The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives

Successful language comprehension often requires comprehenders to infer contrastive focus alternatives, but the mechanisms used to establish contrastive alternatives are still poorly understood. We propose that comprehenders establish contrastive alternatives by using selection mechanisms that disti...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Husband, M, Ferreira, F
Format: Journal article
Published: Routledge 2015
_version_ 1826263498953326592
author Husband, M
Ferreira, F
author_facet Husband, M
Ferreira, F
author_sort Husband, M
collection OXFORD
description Successful language comprehension often requires comprehenders to infer contrastive focus alternatives, but the mechanisms used to establish contrastive alternatives are still poorly understood. We propose that comprehenders establish contrastive alternatives by using selection mechanisms that distinguish contrastive from non-contrastive candidates. To examine this proposal, we investigated the time course of contrastive alternatives in two cross-modal priming experiments, manipulating contrastive focus on prime words and the contrastiveness of visual targets. Experiment 1 examined early processing where comprehenders are entertaining candidates for contrastive alternatives. Experiment 2 examined later processing where comprehenders have selected contrastive alternatives from the candidate set. Results demonstrated that when primes were contrastively focused, initially both contrastive and non-contrastive associates were facilitated, but, in subsequent processing, non-contrastive associates became deactivated while contrastive associates maintained facilitation. We argue that selection mechanisms distinguish contrastive from non-contrastive candidates by deactivating non-contrastive candidates, enabling comprehenders to draw proper inferences about speakers’ implicit meanings.
first_indexed 2024-03-06T19:52:43Z
format Journal article
id oxford-uuid:247f93ab-255a-4428-92ca-81d83422c55a
institution University of Oxford
last_indexed 2024-03-06T19:52:43Z
publishDate 2015
publisher Routledge
record_format dspace
spelling oxford-uuid:247f93ab-255a-4428-92ca-81d83422c55a2022-03-26T11:50:23ZThe role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternativesJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:247f93ab-255a-4428-92ca-81d83422c55aSymplectic Elements at OxfordRoutledge2015Husband, MFerreira, FSuccessful language comprehension often requires comprehenders to infer contrastive focus alternatives, but the mechanisms used to establish contrastive alternatives are still poorly understood. We propose that comprehenders establish contrastive alternatives by using selection mechanisms that distinguish contrastive from non-contrastive candidates. To examine this proposal, we investigated the time course of contrastive alternatives in two cross-modal priming experiments, manipulating contrastive focus on prime words and the contrastiveness of visual targets. Experiment 1 examined early processing where comprehenders are entertaining candidates for contrastive alternatives. Experiment 2 examined later processing where comprehenders have selected contrastive alternatives from the candidate set. Results demonstrated that when primes were contrastively focused, initially both contrastive and non-contrastive associates were facilitated, but, in subsequent processing, non-contrastive associates became deactivated while contrastive associates maintained facilitation. We argue that selection mechanisms distinguish contrastive from non-contrastive candidates by deactivating non-contrastive candidates, enabling comprehenders to draw proper inferences about speakers’ implicit meanings.
spellingShingle Husband, M
Ferreira, F
The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
title The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
title_full The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
title_fullStr The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
title_full_unstemmed The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
title_short The role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
title_sort role of selection in the comprehension of focus alternatives
work_keys_str_mv AT husbandm theroleofselectioninthecomprehensionoffocusalternatives
AT ferreiraf theroleofselectioninthecomprehensionoffocusalternatives
AT husbandm roleofselectioninthecomprehensionoffocusalternatives
AT ferreiraf roleofselectioninthecomprehensionoffocusalternatives