced justice: gender, judging and appellate courts
af: Hilly, LE
Udgivet: (2014)

Life before birth: abortion and prenatal personhood in morality and law
af: Greasley, K
Udgivet: (2013)

Constitutional socio-economic rights: lessons from Central Europe
af: Sadurski, W
Udgivet: (2008)

Security and the right to security of person
af: Powell, RL
Udgivet: (2008)

Possibilities of Constitutional Adjudication in Social Rights Matters
af: András Sajó
Udgivet: (2019-09-01)

Dual citizenship and the right to candidacy: an analysis of Jamaica's foreign allegiance parliamentary disqualification
af: Johns, A, et al.
Udgivet: (2013)

Constitutional change and the rule of recognition
af: Barczentewicz, M
Udgivet: (2019)

The protection of fundamental rights in Bulgaria: revisiting the Kelsenian model for constitutional adjudication
af: Gruev, II
Udgivet: (2021)

The Discourse on Human Rights and the International Regime of Human Rights
af: Eyassu Gayim
Udgivet: (2016-11-01)

Authority, philosophical anarchism, and legitimacy
af: Farris, J, et al.
Udgivet: (2009)

Special issue of the Utrecht Law Review<br> Adjudication in a globalizing context
af: Anthony M. Hol, et al.
Udgivet: (2007-06-01)

Philosophy of P.I. Novgorodtsev’s legal theory and crisis of human being
af: Gerashchenko Alena Igorevna, et al.
Udgivet: (2018-04-01)

Pre-charge detention of terrorist suspects and the right to liberty and security
af: Money-Kyrle, R
Udgivet: (2011)

Enforcing respect
af: Shapiro, M
Udgivet: (2012)

Human rights and the law of human rights: a positive legal regulation of an ontic reality
af: Kalikst Nagel
Udgivet: (2014-06-01)

Emotions in court
af: Luth, M, et al.
Udgivet: (2014)

(R)evolution of the Axiology of Human Rights, Political Freedom and Security as a Determinant of UN Pragmatism
af: Jerzy Menkes, et al.
Udgivet: (2021-04-01)

Axiology of human rights on the premises and determinants of contemporary discourse in the philosophy of international law
af: Anna Kociołek-Pęksa, et al.
Udgivet: (2017-12-01)

Interpretation, jurisdiction, and the authority of law
af: Endicott, T
Udgivet: (2007)

Perfect and imperfect rights, duties and obligations: from Hugo Grotius to Immanuel Kant
af: Salam, A
Udgivet: (2014)

The right to litigate in person
af: Assy, R
Udgivet: (2011)

‘Abominable crime': examining the constitutionality of the Jamaican sodomy law through the lens of the general savings law clause
af: Wheatle, S, et al.
Udgivet: (2011)

Subjects of justice: social institutions and the basic structure
af: Turner, J
Udgivet: (2013)