A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD).
BACKGROUND: Neuropsychiatric symptoms in Alzheimer disease (AD) cause significant distress and present a complex clinical challenge for treatment. Pharmacological treatment options are limited to antipsychotics, which carry extensive safety issues. There is emerging evidence to support the potential...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Elsevier
2015
|
| _version_ | 1797061018778599424 |
|---|---|
| author | Ballard, C Thomas, A Gerry, S Yu, L Aarsland, D Merritt, C Corbett, A Davison, C Sharma, N Khan, Z Creese, B Loughlin, P Bannister, C Burns, A Win, SN Walker, Z |
| author_facet | Ballard, C Thomas, A Gerry, S Yu, L Aarsland, D Merritt, C Corbett, A Davison, C Sharma, N Khan, Z Creese, B Loughlin, P Bannister, C Burns, A Win, SN Walker, Z |
| author_sort | Ballard, C |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | BACKGROUND: Neuropsychiatric symptoms in Alzheimer disease (AD) cause significant distress and present a complex clinical challenge for treatment. Pharmacological treatment options are limited to antipsychotics, which carry extensive safety issues. There is emerging evidence to support the potential benefits of memantine, currently licensed for moderate to severe AD, in the prophylaxis of neuropsychiatric symptoms. METHODS: The MAIN-AD study is a double-blind randomized placebo-controlled withdrawal trial comparing memantine with antipsychotics for the treatment of neuropsychiatric symptoms over 24 weeks. A total of 199 people with probable AD living in care homes already receiving an antipsychotic were randomized to receive either memantine or to continue an antipsychotic. The primary outcomes were function (Bristol Activities of Daily Living Scale [BADLS]) and agitation (Cohen-Mansfield Agitation Inventory [CMAI]). Secondary outcomes were Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI), Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), and mortality. RESULTS: There was no significant difference between groups on the BADLS or CMAI. At 24 weeks, there was a nonsignificant adjusted difference in favor of memantine on the BADLS of 0.23 (95% CI -1.80-2.27; P = .82) and in favor of antipsychotic on the CMAI of 0.09 (95% CI -0.35-8.53; P = .07). Although there were no significant differences in total NPI, there were 5.01 (95% CI -1.68-11.70; P = .05) and 3.63 (95% CI -1.40-8.67; P = .16) point advantages favoring antipsychotics at weeks 12 and 24, respectively. In addition, in an exploratory analysis, individuals allocated to antipsychotics were significantly less likely to experience relapse of neuropsychiatric symptoms at all time points. The group receiving memantine had a nonsignificant 1.3-point advantage on the MMSE at 24 weeks. DISCUSSION: This study indicates no benefits for memantine in the long-term treatment and prophylaxis of clinically significant neuropsychiatric symptoms. The results did indicate some benefits for antipsychotic medications in reducing the relapse of neuropsychiatric symptoms, but this must be balanced against increased mortality risk. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-06T20:25:06Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:2f225bb4-3966-48e1-9040-a7c350a65466 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-06T20:25:06Z |
| publishDate | 2015 |
| publisher | Elsevier |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:2f225bb4-3966-48e1-9040-a7c350a654662022-03-26T12:53:23ZA Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD).Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:2f225bb4-3966-48e1-9040-a7c350a65466EnglishSymplectic Elements at OxfordElsevier2015Ballard, CThomas, AGerry, SYu, LAarsland, DMerritt, CCorbett, ADavison, CSharma, NKhan, ZCreese, BLoughlin, PBannister, CBurns, AWin, SNWalker, ZBACKGROUND: Neuropsychiatric symptoms in Alzheimer disease (AD) cause significant distress and present a complex clinical challenge for treatment. Pharmacological treatment options are limited to antipsychotics, which carry extensive safety issues. There is emerging evidence to support the potential benefits of memantine, currently licensed for moderate to severe AD, in the prophylaxis of neuropsychiatric symptoms. METHODS: The MAIN-AD study is a double-blind randomized placebo-controlled withdrawal trial comparing memantine with antipsychotics for the treatment of neuropsychiatric symptoms over 24 weeks. A total of 199 people with probable AD living in care homes already receiving an antipsychotic were randomized to receive either memantine or to continue an antipsychotic. The primary outcomes were function (Bristol Activities of Daily Living Scale [BADLS]) and agitation (Cohen-Mansfield Agitation Inventory [CMAI]). Secondary outcomes were Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI), Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), and mortality. RESULTS: There was no significant difference between groups on the BADLS or CMAI. At 24 weeks, there was a nonsignificant adjusted difference in favor of memantine on the BADLS of 0.23 (95% CI -1.80-2.27; P = .82) and in favor of antipsychotic on the CMAI of 0.09 (95% CI -0.35-8.53; P = .07). Although there were no significant differences in total NPI, there were 5.01 (95% CI -1.68-11.70; P = .05) and 3.63 (95% CI -1.40-8.67; P = .16) point advantages favoring antipsychotics at weeks 12 and 24, respectively. In addition, in an exploratory analysis, individuals allocated to antipsychotics were significantly less likely to experience relapse of neuropsychiatric symptoms at all time points. The group receiving memantine had a nonsignificant 1.3-point advantage on the MMSE at 24 weeks. DISCUSSION: This study indicates no benefits for memantine in the long-term treatment and prophylaxis of clinically significant neuropsychiatric symptoms. The results did indicate some benefits for antipsychotic medications in reducing the relapse of neuropsychiatric symptoms, but this must be balanced against increased mortality risk. |
| spellingShingle | Ballard, C Thomas, A Gerry, S Yu, L Aarsland, D Merritt, C Corbett, A Davison, C Sharma, N Khan, Z Creese, B Loughlin, P Bannister, C Burns, A Win, SN Walker, Z A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD). |
| title | A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD). |
| title_full | A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD). |
| title_fullStr | A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD). |
| title_full_unstemmed | A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD). |
| title_short | A Double-Blind Randomized Placebo-Controlled Withdrawal Trial Comparing Memantine and Antipsychotics for the Long-Term Treatment of Function and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms in People With Alzheimer's Disease (MAIN-AD). |
| title_sort | double blind randomized placebo controlled withdrawal trial comparing memantine and antipsychotics for the long term treatment of function and neuropsychiatric symptoms in people with alzheimer s disease main ad |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT ballardc adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT thomasa adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT gerrys adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT yul adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT aarslandd adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT merrittc adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT corbetta adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT davisonc adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT sharman adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT khanz adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT creeseb adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT loughlinp adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT bannisterc adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT burnsa adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT winsn adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT walkerz adoubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT ballardc doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT thomasa doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT gerrys doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT yul doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT aarslandd doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT merrittc doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT corbetta doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT davisonc doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT sharman doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT khanz doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT creeseb doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT loughlinp doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT bannisterc doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT burnsa doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT winsn doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad AT walkerz doubleblindrandomizedplacebocontrolledwithdrawaltrialcomparingmemantineandantipsychoticsforthelongtermtreatmentoffunctionandneuropsychiatricsymptomsinpeoplewithalzheimersdiseasemainad |